Survivor: Samoa

Survivor: Samoa is the nineteenth season of the American CBS competitive reality television series Survivor. The season premiered on Thursday, September 17, 2009. Participant applications were due by January 14, 2009. Approximately 800 were invited to be interviewed in several states. Following this, approximately 48 semi-finalists were invited to Los Angeles in April 2009 for final interviews with the producers. From there, 20 finalists were selected to be contestants in the show, which was scheduled to occur between mid June and mid-July 2009 in Samoa. Similar to Survivor: Tocantins, the minimum age requirement for this season was 18 for most states.

In the end, Natalie White defeated Russell Hantz and Mick Trimming in a 7–2–0 jury vote. Hantz won the "Sprint Player of the Season" Award, earning the fans' vote over the next highest vote getters, Shannon "Shambo" Waters and Brett Clouser. This was the first season when the tribes merged at 12 players with nine people on the jury.

Contestants

File:Russell Swan.png

Russell Swan

The 20 contestants were initially split into two teams of ten: Foa Foa and Galu, meaning "trumpet shell" and "wave" in Samoan respectively. The merged tribe, formed on day 19, was named Aiga, which means "family" in Samoan and was first suggested by contestant Erik Cardona. Mike Borassi was originally cast for the previous season Survivor: Tocantins, but had to pull out due to high blood pressure.

List of Survivor: Samoa contestants

Contestant	Age	From	Tribe		Finish
			Original	Merged	Placement	Day
	26	Cincinnati, Ohio	rowspan="4" Template:Stribe		1st voted out	Day 3
	62	Marina del Rey, California	Medically evacuated		Day 5
	48	Campton, New Hampshire	2nd voted out		Day 6
	28	Los Angeles, California	3rd voted out		Day 8
	33	Los Angeles, California	Template:Stribe		4th voted out	Day 11
	22	Maple Grove, Minnesota	Template:Stribe		5th voted out	Day 14
	42	Glenside, Pennsylvania	Template:Stribe		Medically evacuated	Day 15
	33	New York City, New York	Template:Stribe		6th voted out	Day 18
	28	Los Angeles, California	rowspan="7" Template:Stribe	rowspan="12" Template:Stribe	7th voted out 1st jury member	Day 21
	25	San Diego, California	8th voted out 2nd jury member	Day 24
	39	Salem, Oregon	9th voted out 3rd jury member	Day 27
	25	Santa Monica, California	10th voted out 4th jury member	Day 30
	38	Los Angeles, California	11th voted out 5th jury member	Day 31
	25	San Diego, California	12th voted out 6th jury member	Day 33
	45	Renton, Washington	13th voted out 7th jury member	Day 36
	28	Chicago, Illinois	Template:Stribe	14th voted out 8th jury member	Day 37
	23	Los Angeles, California	Template:Stribe	15th voted out 9th jury member	Day 38
	33	Los Angeles, California	rowspan="3" Template:Stribe	2nd runner-up	Day 39
	36	Dayton, Texas	Runner-up
	26	Van Buren, Arkansas	Sole Survivor

Future appearances

Russell Hantz later competed on Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains, Survivor: Redemption Island, and Australian Survivor: Champions vs. Contenders. Russell Swan competed on Survivor: Philippines. Laura Morett competed on Survivor: Blood vs. Water alongside her daughter Ciera Eastin. Monica Padilla returned for Survivor: Cambodia. John Fincher later married Survivor: Micronesia winner Parvati Shallow and appeared on Survivor: Winners at War as part of the loved ones visit.

Season summary

File:Lefaga, Return to Paradise beach, south coast Upolu Island, Samoa, 2009.jpg

The season filmed in Upolu in Samoa.

The 20 contestants were assigned tribes at the start of the game and, based only on appearances, were instructed to elect a leader who would make critical decisions at challenges for the first half of the game. The leader of the tribe that won the reward challenge would also choose a member of their tribe to observe the other tribe for a day, receiving a clue to the hidden immunity idol at the other tribe's camp. Mick was chosen as Foa Foa's leader, and Russell S. as Galu's.

