Phonological history of English consonant clusters
Template:Short description Template:Lead too short Template:English phonology topics Template:IPA notice The phonological history of English includes various changes in the phonology of consonant clusters.
H-cluster reductions
Script error: No such module "Labelled list hatnote". The H-cluster reductions are various consonant reductions that have occurred in the history of English, involving consonant clusters beginning with Script error: No such module "IPA". that have lost the Script error: No such module "IPA". (or become reduced to Script error: No such module "IPA".) in some or all dialects.
Reductions of /hw/
Script error: No such module "Labelled list hatnote". The cluster Script error: No such module "IPA". (spelled ⟨wh⟩ since Middle English) has been subject to two kinds of reduction:
- Reduction to Script error: No such module "IPA". before rounded vowels (due to Script error: No such module "IPA". being perceived as a Script error: No such module "IPA". with the labialization characteristic of that environment). This occurred with the word how in the Old English period, and with who, whom and whose in Middle English (the latter words having had an unrounded vowel in Old English).
- Reduction to Script error: No such module "IPA"., a development that has affected the speech of the great majority of English speakers, causing them to pronounce ⟨wh-⟩ the same as ⟨w-⟩ (sometimes called the wine–whine merger or glide cluster reduction). The distinction is maintained, however, in Scotland, most of Ireland, and some Southern American English.
Reduction of /hl/, /hr/ and /hn/
The Old English consonant clusters Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA". and Script error: No such module "IPA". were reduced to Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA"., and Script error: No such module "IPA". in Middle English. For example, Old English Script error: No such module "Lang"., Script error: No such module "Lang". and Script error: No such module "Lang". become loaf, ring and nut in Modern English.
Reduction of /hj/
In some dialects of English the cluster Script error: No such module "IPA". is reduced to Script error: No such module "IPA".,[1] leading to pronunciations like Script error: No such module "IPA". for huge and Script error: No such module "IPA". for human, and making hew, hue, and Hugh homophones of ewe, yew, and you. This is sometimes considered a type of glide cluster reduction, but it is much less widespread than wh-reduction, and is generally stigmatized where it is found. Aside from accents with general H-dropping, in the United States this reduction is mostly found in accents of Philadelphia and New York City; it also occurs in Cork accents of Irish English. In other dialects of English, hew and yew remain distinct; however, the cluster Script error: No such module "IPA". of hew, human, etc. is often reduced from Script error: No such module "IPA". to just Script error: No such module "IPA". (a voiceless palatal fricative).[2][3]
Y-cluster reductions
Script error: No such module "Labelled list hatnote". Y-cluster reductions are reductions of clusters ending with the palatal approximant Script error: No such module "IPA"., which is the sound of Template:Angbr in yes, and is sometimes referred to as "yod", from the Hebrew letter yod(h), which has the sound Script error: No such module "IPA".. Many such clusters arose in dialects in which the falling diphthong Script error: No such module "IPA". (the product of the merger of several Middle English vowel sequences) became the rising diphthong Script error: No such module "IPA".. (For more information, see Phonological history of English high back vowels.) They were thus often found before the vowel Script error: No such module "IPA"., as in cube Script error: No such module "IPA". – which was in some cases modified to Script error: No such module "IPA". or Script error: No such module "IPA". before (historical) Script error: No such module "IPA"., as in cure, or weakened to Script error: No such module "IPA". or Script error: No such module "IPA". as in argument. They also occurred in words ending in -ion and -ious, such as nation and precious.
This change from Script error: No such module "IPA". to Script error: No such module "IPA"., which had occurred in London by the end of the 17th century, did not take place in all dialects. A few dialects, notably in Wales, as well as in some parts of northern England, New England, and the American South, still retain a (falling) Script error: No such module "IPA". diphthong where standard English has Script error: No such module "IPA". – these dialects therefore lack the clusters with Script error: No such module "IPA". and have not been subject to the reductions described here.[4]
The diphthongs Script error: No such module "IPA". or Script error: No such module "IPA". are most commonly indicated by the spellings Template:Angbr, Template:Angbr, Template:Angbr (where C is any consonant and V is any vowel), Template:Angbr and Template:Angbr, as in feud, few, mute, cue and suit, while the historical monophthong Script error: No such module "IPA". is commonly indicated by the spellings Template:Angbr and Template:Angbr, as in moon and soup.
Yod-dropping
Yod-dropping is the elision of the Script error: No such module "IPA". from certain syllable-initial clusters of the type described above. Particular cases of yod-dropping may affect all or some of the dialects that have the relevant clusters.
The change of Script error: No such module "IPA". to Script error: No such module "IPA". in these positions (as described above) produced some clusters which would have been difficult or impossible to pronounce, which led to what John Wells calls "early yod dropping" in which the Script error: No such module "IPA". was elided in the following environments:[5]
- After Script error: No such module "IPA"., for example chute Script error: No such module "IPA"., chew Script error: No such module "IPA"., juice Script error: No such module "IPA".
