Enki: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>TX55
mNo edit summary
imported>AndreJustAndre
Line 8: Line 8:
| caption = Detail of Enki from the Adda Seal, an ancient Akkadian cylinder seal dating to circa 2,300 BCE<ref name="seal">{{cite web|title=The Adda Seal|url=https://www.britishmuseum.org/research/collection_online/collection_object_details.aspx?objectId=368706&partId=1&searchText=89115&page=1|website=British Museum}}</ref>
| caption = Detail of Enki from the Adda Seal, an ancient Akkadian cylinder seal dating to circa 2,300 BCE<ref name="seal">{{cite web|title=The Adda Seal|url=https://www.britishmuseum.org/research/collection_online/collection_object_details.aspx?objectId=368706&partId=1&searchText=89115&page=1|website=British Museum}}</ref>
| deity_of = God of subterranean fresh waters, wisdom, crafts, creation, magic and incantations {{sfn|Galter|1983|p=52-103}}
| deity_of = God of subterranean fresh waters, wisdom, crafts, creation, magic and incantations {{sfn|Galter|1983|p=52-103}}
| symbol = ram-headed staff, [[Sea goat|goat-fish]], [[turtle]], [[ibex]]{{sfn|Wiggermann|1997|p=226}}, vase with flowing waters{{sfn|Seidl|1971|p=486}}
| symbol = ram-headed staff, [[Sea goat|goat-fish]], [[turtle]], [[ibex]]{{sfn|Wiggermann|1997|p=226}}
| consort = {{plainlist|
| consort = {{plainlist|
*[[Damgalnuna]]
*[[Damgalnuna]]
Line 52: Line 52:


=== Enki ===
=== Enki ===
The name Enki is usually translated as “Lord of the Earth” in [[Sumerian language|sumerian]].{{Sfn|Galter|1983|p=8}} This explanation is not universally accepted.{{Sfn|Lambert|1989|p=116}} Several scholars argue that it does not seemingly fit the functions of the god.{{Sfn|Galter|1983|p=8}}{{Sfn|Kramer|1960|p=276}} It has been proposed that Enki could have been an epithet of the deity that eventually replaced his original name.{{Sfn|Galter|1983|p=8-9}} [[Samuel Noah Kramer]] argued that the epithet <nowiki>''Lord of the Earth''</nowiki> was given to the god by the theologians of [[Eridu]] in order to elevate his position in the pantheon and make him a rival of [[Enlil]].{{Sfn|Kramer|1960|p=276}}However, [[Thorkild Jacobsen]] points out that there is no conclusive evidence of a rivalry between Enki and Enlil in Sumerian texts.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1992|p=415}} Jacobsen interpreted Enki as a personification of the power of sweet waters. He explained his name ‘’Lord (productive manager) of the Earth’’ as a reflection of the role of water in the fertilizing of the earth.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1976|p=111}} He proposed that Enki’s original name was [[Abzu|Abzû]], later regarded as his under-earth sweet water domain and living place.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1970|p=22}} However according to Peeter Espak there is no conclusive proof that Enki was regarded as an ancient personification of water in the available sources of the old sumerian period.{{Sfn|Espak|2010|p=237}} Despite the similarity between their names, Enki of Eridu and [[Ancestors of Enlil|the primordial god Enki]] were separate figures.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1976|p=252}} Jacobsen proposed that their names had slightly different meanings and he translated the name of the primordial god as “Lord Earth”.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1976|p=252}}The forms of their names in the [[Emesal]] dialect are different; the name of Enki of Eridu is written Amanki, while the name of the primordial god is written Umunki.{{Sfn|Lambert|2013|p=414}}
The name Enki is usually translated as “Lord of the Earth” in [[Sumerian language|Sumerian]].{{Sfn|Galter|1983|p=8}} This explanation is not universally accepted.{{Sfn|Lambert|1989|p=116}} Several scholars argue that it does not seemingly fit the functions of the god.{{Sfn|Galter|1983|p=8}}{{Sfn|Kramer|1960|p=276}} It has been proposed that Enki could have been an epithet of the deity that eventually replaced his original name.{{Sfn|Galter|1983|p=8-9}} [[Samuel Noah Kramer]] argued that the epithet <nowiki>''Lord of the Earth''</nowiki> was given to the god by the theologians of [[Eridu]] in order to elevate his position in the pantheon and make him a rival of [[Enlil]].{{Sfn|Kramer|1960|p=276}}However, [[Thorkild Jacobsen]] points out that there is no conclusive evidence of a rivalry between Enki and Enlil in Sumerian texts.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1992|p=415}} Jacobsen interpreted Enki as a personification of the power of sweet waters. He explained his name ‘’Lord (productive manager) of the Earth’’ as a reflection of the role of water in the fertilizing of the earth.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1976|p=111}} He proposed that Enki’s original name was [[Abzu|Abzû]], later regarded as his under-earth sweet water domain and living place.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1970|p=22}} However according to Peeter Espak there is no conclusive proof that Enki was regarded as an ancient personification of water in the available sources of the old sumerian period.{{Sfn|Espak|2010|p=237}} Despite the similarity between their names, Enki of Eridu and [[Ancestors of Enlil|the primordial god Enki]] were separate figures.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1976|p=252}} Jacobsen proposed that their names had slightly different meanings and he translated the name of the primordial god as “Lord Earth”.{{Sfn|Jacobsen|1976|p=252}}The forms of their names in the [[Emesal]] dialect are different; the name of Enki of Eridu is written Amanki, while the name of the primordial god is written Umunki.{{Sfn|Lambert|2013|p=414}}