At Foa Foa, Russell H. attempted to make living conditions harsher for his tribe by dumping water out of canteens and burning socks, leading to Foa Foa losing nearly every challenge. Russell H. managed to find his tribe's hidden immunity idol at his own camp and, after making alliances with virtually all of his tribe mates, amassed a huge amount of influence among the members of his tribe. Galu's winning streak led to a relaxed state at the camp, a condition that Shambo resented, putting her at odds with the tribe. After Galu won a reward challenge, Russell S. opted to send Shambo over to Foa Foa for one night, where she found the tribe had a strong work ethic and welcomed her. Russell S. was removed from the game due to fatigue, and Galu elected Shambo as their new leader in order to gain her loyalty.

The two tribes merged with twelve players left: four from Foa Foa and eight from Galu. Natalie from Foa Foa was able to convince the Galu women to vote off one of their own, Erik. At this vote, Russell H. had played his hidden immunity idol, but it was all for naught as Erik was eliminated. Russell H. managed to find the idol in its new location before the next tribal council. He played his new idol there, saving himself from being voted off as he was targeted by every Galu member. With ten players remaining, Shambo decided to align with the Foa Foa alliance, which led to a 5-5 tie. John from the Galu alliance, paranoid that he would get eliminated from the game by a random rock draw, switched his vote on the tiebreaker to send off a Galu. This put the Foa Foa alliance in the majority. Foa Foa systematically eliminated the former Galu members. However, their plans were halted when Brett (the final member of the Galu alliance) won three immunity challenges in a row. Perceived as physically drained, and unlikely to beat Brett in the coming immunity challenges, Shambo and Jaison were voted out. With four players remaining, Russell H. ended Brett's immunity streak in the final four immunity contest. Brett was the final player voted out.

Russell H., Mick, and Natalie were the final three. At the Final Tribal Council, Mick was ignored by the jury, given his lack of leadership when assigned that role and his seemingly lackluster enthusiasm for the game. Though Russell H. felt confident that Natalie would be viewed by the jury as a coattail rider while he would be seen as a topnotch player, the jury lambasted his poor social connections, whilst Natalie was praised for her quieter, adaptive gameplay. Natalie was ultimately named the Sole Survivor over Russell H. and Mick by a vote of 7–2–0.

Challenge winners and eliminations by episode

Episode			Challenge winner(s)		Eliminated
No.	Title	Original air date	Reward	Immunity	Tribe	Player
1	"The Puppet Master"	September 17, 2009	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Marisa
2	"Taking Candy From a Baby"	September 24, 2009	rowspan=2 colspan=2 Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Mike
			Template:Stribe	Betsy
3	"It's Called a Russell Seed"	October 1, 2009	colspan=2 Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Ben
4	"Hungry for a Win"	October 8, 2009	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Yasmin
5	"Walking on Thin Ice"	October 15, 2009	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Ashley
6	"This Is the Man Test"	October 22, 2009	colspan=2 Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Template:Stribe	Russell S.
7	"Houdini Magic"	October 29, 2009	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Liz
8	"All Hell Breaks Loose"	November 5, 2009	rowspan=2 Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	John	rowspan="4" Template:Stribe	Erik
			Laura
9	"Tastes Like Chicken"	November 12, 2009	Dave, John, Kelly, Monica, Shambo	Laura	Kelly
10	"The Day of Reckoning"	November 19, 2009	Brett, Dave, Laura, Natalie, Russell H.	Mick	Laura
11	"The First 27 Days"	November 26, 2009	Recap Episode
12	"Off With Their Heads!"	December 3, 2009	Template:Stribe	Jaison	rowspan="6" Template:Stribe	John
13	"Damage Control"	December 10, 2009	rowspan=2 Template:Stribe	Jaison	Dave
			Brett	Monica
14	"Two Brains Are Better Than One"	December 17, 2009	Jaison, Russell H., Shambo	Brett	Shambo
15	"This Game Ain't Over"	December 20, 2009	rowspan=2 align="center" Template:Stribe	Brett	Jaison
			Russell H.	Brett
16	"The Reunion"

In the case of multiple tribes or castaways who win reward or immunity, they are listed in order of finish, or alphabetically where it was a team effort; where one castaway won and invited others, the invitees are in brackets.