- After Script error: No such module "IPA"., for example yew Script error: No such module "IPA". (compare Script error: No such module "IPA". in some conservative dialects)
- After Script error: No such module "IPA"., for example rude Script error: No such module "IPA".
- After stop+Script error: No such module "IPA". clusters, for example blue Script error: No such module "IPA".
Script error: No such module "Listen". The previously mentioned accents that did not have the Script error: No such module "IPA".→Script error: No such module "IPA". change were not subject to this process. Thus, for example, in much Welsh English pairs like chews/choose, yew/you and threw/through remain distinct: the first member of each pair has the diphthong Script error: No such module "IPA"., while the second member has Script error: No such module "IPA".:[6]
- chews Script error: No such module "IPA"., choose Script error: No such module "IPA".
- yew Script error: No such module "IPA"., you Script error: No such module "IPA".
- threw Script error: No such module "IPA"., through Script error: No such module "IPA".
Conversely, an initial Script error: No such module "IPA". does not appear in Welsh English before Script error: No such module "IPA". in words such as yeast and yield.[7]
Many varieties of English have extended yod-dropping to the following environments if the Script error: No such module "IPA". is in the same syllable as the preceding consonant:
- After Script error: No such module "IPA"., for example suit Script error: No such module "IPA".
- After Script error: No such module "IPA"., for example lute Script error: No such module "IPA".
- After Script error: No such module "IPA"., for example Zeus Script error: No such module "IPA".
- After Script error: No such module "IPA"., for example enthuse Script error: No such module "IPA".
Yod-dropping in the above environments used to be considered nonstandard in England but now also occurs by educated RP-speakers.[8] (The Script error: No such module "IPA". after Script error: No such module "IPA". is not normally dropped in RP in medial positions, however: compare pursuit Script error: No such module "IPA"..) In General American, yod-dropping is found not only in the above environments but also after Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA". and Script error: No such module "IPA". (for example, tune Script error: No such module "IPA"., dew Script error: No such module "IPA"., and new Script error: No such module "IPA".).
The lack of yod-dropping in those contexts has occasionally been held to be a shibboleth distinguishing Canadians from Americans. However, in a survey conducted in the Golden Horseshoe area of Southern Ontario in 1994, over 80% of respondents under the age of 40 pronounced student and news without yod.[9]
General American thus undergoes yod-dropping after all alveolar consonants. A few accents of American English, such as working-class Southern American English, however, preserve the distinction in pairs like do/dew because, like in the Welsh English dialects discussed above, they retain a diphthong Script error: No such module "IPA". in words in which RP has Script error: No such module "IPA".: Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA"., etc.[10]
However, in words like annual, menu, volume, Matthew, continue, etc., with a syllable break before the Script error: No such module "IPA"., there is no yod-dropping. The same applies accordingly to British and other accents; the yod is often dropped after initial Script error: No such module "IPA"., for example, but it is not dropped in words like volume or value. (British speakers omit the Script error: No such module "IPA". in figure, but most Americans retain it.)
Additionally, there is no Script error: No such module "IPA". in British pronunciations of coupon and Pulitzer, Script error: No such module "IPA". and Script error: No such module "IPA". respectively, but many American speakers keep the yod, realizing them as Script error: No such module "IPA". and Script error: No such module "IPA"., although Pulitzer with the pew sound is widely incorrect.[11][12]
In New Zealand and to some extent Australian English, debut is mainly pronounced without the yod as Script error: No such module "IPA"..[13]
Yod-dropping after Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA"., and Script error: No such module "IPA". was also a traditional feature of Cockney speech, which continues to be the case after Script error: No such module "IPA"., but now, after Script error: No such module "IPA". and Script error: No such module "IPA"., yod-coalescence is now more common.[14]
Some East Anglian accents such as Norfolk dialect extend yod-dropping not only to the position after Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA". or Script error: No such module "IPA". but also to the position after nonalveolar consonants as well: pairs like beauty/booty, mute/moot, cute/coot can then be homophonous.[15] A well-known series of British television advertisements beginning in the 1980s featured Bernard Matthews, who was from Norfolk and described his turkeys as "bootiful" (for beautiful). Such accents pronounce a Script error: No such module "IPA". in words like "use", "unit", etc. only if there is no consonant before the Script error: No such module "IPA".. Script error: No such module "anchor".