[[Edmond Sollberger]] and [[Wilfred G. Lambert]] have proposed a different translation for the name of Enki of Eridu. It has been remarked that an omissible g appears at the end of the second element of his name, which does not appear in the name of the primordial god.{{Sfn|Lambert|2013|p=417}}For this reason they interpret this second element not as ki, ‘’earth’’, but as ki(g) of unknown meaning.{{Sfn|Espak|2006|p=27}} Sollberger understood an element ki(g) meaning ‘’favour, benevolence, love’’ in Sumerian. Therefore he translated Enki(g) as ‘’Lord Love’’,{{Sfn|Sollberger|1966|p=141}}or ‘’Lord Benevolence’’.{{Sfn|Sollberger|Kupper|p=301|1971}} He argues that this translation reflects Enki’s well attested role in myths as a friend of mankind.{{Sfn|Sollberger|1966|p=141}} However, this explanation is not generally accepted. It has been remarked that it is possible that the omissible g developed via [[dissimilation]],{{Sfn|Lisman|2013|p=128}} though similar examples of dissimilation are so far not attested in Sumerian.{{Sfn|Espak|2006|p=28}}
[[Edmond Sollberger]] and [[Wilfred G. Lambert]] have proposed a different translation for the name of Enki of Eridu. It has been remarked that an omissible g appears at the end of the second element of his name, which does not appear in the name of the primordial god.{{Sfn|Lambert|2013|p=417}}For this reason they interpret this second element not as ki, ‘’earth’’, but as ki(g) of unknown meaning.{{Sfn|Espak|2006|p=27}} Sollberger understood an element ki(g) meaning ‘’favour, benevolence, love’’ in Sumerian. Therefore he translated Enki(g) as ‘’Lord Love’’,{{Sfn|Sollberger|1966|p=141}}or ‘’Lord Benevolence’’.{{Sfn|Sollberger|Kupper|p=301|1971}} He argues that this translation reflects Enki’s well attested role in myths as a friend of mankind.{{Sfn|Sollberger|1966|p=141}} However, this explanation is not generally accepted. It has been remarked that it is possible that the omissible g developed via [[dissimilation]],{{Sfn|Lisman|2013|p=128}} though similar examples of dissimilation are so far not attested in Sumerian.{{Sfn|Espak|2006|p=28}}
Line 59: Line 59:
The name Ea first occurs in personal names from the [[Akkadian Empire|Old Akkadian period]]. Earlier translations interpreting Ea as a sumerian name meaning ‘’House of Water’’ or ‘’House of the Moon, Moon station’’ are regarded as implausible by modern scholarship.{{Sfn|Galter|1983|p=3}} In a few modern publications, the interpretation ‘’House of Water’’ is sometimes presented as a scribal popular etymology. However, according to Lambert, there is no evidence for such a reinterpretation.{{Sfn|Lambert|1989|p=116}}
The name Ea first occurs in personal names from the [[Akkadian Empire|Old Akkadian period]]. Earlier translations interpreting Ea as a sumerian name meaning ‘’House of Water’’ or ‘’House of the Moon, Moon station’’ are regarded as implausible by modern scholarship.{{Sfn|Galter|1983|p=3}} In a few modern publications, the interpretation ‘’House of Water’’ is sometimes presented as a scribal popular etymology. However, according to Lambert, there is no evidence for such a reinterpretation.{{Sfn|Lambert|1989|p=116}}