Voting history

	Original tribes								Merged tribe
Episode	1	2		3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10		12	13		14	15
Day	3	5	6	8	11	14	15	18	21	24	27		30	31	33	36	37	38
Tribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	colspan="2" Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe
Eliminated	Marisa	Mike	Betsy	Ben	Yasmin	Ashley	Russell S.	Liz	Erik	Kelly	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Laura	John	Dave	Monica	Shambo	Jaison	Brett
Vote	7–3	EvacuatedTemplate:Efn	7–1	6–1	8–2	5–1	EvacuatedTemplate:Efn	4–1	10–2	4–0Template:Efn	5–5	5–3	7–1–1	7–1	5–2	5–1	4–1	3–1
Voter	Votes
Natalie	Marisa		Betsy	Ben		Ashley		Liz	Erik	Kelly	Laura	Template:Stribe	John	Dave	Monica	Shambo	Jaison	Brett
Russell H.	Marisa		Betsy	Ben		Ashley		Liz	Erik	Kelly	Laura	Laura	John	Dave	Monica	Shambo	Jaison	Brett
Mick	Ashley		Betsy	Ben		Ashley		Liz	Erik	Kelly	Laura	Laura	John	Dave	Monica	Shambo	Jaison	Brett
Brett					Yasmin				Erik	Russell H.	Natalie	Natalie	John	Dave	Russell H.	Shambo	Jaison	Mick
Jaison	Marisa		Betsy	Ben		Ashley		Liz	Erik	Kelly	Laura	Laura	John	Dave	Monica	Shambo	Mick
Shambo					Monica				Jaison	Russell H.	Laura	Laura	Dave	Dave	Monica	Mick
Monica					Yasmin				Erik	Russell H.	Natalie	Natalie	John	Dave	Russell H.
Dave					Yasmin				Erik	Russell H.	Natalie	Natalie	John	Shambo
John					Yasmin				Erik	Russell H.	Natalie	Laura	Mick
Laura					Yasmin				Erik	Russell H.	Natalie	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn
Kelly					Yasmin				Erik	Russell H.
Erik					Yasmin				Jaison
Liz	Marisa		Betsy	Ben		Ashley		Jaison
Russell S.					Yasmin
Ashley	Marisa		Betsy	Ben		Liz
Yasmin					Monica
Ben	Marisa		Betsy	Ashley
Betsy	Ashley		Ben
Mike	Marisa
Marisa	Ashley

Jury vote
Episode	16
Day	39
Finalist	Natalie	Russell H.	Mick
Votes	7–2–0
Juror	Vote
Brett	Template:Ya
Jaison	Template:Ya
Shambo		Template:Ya
Monica	Template:Ya
Dave	Template:Ya
John		Template:Ya
Laura	Template:Ya
Kelly	Template:Ya
Erik	Template:Ya

Reception

Survivor: Samoa has received wildly polarizing opinions from both fans and critics. The primary criticism is aimed at the perceived overexposure of contestant Russell Hantz. Critics believe this was done to an extent that it rendered many of the other contestants, including winner Natalie White, unmemorable due to their lack of screen time. However, not all opinions of the season were negative. The gameplay of Hantz, which was seen as very unorthodox compared to other Survivor players, garnered high praise from fans, allowing him to win the Fan Favorite Award for the season. Hantz's cutthroat attitude and ability to find hidden immunity idols without a clue propelled him into becoming one of the most infamous villains in the show's history. Dalton Ross of Entertainment Weekly ranked this season 15th out of 40. In 2015, a poll by Rob Has a Podcast ranked this season 15th out of 30, with Rob Cesternino ranking this season 8th. This was updated in 2021 during Cesternino's podcast, Survivor All-Time Top 40 Rankings, ranking 25th out of 40. The Purple Rock Survivor Podcast listed Samoa as the twenty-second best season out of 40. They claim the season is, "incredibly divisive, and understandably so. It is impossible to think of this season without thinking of one specific player, and your feelings about that player will likely determine how you rate this season." Inside Survivor listed the season as the twenty-sixth best out of 40, claiming that, "if Survivor was going to continue into its second decade, it needed a kick up the ass—something to revitalize the format and push it forward into a new generation. Survivor: Samoa was the start of that, in large part thanks to a trilby-wearing oil company owner named Russell Hantz." In 2014, The Wire ranked the season as the third-worst of the series (only ahead of Gabon and Redemption Island). In 2024, Nick Caruso of TVLine ranked this season 33rd out of 47.

External links

• Official CBS Survivor: Samoa Website