| Script error: No such module "IPA". | Script error: No such module "IPA". | IPA | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| brewed | brood | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| brume | broom | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| chews | choose | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| chute | shoot | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| drupe | droop | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| rheum | room | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| rude | rood | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| rue | roo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| ruse | roos | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| threw | through | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| yew | you | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| yule | you'll | Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| Script error: No such module "IPA". | Script error: No such module "IPA". | IPA | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blume | bloom | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| glume | gloom | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Lewis | Louis | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| lieu | loo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| lieu | Lou | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Luke | look | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With foot–goose merger. |
| lune | loon | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| lute | loot | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| slew | slough | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| slue | slough | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| sue | Sioux | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| suit | soot | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With foot–goose merger. |
| Script error: No such module "IPA". | Script error: No such module "IPA". | IPA | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| adieu | ado | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| dew | do | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Dewar | doer | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| due | do | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| dune | Doon | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| knew | nu | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| new | nu | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| tune | toon | Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| Script error: No such module "IPA". | Script error: No such module "IPA". | IPA | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| beaut | boot | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| beauty | booty | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| butte | boot | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| cue | coo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| cute | coot | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| feud | food | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| few | foo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| fuel | fool | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With vile–vial merger. |
| hew | who | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| hews | who's | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| hews | whose | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| hue | who | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| hues | who's | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| hues | whose | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Hugh | who | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Hughes | who's | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Hughes | whose | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Kew | coo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| kyu | coo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| mew | moo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| mew | moue | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| mewed | mood | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| muse | moos | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| muse | moues | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| mute | moot | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| pew | poo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| pule | pool | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| pure | poor | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Q; cue | coo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| que | coo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| queue | coo | Script error: No such module "IPA". |
Yod-coalescence
Yod-coalescence is a process that fuses the clusters Script error: No such module "IPA". into the sibilants Script error: No such module "IPA". respectively (for the meanings of those symbols, see English phonology). The first two are examples of affrication.
Unlike yod-dropping, yod-coalescence frequently occurs with clusters that would be considered to span a syllable boundary and so commonly occurs before unstressed syllables. For example, in educate, the Script error: No such module "IPA". cluster would not usually be subject to yod-dropping in General American, as the Script error: No such module "IPA". is assigned to the previous syllable, but it commonly coalesces to Script error: No such module "IPA".. Here are a few examples of yod-coalescence universal in all English dialects:
- Script error: No such module "IPA". in most words ending -ture, such as nature Script error: No such module "IPA".
- Script error: No such module "IPA". in soldier Script error: No such module "IPA".
- Script error: No such module "IPA". in words ending with -ssure such as pressure Script error: No such module "IPA". (also in words ending with consonant+sure, consonant+sion, -tion)
- Script error: No such module "IPA". in words ending vowel+sure such as measure Script error: No such module "IPA". (also vowel+sion, r+sion)
In some other words, the coalesced pronunciation is common in English dialects around the world, but an older non-coalesced form still exists among some speakers of standard British English:
- educate Script error: No such module "IPA". (also in standard RP: Script error: No such module "IPA".)
- azure Script error: No such module "IPA". (also in RP Script error: No such module "IPA".)
- issue Script error: No such module "IPA". (also in RP Script error: No such module "IPA".), the intermediate form Script error: No such module "IPA". being also common
Coalescence can even occur across word boundaries, as in the colloquial "gotcha" Template:IPAc-en (for got you Template:IPAc-en) and "whatcha" Template:IPAc-en (for what're you Template:IPAc-en).
In certain English accents, yod-coalescence also occurs in stressed syllables, as in tune and dune. That occurs in Australian, Cockney, Estuary English, Zimbabwean English, some speakers of Hiberno-English, Newfoundland English, South African English, and to a certain extent[16] in New Zealand English, RP,[17] many speakers in Scottish English, and even some varieties of English in Asia, like Philippine English (many speakers because of the influence by the phonology of their mother languages). That results in pronunciations such as the following:
- dew/due Script error: No such module "IPA". (RP: Script error: No such module "IPA".)
- tune Script error: No such module "IPA". (RP: Script error: No such module "IPA".)
In certain varieties such as Australian, Ugandan, and some RP,[17] stressed Script error: No such module "IPA". can also coalesce:
- resume Script error: No such module "IPA". (RP: Script error: No such module "IPA".)
- assume Script error: No such module "IPA". (RP: Script error: No such module "IPA".)
That can lead to additional homophony; for instance, dew and due come to be pronounced the same as Jew.