Due to the fact that the name appears associated with semitic elements in the sources of the Old Akkadian Period, it has been suggested that Ea is most likely a semitic name.{{Sfn|Roberts|1972|p=20-21}}It has been proposed that the etymology of the name is connected to the semitic root ḥyy, ‘’to live’’.{{Sfn|Archi|2010|p=15}} This explanation has not been proved with certainty, though it is considered plausible.{{Sfn|Espak|2010|p=163}} Miguel Civil proposed that the name of the god [[Haya (god)|Haya]] was originally an alternative spelling of Ea.{{Sfn|Civil|1983|p=44}} Margaret W. Green proposed that the names Ea and Haya were both derived from the name of a pre Sumerian deity that was integrated into the pantheons of the sumerians and of the semitic peoples, and that Haya persisted as a separate deity after Ea was syncretized with Enki.{{Sfn|Green|1975|p=75}}The hypothesis of a connection between the names Ea and Haya is considered to be credible, but it is not proved, and it is not accepted by all scholars.{{Sfn|Weeden|2009|p=98-103}}
Due to the fact that the name appears associated with Semitic elements in the sources of the Old Akkadian Period, it has been suggested that Ea is most likely a Semitic name.{{Sfn|Roberts|1972|p=20-21}} It has been proposed that the etymology of the name is connected to the Semitic root ''ḥyy'', ‘’to live’’.{{Sfn|Archi|2010|p=15}} This explanation has not been proved with certainty, though it is considered plausible.{{Sfn|Espak|2010|p=163}} Miguel Civil proposed that the name of the god [[Haya (god)|Haya]] was originally an alternative spelling of Ea.{{Sfn|Civil|1983|p=44}} Margaret W. Green proposed that the names Ea and Haya were both derived from the name of a pre Sumerian deity that was integrated into the pantheons of the Sumerians and of the Semitic peoples, and that Haya persisted as a separate deity after Ea was syncretized with Enki.{{Sfn|Green|1975|p=75}} The hypothesis of a connection between the names Ea and Haya is considered to be credible, but it is not proved, and it is not accepted by all scholars.{{Sfn|Weeden|2009|p=98-103}}


== Alternative names and epithets ==
== Alternative names and epithets ==

Revision as of 07:56, 24 June 2025

Template:Short description Script error: No such module "other uses". Template:Use dmy dates Script error: No such module "Infobox".Template:Template otherScript error: No such module "Check for unknown parameters".Template:Wikidata imageTemplate:Compare image with Wikidata Template:Mesopotamian myth (7) Template:Contains special characters

Enki (Template:Langx Template:Transliteration) is the Sumerian god of water, knowledge (gestú), crafts (gašam), and creation (nudimmud), and one of the Anunnaki. He was later known as Ea (Template:Langx) or Ae[1] in Akkadian (Assyrian-Babylonian) religion, and is identified by some scholars with Ia in Canaanite religion. The name was rendered Aos within Greek sources (e.g. Damascius).[2]

He was originally the patron god of the city of Eridu, but later the influence of his cult spread throughout Mesopotamia and to the Canaanites, Hittites and Hurrians. He was associated with the southern band of constellations called stars of Ea, but also with the constellation AŠ-IKU, the Field (Square of Pegasus).[3] Beginning around the second millennium BCE, he was sometimes referred to in writing by the numeric ideogram for "40", occasionally referred to as his "sacred number".Template:Sfn[4] The planet Mercury, associated with Babylonian Nabu (the son of Marduk) was, in Sumerian times, identified with Enki,Template:Sfn as was the star Canopus.[5]

Many myths about Enki have been collected from various sites, stretching from Southern Iraq to the Levantine coast. He is mentioned in the earliest extant cuneiform inscriptions throughout the region and was prominent from the third millennium down to the Hellenistic period.

The names Enki and Ea

The meaning of the names Enki and Ea is uncertain. It is presumed that they were originally separate deities, though it is unclear when they were fully equated with each other.[6] Alfonso Archi argues that syncretism between them likely already existed at least from the mid third millenium BCE in parts of Babylonia.Template:Sfn

Enki

The name Enki is usually translated as “Lord of the Earth” in Sumerian.Template:Sfn This explanation is not universally accepted.Template:Sfn Several scholars argue that it does not seemingly fit the functions of the god.Template:SfnTemplate:Sfn It has been proposed that Enki could have been an epithet of the deity that eventually replaced his original name.Template:Sfn Samuel Noah Kramer argued that the epithet ''Lord of the Earth'' was given to the god by the theologians of Eridu in order to elevate his position in the pantheon and make him a rival of Enlil.Template:SfnHowever, Thorkild Jacobsen points out that there is no conclusive evidence of a rivalry between Enki and Enlil in Sumerian texts.Template:Sfn Jacobsen interpreted Enki as a personification of the power of sweet waters. He explained his name ‘’Lord (productive manager) of the Earth’’ as a reflection of the role of water in the fertilizing of the earth.Template:Sfn He proposed that Enki’s original name was Abzû, later regarded as his under-earth sweet water domain and living place.Template:Sfn However according to Peeter Espak there is no conclusive proof that Enki was regarded as an ancient personification of water in the available sources of the old sumerian period.Template:Sfn Despite the similarity between their names, Enki of Eridu and the primordial god Enki were separate figures.Template:Sfn Jacobsen proposed that their names had slightly different meanings and he translated the name of the primordial god as “Lord Earth”.Template:SfnThe forms of their names in the Emesal dialect are different; the name of Enki of Eridu is written Amanki, while the name of the primordial god is written Umunki.Template:Sfn

Edmond Sollberger and Wilfred G. Lambert have proposed a different translation for the name of Enki of Eridu. It has been remarked that an omissible g appears at the end of the second element of his name, which does not appear in the name of the primordial god.Template:SfnFor this reason they interpret this second element not as ki, ‘’earth’’, but as ki(g) of unknown meaning.Template:Sfn Sollberger understood an element ki(g) meaning ‘’favour, benevolence, love’’ in Sumerian. Therefore he translated Enki(g) as ‘’Lord Love’’,Template:Sfnor ‘’Lord Benevolence’’.Template:Sfn He argues that this translation reflects Enki’s well attested role in myths as a friend of mankind.Template:Sfn However, this explanation is not generally accepted. It has been remarked that it is possible that the omissible g developed via dissimilation,Template:Sfn though similar examples of dissimilation are so far not attested in Sumerian.Template:Sfn

Ea

The name Ea first occurs in personal names from the Old Akkadian period. Earlier translations interpreting Ea as a sumerian name meaning ‘’House of Water’’ or ‘’House of the Moon, Moon station’’ are regarded as implausible by modern scholarship.Template:Sfn In a few modern publications, the interpretation ‘’House of Water’’ is sometimes presented as a scribal popular etymology. However, according to Lambert, there is no evidence for such a reinterpretation.Template:Sfn