Yod-coalescence has traditionally been resisted in Received Pronunciation. It has certainly become established in words of the first group listed above (nature, soldier, pressure etc.), but it is not yet universal in those of the second group (educate etc.), and it does not generally occur in those of the third group (dew, tune etc.).[18]
| Script error: No such module "IPA". | Script error: No such module "IPA". | IPA | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| deuce | juice | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| dew | Jew | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| dewed | Jude | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| dual | jewel | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| due | Jew | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| duel | jewel | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| duke | juke | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| duly | Julie | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| dune | June | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| duty | Judy | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With intervocalic alveolar flapping. |
| sue | shoe | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| sue | shoo | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| suit | chute | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| suit | shoot | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| 'tude | chewed | Script error: No such module "IPA". |
See also
Other initial cluster reductions
Reduction of /wr/ and /wl/
Old and Middle English had an initial Script error: No such module "IPA". cluster (note that /r/ does not denote Template:IPAblink here), hence the spelling of words like write and wrong. This was reduced to just Script error: No such module "IPA"., apparently during the 17th century. An intermediate stage may have been an Script error: No such module "IPA". with lip rounding.[19]
As a result of this reduction, pairs of words like rap and wrap, rite and write, etc. are homophones in practically all varieties of Modern English. They remain distinct in the Doric dialect of Scots, where the wr- cluster is pronounced Script error: No such module "IPA".. Alexander John Ellis reported distinctions between wr and r in Cumbria and in several varieties of Scots in the nineteenth century.[20]
Old English also had a cluster Script error: No such module "IPA"., which reduced to Script error: No such module "IPA". during Middle English. For example, the word lisp derives from Old English wlisp(ian).
Reduction of Script error: No such module "IPA".
Middle English initial Script error: No such module "IPA". is reduced in modern English to Script error: No such module "IPA"., making pairs like knot/not and knight/night homophones.
The Script error: No such module "IPA". cluster was spelled cn- in Old English; this changed to kn- in Middle English, and this spelling survives in Modern English, despite the loss of the Script error: No such module "IPA". sound. Cognates in other Germanic languages usually still sound the initial Script error: No such module "IPA".. For example, the Old English ancestor of knee was Script error: No such module "Lang"., pronounced Script error: No such module "IPA"., and the cognate word in Modern German is Script error: No such module "Lang"., pronounced Script error: No such module "IPA"..
Most dialects of English reduced the initial cluster Script error: No such module "IPA". to Script error: No such module "IPA". relatively recently; the change seems to have taken place in educated English during the 17th century.[21] Several German-language grammars of English from the late 17th and early 18th centuries transcribed English kn- as tn-, dn-, implying that a stage of assimilation (or perhaps debuccalization to Script error: No such module "IPA".) preceded that of complete reduction.[22]
The cluster is preserved in some Scots dialects,[23] and Alexander John Ellis recorded it in parts of the Northern English counties of Cumbria and Northumberland in the late nineteenth century.[24]
Reduction of /ɡn/
The Middle English initial cluster Script error: No such module "IPA". is reduced to Script error: No such module "IPA". in Modern English. Like the reduction of Script error: No such module "IPA"., this seems to have taken place during the seventeenth century.[25] The change affected words like gnat, gnostic, gnome, etc., the spelling with gn- being retained despite the loss of the Script error: No such module "IPA". sound. The cluster is preserved in some Scots dialects.[23]
The song The Gnu jokes about this silent g and other silent letters in English. In fact the g in gnu may always have been silent in English, since this loanword did not enter the language until the late 18th century.[26] The trumpeter Kenny Wheeler wrote a composition titled Gnu High, a pun on "new high".
S-cluster reductions
In some types of Caribbean English, the initial clusters Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA"., and Script error: No such module "IPA". are reduced by the loss of Script error: No such module "IPA".. The following stop is then subject to regular aspiration (or devoicing of the following approximant) in its new word-initial environment. Some examples of such pronunciations are:
| spit | → 'pit | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| stomach | → 'tomach | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| spend | → 'pen | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". (also affected by final cluster reduction) |
| squeeze | → 'queeze | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
According to Wells, these reductions occur only in the broadest creole.[27]
Final cluster reductions
NG-coalescence
NG-coalescence is a historical sound change by which the final cluster Script error: No such module "IPA"., pronounced Script error: No such module "IPA". (the Script error: No such module "IPA". being realized as a velar nasal by assimilation with the velar Script error: No such module "IPA".), came to be pronounced as just Script error: No such module "IPA". – that is, the final Script error: No such module "IPA". was dropped, but the velar quality of the nasal remained. The change took place in educated London speech around the end of the 16th century, and explains why there is no Script error: No such module "IPA". sound at the end of words like fang, sing, wrong and tongue in the standard varieties of Modern English.[28]
The change in fact applies not only at the end of a word, but generally at the end of a morpheme. If a word ending in -ng is followed by a suffix or is compounded with another word, the Script error: No such module "IPA". pronunciation normally remains. For example, in the words fangs, sings, singing, singer, wronged, wrongly, hangman, there is no Script error: No such module "IPA". sound. An exception is the comparative and superlative forms of adjectives: in the words longer/longest, stronger/strongest, younger/youngest, the Script error: No such module "IPA". is pronounced in most accents. The pronunciation with Script error: No such module "IPA". is thus possible only before a vowel; before a consonant, the only possibility is a bare Script error: No such module "IPA"..