Due to the fact that the name appears associated with Semitic elements in the sources of the Old Akkadian Period, it has been suggested that Ea is most likely a Semitic name.Template:Sfn It has been proposed that the etymology of the name is connected to the Semitic root ḥyy, ‘’to live’’.Template:Sfn This explanation has not been proved with certainty, though it is considered plausible.Template:Sfn Miguel Civil proposed that the name of the god Haya was originally an alternative spelling of Ea.Template:Sfn Margaret W. Green proposed that the names Ea and Haya were both derived from the name of a pre Sumerian deity that was integrated into the pantheons of the Sumerians and of the Semitic peoples, and that Haya persisted as a separate deity after Ea was syncretized with Enki.Template:Sfn The hypothesis of a connection between the names Ea and Haya is considered to be credible, but it is not proved, and it is not accepted by all scholars.Template:Sfn

Alternative names and epithets

Nudimmud

Nudimmud, one of the most frequently attested alternative names and epithets of Enki/Ea, was almost exclusively used in literary texts. In akkadian sources, it could also appear in royal inscriptions, prayers, and incantations.Template:SfnIt already appears in the Zame Hymns under the form den-nu-te-mud.Template:Sfn The standard writing was dnu-dím-mud. Alternative forms include, for example, nu-te-me-nud from the Fāra period or nu-da-mud from the Ur III period. The verbal elements dím and mud in the standard orthography respectively mean ‘’to build, create’’, and ‘’to bring forth’’.Template:Sfn The god list An=Anum ša ameli explains Nudimmud as Ea in his aspect as the god of creation.Template:Sfn Thorkild Jacobsen interpreted the name as ‘’Image fashioner’’, ‘’God of shaping’’, reflecting Ea’s role as the god of crafts and as the god who creates figures from clay.Template:Sfn It has been remarked that older spellings of Nudimmud do not feature the element dím.Template:Sfn Antoine Cavigneaux and Manfred Krebernik conclude that the orthography with dím is likely due to a later etymological reinterpretation of the name.Template:SfnThe meaning of Nudimmud in the older periods is unclear.Template:Sfn

Nagbu

Nagbu, ‘’Source, spring’’,Template:Sfn was an alternative name of Enki/Ea which reflected his role as the lord of the springs and subterranean waters. In this aspect he was not only connected to irrigation and fertility,Template:Sfn but he was also associated with the art of incantation, as subterranean water played an important role in Mesopotamian magic and incantation rituals.Template:Sfn Nagbu is attested chiefly in sources from Babylonia, and in the Neo Babylonian period, the name often appears in incantation texts.Template:Sfn It was written with the logogram dIDIM. This logogram already appears as a theophoric element in Akkadian and Neo Sumerian names.Template:SfnStarting from the second millennium BC it often appears in Babylonian personal names.Template:Sfn In the god list An=Anum, Nagbu is equated with Ea. It is unclear whether Nagbu was originally an independent deity or an aspect of Ea.Template:Sfn

Niššīku

Niššīku was an alternative name and epithet of Enki/Ea of uncertain meaning. It is first attested in literary texts of the Old Babylonian period.Template:Sfn Wilfred G. Lambert and Alan R. Millard propose that the name was derived from the Semitic element nasīku ,’’chieftain’’, which reflects Enki’s sumerian epithet nun.Template:Sfn Hannes D. Galter considers that a connection between an Old Babylonian expression and a loanword from Aramaic is implausible.Template:SfnAlternative spellings of the name include Naššīku and Ninšīku.Template:Sfn Ninšīku is likely a later folk etymology from Sumerian. It is attested from the Middle Babylonian period onwards.Template:Sfn One god list explains Ninšīku as Ea in his aspect as god of wisdom. In this interpretation, -šiku was likely equated with Sumerian kù-zu, ‘’wise’’.Template:Sfn

DIŠ

The logogram DIŠ often designates Enki/Ea in Assyrian texts. In Neo Assyrian sources, it chiefly appears in royal inscriptions and incantation literature.Template:Sfn It is sometimes attested as a theophoric element in personal names of the first millenium. In Neo Babylonian Uruk it designates Anu instead. The reading of DIŠ in akkadian is unknown. Galter suggests that DIŠ was possibly a numeral symbolizing the number 60, a number associated with Anu, and that its use for Ea could have been a way to equate him with the supreme god of the pantheon.Template:Sfn

Other names and epithets

Enki/Ea had a variety of other names and epithets reflecting his different functions and his association with his abode, Abzû, and his cult center, Eridu.Template:Sfn Galter remarks that the majority of other names of Ea are only documented from sources from the late second millennium, and therefore he presumes that they represent an effort to fully encompass and describe all of the aspects of the god.Template:Sfn Craftsmanship deities such as Uttu and Ninagal could be regarded as alternative names of Ea in late sources.Template:Sfn

The majority of akkadian epithets of Ea reflect his role as the god of wisdom.Template:Sfn Such epithets include for example, bēl nēmeqi (‘’Lord of wisdom’’),bēl tašīmti (‘’Lord of understanding’’),Template:Sfn and apkal ilī.(‘’Sage of the gods’’).Template:Sfn Bēl nagbi, (‘’Lord of the subterranean waters’’)Template:Sfn was a frequently attested epithet of Ea in his aspect as a water god.Template:Sfn He could be referred to as bēl tenēšēti, ‘’Lord of mankind’’.Template:Sfn His association to the arts of incantation was reflected in his epithets mašmaš ilī, ‘’Exorcist of the gods’’,Template:Sfn and bēl išīputti (‘’Lord of the purification rites’’).Template:Sfn

Ea could be referred to as Ea-šarru in some akkadian texts.Template:Sfn According to Galter, it is unclear whether Ea-šarru was simply an epithet of Ea or if a foreign deity was identified with Ea and -šarru,‘’king’’, was added to distinguish them. He remarks that the earliest attestations of this name occur outside of Mesopotamia, which could indicate that the name did not originate in the region.Template:Sfn

A common epithet of Enki/Ea in literary texts was Enlil-banda, ‘’the junior Enlil’’. An early attestation of this epithet dates to the Old Babylonian Period.Template:Sfn Several possible interpretations of this name have been suggested by scholars. It could indicate that Ea was regarded as a younger brother of Enlil, it could have been a way to equate Ea with Enlil, it could have been a way to assert that he is ‘’like Enlil’' in his domain,Template:Sfn or it could mean that he received his functions and abode from Enlil.Template:Sfn

Enki’s epithets king of the Abzû and king of Eridu are already attested in sumerian sources from the Early Dynastic Period.Template:Sfn Another of his epithets was (ddàra-abzu), translated as IbexTemplate:SfnTemplate:Sfn or StagTemplate:Sfn of the Abzû. The ibex was associated with Enki in historical times.Template:Sfn An early attestation of this byname is found in an Old Babylonian hymn. Several compound bynames of Enki/Ea formed with the element dàra appear in a later god list.Template:SfnTemplate:Sfn

Symbols and iconography

File:Ea (Babilonian) - EnKi (Sumerian).jpg
Detail of the Adda Seal, an ancient Akkadian cylinder seal (circa 2300 BC) depicting Ea with water streams coming from his shoulders. British Museum.