In other cases (when it is not morpheme-final), word-internal -ng- does not show the effects of coalescence, and the pronunciation Script error: No such module "IPA". is retained, as in finger and angle. This means that the words finger and singer do not rhyme in most modern varieties of English, although they did in Middle English. The process of NG-coalescence might therefore be referred to as the singer–finger split.
Some accents, however, do not show the full effects of NG-coalescence as described above. In these accents, sing may be found with Script error: No such module "IPA"., and singer may rhyme with finger.[29] This is particularly associated with English English accents in areas such as Lancashire, the West Midlands and Derbyshire, and is also present in north-east varieties of Welsh English. This includes the cities of Birmingham (see Brummie), Manchester (see Manchester dialect), Liverpool (see Scouse), Sheffield and Stoke-on-Trent (see Potteries dialect). This also occurs in a small area of Kent. As this occurs around the mining area of Kent, it might be a result of large-scale migration by miners from other more northerly coalfields to Kent in the 1920s.
It is also associated with some American English accents in the New York City area.[30]
On the other hand, in some accents of the west of Scotland and Ulster, NG-coalescence is extended to morpheme-internal position, so that finger is pronounced Script error: No such module "IPA". (cf. Dutch vinger Script error: No such module "IPA".), thus rhyming with singer (although the Script error: No such module "IPA". is not dropped before a stressed syllable, as in engage).
It is because of NG-coalescence that Script error: No such module "IPA". is now normally regarded one of the phonemes of standard English. In Middle English, the Script error: No such module "IPA". can be regarded as an allophone of Script error: No such module "IPA"., occurring before velar consonants, but in Modern English, in view of minimal pairs such as pan–pang and sin–sing, that analysis no longer appears to hold. Nevertheless, some linguistsScript error: No such module "Unsubst". (particularly generativists) do regard a word like sing as being underlyingly Script error: No such module "IPA"., positing a rule that deletes Script error: No such module "IPA". after a nasal before a morpheme boundary, after the nasal has undergone assimilation. A problem with this view is that there are a few words in which Script error: No such module "IPA". is followed neither by a velar nor a morpheme boundary (such as gingham, dinghy, orangutan and Singapore, for those speakers who pronounce them without Script error: No such module "IPA".), and some in which the Script error: No such module "IPA". is not deleted before a morpheme boundary (such as longer, stronger, younger noted above). In the case of longer, a minimal pair occurs for some speakers between Script error: No such module "IPA". (comparative form of the adjective long) and Script error: No such module "IPA". ("someone who longs"; agent noun of the verb long).
The above-mentioned accents which lack NG-coalescence may more easily be analyzed as lacking a phoneme Script error: No such module "IPA".. The same may apply to those where NG-coalescence is extended to morpheme-internal position, since here a more consistent Script error: No such module "IPA".-deletion rule can be formulated.[31]
G-dropping
Script error: No such module "Labelled list hatnote". G-dropping is a popular name for the feature of speech whereby Script error: No such module "IPA". is used in place of the standard Script error: No such module "IPA". in weak syllables. This applies especially to the -ing ending of verbs, but also in other words such as morning, nothing, ceiling, Buckingham, etc. G-dropping speakers may pronounce this syllable as Script error: No such module "IPA". or Script error: No such module "IPA". (reducing to a syllabic [n] in some cases), while non-G-dropping speakers have Script error: No such module "IPA". (Script error: No such module "IPA". with the weak vowel merger) or Script error: No such module "IPA"..[32]
Relative to the great majority of modern dialects, which have NG-coalescence, G-dropping does not involve the dropping of any sound, simply the replacement of the velar nasal with the alveolar nasal. The name derives from the apparent orthographic consequence of replacing the sound written Template:Angbr with that normally written Template:Angbr. The spelling -in' is sometimes used to indicate that a speaker uses the G-dropping pronunciation, as in makin' for making.
The pronunciation with Script error: No such module "IPA". rather than Script error: No such module "IPA". is a long-established one. Old English verbs had a present participle in -ende and a verbal noun (gerund) form in -ing(e). These merged into a single form, written -ing, but not necessarily spoken as such – the Script error: No such module "IPA". pronunciation may be inherited from the former distinct present participle form. The Script error: No such module "IPA". variant appears to have been fashionable generally during the 18th century, with the alternative Script error: No such module "IPA". being adopted in educated speech around the 1820s, possibly as a spelling pronunciation.[33]
Today, G-dropping is a feature of colloquial and non-standard speech of all regions, including stereotypically of Cockney, Southern American English and African American Vernacular English. Its use is highly correlated with the socioeconomic class of the speaker, with speakers of lower classes using Script error: No such module "IPA". with greater frequency. It has also been found to be more common among men than women, and less common in more formal styles of speech.[34]
The fact that the Script error: No such module "IPA". pronunciation was formerly associated with certain upper-class speech is reflected in the phrase huntin’, shootin’ and fishin’ (used in referring to country gentry who frequently engaged in such field sports). Further evidence that this pronunciation was once standard comes from old rhymes, as in this couplet from John Gay's 1732 pastoral Acis and Galatea, set to music by Handel:
- Shepherd, what art thou pursuing,
- Heedless running to thy ruin?