Enki/Ea is considered one of the few Mesopotamian deities with a recognizable iconography.Template:Sfn His most distinguishing features are water streams flowing from his body, often accompanied by fish swimming in the water. These features are first attested in the Old Akkadian Period.Template:Sfn Enki’s iconography in the older periods is uncertain. It has been proposed that he is depicted on an Early Dynastic seal representing a sitting god with two fish beneath his feet,Template:Sfn though this identification is not universally accepted.Template:Sfn Enki/Ea’s water streams could be depicted as coming from his shoulders or his hips, or he could be depicted sitting within his shrine or abode, with the streams surrounding it in the shape of a rectangle.Template:SfnTemplate:Sfn Additionally, he could often be depicted with water sprouting vesselsTemplate:Sfn, carrying them either on his shoulders, in his hand or above his hand.Template:Sfn

File:God Ea, also Enki, holding a cup with overflowing water. From Iraq. Pergamon Museum.jpg
Old Babylonian (19th-17th century BCE) statue of Ea holding a vessel with flowing waters. Pergamon Museum.

His emblems include the goat-fish and the ram-headed staff.Template:Sfn They were often depicted together, for example on kudurrus.Template:SfnTemplate:Sfn The kudurru of Nazi-Maruttash refers to them as ‘’the great emblems of Ea’’.Template:Sfn The ram-headed staff is attested in art from the Old Babylonian period until the Achaemenid period. In Neo Assyrian seals, Ea is sometimes represented carrying a crook, which Jeremy Black and Anthony Green suggest may be a symbolic representation of the staff.Template:Sfn The goat-fish is attested in mesopotamian art from the Neo Sumerian period until Hellenistic times, and it was later adopted into roman art.Template:Sfn It is at the origin of the zodiacal constellation Capricorn.Template:Sfn Ea could often be represented sitting or standing on it.Template:Sfn While the goat-fish’s connection to Ea is well attested, it could also be depicted as a general apotropaic figure, not attached to any god.Template:Sfn Clay figurines of goat-fishes could be used in apotropaic magic.Template:Sfn

Another symbol of Ea was the turtle. It was associated with him since the Old Akkadian period.Template:SfnTemplate:Sfn On kudurrus it could be used as his symbol instead of the goat-fish with the ram-headed staff, or it could be represented on the back of the goat-fish.Template:Sfn

Ea was often depicted alongside his two faced vizier Isimud. Since the Old Akkadian period he could also be depicted alongside his Lahmu servants, divinities represented as naked or kilted male figures with abundant facial hair and locks of hair on each side of their face.Template:Sfn On cylinder seals they could be represented as his doorkeepers, holding a gate-post, or in later periods a spade.Template:Sfn Another figure closely associated with Ea in pictorial representations is the fish-man, who has the upper body of a man and the lower body of a fish. It was depicted next to symbols of Ea.Template:Sfn It is attested in pictorial representations from the Neo Sumerian period up until Hellenistic times, and might have been the precursor of the merman in Greek and Medieval European art and literature.Template:SfnTemplate:Sfn

In Akkadian period seals, Ea was depicted in various scenes, some of which likely have a mythological background. A well known example is the seal of Adda.Template:SfnTemplate:Sfn There he is depicted with one foot on a mountain, with water streams coming out of his shoulders, and fish swimming in them. An ibex or a bull is seated beneath his right foot. An eagle descends from above to the center of the scene. Ea’s two faced vizier stands behind him. The god rising from the mountain is most often interpreted as Shamash, though Adad or Ninurta have also been proposed, and the armed goddess as Ishtar.Template:Sfn[7] Another well attested example is a motif where a half man, half bird creature is presented before an enthroned Ea by one or two gods, one of which is generally Isimud.Template:Sfn Various interpretations of these scenes have been proposed by scholars.Template:Sfn Pierre Amiet proposed that the scene on the Adda cylinder may represent the revelation of the forces of nature in early spring.Template:Sfn Kramer and Maier proposed that the scene of the ‘’bird-man’’ led before the god of streams could be derived from the Anzû myth, representing the return of the tablets of destinies to Enki after the defeat of the Anzû bird who had stolen them,Template:Sfn as in the sumerian version of the myth he was their guardian, while in the akkadian version they were stolen from Enlil instead.Template:SfnTemplate:Sfn However, since only a few, difficult to understand myths are preserved from the period, the narrative behind the scenes remains uncertain.Template:Sfn Ea could also be depicted travelling on his boat. According to one text, the name of the boat was ‘’Ibex of the Abzû’’Template:Sfn. Enki’s association with the ibex dates to the second half of the third millennium.Template:Sfn