Template:Notatypo was presumably pronounced "shepherd, what art thou pursuin', heedless runnin' to thy ruin", although this would sound very odd in an opera today. Similarly, in the poetry of Jonathan Swift (1667–1745), -ing forms consistently rhyme with words ending in Script error: No such module "IPA"., as in this verse of A Ballad on the Game of Traffic, where "lining" rhymes with "fine in":
- But Weston has a new-cast gown
- On Sundays to be fine in,
- And, if she can but win a crown,
- 'Twill just new dye the lining.
Reduction of /mb/ and /mn/
In later Middle English, the final cluster Script error: No such module "IPA". was reduced to just Script error: No such module "IPA". (the plum-plumb merger). This affects words such as lamb and plumb, as well as derived forms with suffixes, such as lambs, lambing, plumbed, plumber.
By analogy with words like these, certain other words ending in Script error: No such module "IPA"., which had no historical Script error: No such module "IPA". sound, had a silent letter Template:Angbr added to their spelling by way of hypercorrection. Such words include limb and crumb.[35]
Where the final cluster Script error: No such module "IPA". occurred, this was reduced to Script error: No such module "IPA". (the him-hymn merger), as in column, autumn, damn, solemn. (Compare French Script error: No such module "Lang"., where the cluster has been reduced to Script error: No such module "IPA"..) Both sounds are nonetheless still pronounced before vowels in certain derivatives, such as columnar, autumnal, damnation, solemnity.
Generalized final cluster reduction
General reduction of final consonant clusters occurs in African American Vernacular English and Caribbean English. It also appears in the Local Dublin English.[36] The new final consonant may be slightly lengthened as an effect.
Examples are:
| test | → tes' | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| desk | → des' | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| hand | → han' | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| send | → sen' | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| left | → lef' | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| wasp | → was' | Script error: No such module "IPA". | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
The plurals of test and desk may become tesses and desses by the same rule that gives plural messes from singular mess.[37][38][39][40]
Medial cluster reductions
When a consonant cluster ending in a stop is followed by another consonant or cluster in the next syllable, the final stop in the first syllable is often elided. This may happen within words or across word boundaries. Examples of stops that will often be elided in this way include the Script error: No such module "IPA". in postman and the Script error: No such module "IPA". in cold cuts or band saw.[41]
Historically, similar reductions have taken place before syllabic consonants in certain words, leading to the silent Template:Angbr in words like castle and listen. This change took place around the 17th century. In the word often, the Script error: No such module "IPA". sound later came to be re-inserted by some speakers as a spelling pronunciation.[42]
An earlier reduction that took place in early Middle English was the change of Script error: No such module "IPA". to Script error: No such module "IPA". (the sent-cent merger). This led to the modern sound of [[soft C|soft Template:Vr]].
Consonant insertions
Prince–prints merger
For many speakers, an epenthetic Script error: No such module "IPA". is inserted in the final cluster Script error: No such module "IPA"., making it identical or very similar to the cluster Script error: No such module "IPA".. For example, the words prince and prints have come to be homophones or nearly so.
The epenthesis is a natural consequence of the transition from the nasal Script error: No such module "IPA". to the fricative Script error: No such module "IPA".; if the raising of the soft palate (which converts a nasal to an oral sound) is completed before the release of the tongue tip (which enables a fricative sound), an intervening stop Script error: No such module "IPA". naturally results.[43] The merger of Script error: No such module "IPA". and Script error: No such module "IPA". is not necessarily complete, however; the duration of the epenthetic Script error: No such module "IPA". in Script error: No such module "IPA". has been found to be often shorter (and the Script error: No such module "IPA". longer) than in the underlying cluster Script error: No such module "IPA"..[44] Some speakers preserve a clearer distinction, with prince having Script error: No such module "IPA"., and prints having Script error: No such module "IPA". or Script error: No such module "IPA".. The epenthesis does not occur between syllables, in words like consider.[45]
Other insertions
The merger of Script error: No such module "IPA". and Script error: No such module "IPA". is also possible, making bans and pens sound like bands and pends. However, this is less common than the merger of Script error: No such module "IPA". and Script error: No such module "IPA". described above, and in rapid speech may involve the elision of the Script error: No such module "IPA". from Script error: No such module "IPA". rather than epenthesis in Script error: No such module "IPA"..[46]
Epenthesis of a stop between a nasal and a fricative can also occur in other environments, for example:
- Script error: No such module "IPA". may become Script error: No such module "IPA". (so pinscher is often pronounced like pincher)
- Script error: No such module "IPA". may become Script error: No such module "IPA". (so Samson becomes "Sampson", hamster becomes "hampster")
- Script error: No such module "IPA". may become Script error: No such module "IPA". (so Kingston becomes "kinkston")[46]
Epenthesis may also happen in the cluster Script error: No such module "IPA"., which then becomes Script error: No such module "IPA"., so else rhymes with belts.
An epenthetic Script error: No such module "IPA". often intervenes in the cluster Script error: No such module "IPA". in the word dreamt, making it rhyme with attempt.
Some originally epenthetic consonants have become part of the established pronunciation of words. This applies, for instance, to the Script error: No such module "IPA". in words like thimble, grumble and scramble.[35]
For the insertion of glottal stops before certain consonants, see Glottalization below.
| fricative | affricate | IPA | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aaron's | errands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With Mary-marry-merry merger. |
| -ance | -ants | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| ANSI | antsy | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| bans | bands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Ben's | bends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| bines | binds | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| brans | brands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| bunce | bunts | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Bynes | binds | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| chance | chants | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| dense | dents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| dense | dints | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| -ence | -ents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Erin's | errands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With weak vowel merger. |
| fines | finds | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| fens | fends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Finns | fends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| fins | fends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| glans | glands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Hans | hands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | Hans may also be pronounced Script error: No such module "IPA". or Script error: No such module "IPA".. |
| Heinz | hinds | Script error: No such module "IPA". | Heinz may also be pronounced Script error: No such module "IPA".. |
| hence | hints | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| Hines | hinds | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| inns | ends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| ins | ends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| intense | intents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| Kines | kinds | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| LANs | lands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| lens | lends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| men's | mends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| mince | mints | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| mines | minds | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| N's; ens | ends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| patience | patients | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| pawns | ponds | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With cot-caught merger. |
| pens | pends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| pins | pends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| ponce | ponts | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| pons | ponds | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| presence | presents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| prince | prints | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| rinse | rents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| sans | sands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| sense | cents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| sense | scents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| since | cents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| since | scents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| spins | spends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| Stan's | stands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| tens | tends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| tense | tents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| tense | tints | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| tins | tends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| Vince | vents | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| wans | wands | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| wens | wends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| wens | winds (n.) | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| wince | Wentz | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| whence | Wentz | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With wine-whine merger. |
| whines | winds (v.) | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With wine-whine merger. |
| wines | winds (v.) | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| wins | wends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| wins | winds (n.) | Script error: No such module "IPA". | |
| wyns, wynns | wends | Script error: No such module "IPA". | With pen-pin merger. |
| wyns, wynns | winds (n.) | Script error: No such module "IPA". |
Alterations of clusters
Assimilation
In English as in other languages, assimilation of adjacent consonants is common, particularly of a nasal with a following consonant. This can occur within or between words. For example, the Script error: No such module "IPA". in encase is often pronounced Script error: No such module "IPA". (becoming a velar nasal by way of assimilation with the following velar stop Script error: No such module "IPA".), and the Script error: No such module "IPA". in ten men likely becomes Script error: No such module "IPA"., assimilating with the following bilabial nasal Script error: No such module "IPA".. Other cases of assimilation also occur, such as pronunciation of the Script error: No such module "IPA". in bad boy as Script error: No such module "IPA".. Voicing assimilation determines the sound of the endings -s (as in plurals, possessives and verb forms) and -ed (in verb forms): these are voiced (Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA".) following a voiced consonant (or vowel), but voiceless (Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA".) after a voiceless consonant, as in gets, knocked.[47]
Glottalization
While there are many accents (such as Cockney) in which syllable-final Script error: No such module "IPA". is frequently glottalized (realized as a glottal stop, Script error: No such module "IPA".) regardless of what follows it, the glottaling of Script error: No such module "IPA". in clusters is a feature even of standard accents, such as RP. There, Script error: No such module "IPA". may be heard for Script error: No such module "IPA". in such words and phrases as quite good, quite nice, nights. More precisely, it occurs in RP when Script error: No such module "IPA". appears in the syllable coda, is preceded by a vowel, liquid or nasal, and it is followed by another consonant except (normally) a liquid or semivowel in the same word, as in mattress.[48]
Another possibility is pre-glottalization (or glottal reinforcement), where a glottal stop is inserted before a syllable-final stop, rather than replacing it. That can happen before Script error: No such module "IPA"., Script error: No such module "IPA". and Script error: No such module "IPA". or also before the affricate Script error: No such module "IPA".. It can occur in RP in the same environments as those mentioned above, without the final restriction so a glottal stop may appear before the Script error: No such module "IPA"., as in mattress. It can also occur before a pause as in quite! spoken alone but not in quite easy. In the case of Script error: No such module "IPA"., pre-glottalization is common even before a vowel, as in teacher.[49]
According to Wells, this pre-glottalization originated in the 20th century (at least, it was not recorded until then). Glottalization of Script error: No such module "IPA". spread rapidly during the 20th century.[48]
S-cluster metathesis
Final consonant clusters starting with Script error: No such module "IPA". sometimes undergo metathesis, meaning that the order of the consonants is switched. For example, the word ask may be pronounced like "ax", with the Script error: No such module "IPA". and the Script error: No such module "IPA". switched.
This example has a long history: the Old English verb áscian also appeared as acsian, and both forms continued into Middle English, the latter, metathesizing to "ask". The form axe appears in Chaucer: "I axe, why the fyfte man Was nought housband to the Samaritan?" (Wife of Bath's Prologue, 1386), and was considered acceptable in literary English until about 1600.[50]Script error: No such module "Unsubst". It persists in some dialects of rural England as well as in Ulster Scots[51] as Script error: No such module "IPA"., and in Jamaican English as Script error: No such module "IPA"., from where it has entered London English as Script error: No such module "IPA"..
S-cluster metathesis has been observed in some forms of African American Vernacular English, although it is not universal, one of the most stigmatized features of AAVE and often commented on by teachers.[37]Script error: No such module "Unsubst". Examples of possible AAVE pronunciations include:
| ask | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| grasp | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| wasp | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| gasp | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
Merger of /str/ and /skr/
For some speakers of African American Vernacular English, the consonant cluster Script error: No such module "IPA". is pronounced as Script error: No such module "IPA".. For example, the word street may be pronounced as Script error: No such module "IPA"..[52]
The form has been found to occur in Gullah and in the speech of some young African Americans born in the Southern United States. It is reported to be a highly stigmatized feature, with children who use it often being referred to speech pathologists.[53]
Yod-rhotacization
Template:Misleading Yod-rhotacization is a process that occurs for some Memphis AAVETemplate:R speakers, where Script error: No such module "IPA". is rhotacized to Script error: No such module "IPA". in consonant clusters, causing pronunciations like:
| beautiful | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| cute | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
| music | → Script error: No such module "IPA". |
Compare yod-dropping and yod-coalescence, described above (and also the coil–curl merger, which features the reverse process, Script error: No such module "IPA". → Script error: No such module "IPA".).
See also
- Phonological history of English
- Phonological history of English consonants
- Phonological history of English fricatives and affricates
- H-dropping
References
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1". Excerpts from: Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Jespersen, O., A Modern English Grammar on Historical Principles, vol. 1, 12.81-82.
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Jespersen, O., A Modern English Grammar on Historical Principles, vol. 1, 12.71.
- ↑ Vietor, Wilhelm: Elemente der Phonetik und Orthoepie des Deutschen, Englischen und Französischen, 2nd ed., Heilbronn, 1887, p. 171
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Jespersen, O., A Modern English Grammar on Historical Principles, vol. 1, 12.72.
- ↑ The first recorded use of the word gnu in English dates back to 1777, according to Merriam-Webster's dictionary.
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Wells (1982), pp. 189, 366.
- ↑ Wells (1982), pp. 60–64.
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Wyld, H.C., A History of Modern Colloquial English, Blackwell 1936, cited in Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Wells (1982), pp. 17, 19, 26.
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ * Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ HLW: Word Forms: Processes: English Accents
- ↑ List of AAVE features contrasting with MUSE Template:Webarchive
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Denham, K., Lobeck, A., Linguistics for Everyone: An Introduction, Cengage Learning 2012, p. 162.
- ↑ Algeo, J., Butcher, C. The Origins and Development of the English Language, Cengage Learning 2013, p. 49.
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Yu, A.C.L., in The Blackwell Companion to Phonology, Wiley 2011, p. 1906.
- ↑ Wells, J.C., "Some day my prints will come", John Wells's Phonetic Blog, 25 August 2010.
- ↑ a b Alan Cruttenden, Gimson's Pronunciation of English, Routledge 2013, p. 99.
- ↑ Nathan, G.S., Phonology: A Cognitive Grammar Introduction, John Benjamins Publishing 2008, pp. 77–78.
- ↑ a b Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Template:Harvp.
- ↑ Online Etymology Dictionary - Ask
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Dandy, E.B., Black Communications: Breaking Down the Barriers, African American Images, 1991, p. 44.