The little owl is called the bird of Ea in the Bird Call Text.Template:Sfn

Worship

The main temple to Enki was called E-abzu, meaning "abzu temple" (also E-en-gur-a, meaning "house of the subterranean waters"), a ziggurat temple surrounded by Euphratean marshlands near the ancient Persian Gulf coastline at Eridu. It was the first temple known to have been built in Southern Iraq. Four separate excavations at the site of Eridu have demonstrated the existence of a shrine dating back to the earliest Ubaid period, more than 6,500 years ago. Over the following 4,500 years, the temple was expanded 18 times, until it was abandoned during the Persian period.Template:SfnScript error: No such module "Unsubst". On this basis Thorkild Jacobsen[8] has hypothesized that the original deity of the temple was Abzu, with his attributes later being taken by Enki over time. P. Steinkeller believes that, during the earliest period, Enki had a subordinate position to a goddess (possibly Ninhursag), taking the role of divine consort or high priest,[9] later taking priority. The Enki temple had at its entrance a pool of fresh water, and excavation has found numerous carp bones, suggesting collective feasts. Carp are shown in the twin water flows running into the later God Enki, suggesting continuity of these features over a very long period. These features were found at all subsequent Sumerian temples, suggesting that this temple established the pattern for all subsequent Sumerian temples. "All rules laid down at Eridu were faithfully observed".[10]

Mythology

File:Impression of an Akkadian cylinder seal with inscription The Divine Sharkalisharri Prince of Akkad Ibni-Sharrum the Scribe his servant.jpg
Impression of a cylinder seal of the time of Akkadian King Sharkalisharri (c. 2200 BC), with central inscription: "The Divine Sharkalisharri Prince of Akkad, Ibni-Sharrum the Scribe his servant". Depiction of Ea with long-horned water buffalo. Circa 2217–2193 BC. Louvre Museum.[11][12][13]

Creation of life and sickness

The cosmogenic myth common in Sumer was that of the hieros gamos, a sacred marriage where divine principles in the form of dualistic opposites came together as male and female to give birth to the cosmos. In the epic Enki and Ninhursag, Enki, as lord of Ab or fresh water, is living with his wife in the paradise of Dilmun where

Template:Poemquote

Despite being a place where "the raven uttered no cries" and "the lion killed not, the wolf snatched not the lamb, unknown was the kid-killing dog, unknown was the grain devouring boar", Dilmun had no water and Enki heard the cries of its goddess, Ninsikil, and orders the sun-god Utu to bring fresh water from the Earth for Dilmun. As a result,

Template:Poemquote

Dilmun was identified with Bahrain, whose name in Arabic means "two seas", where the fresh waters of the Arabian aquifer mingle with the salt waters of the Persian Gulf. This mingling of waters was known in Sumerian as Nammu, and was identified as the mother of Enki.

The subsequent tale, with similarities to the Biblical story of the forbidden fruit, repeats the story of how fresh water brings life to a barren land.[14] Enki, the Water-Lord then "caused to flow the 'water of the heart" and having fertilised his consort Ninhursag, also known as Ki or Earth, after "Nine days being her nine months, the months of 'womanhood'... like good butter, Nintu, the mother of the land, ...like good butter, gave birth to Ninsar, (Lady Greenery)". When Ninhursag left him, as Water-Lord he came upon Ninsar (Lady Greenery). Not knowing her to be his daughter, and because she reminds him of his absent consort, Enki then seduces and has intercourse with her. Ninsar then gave birth to Ninkurra (Lady Fruitfulness or Lady Pasture), and leaves Enki alone again. A second time, Enki, in his loneliness finds and seduces Ninkurra, and from the union Ninkurra gave birth to Uttu (weaver or spider, the weaver of the web of life).

A third time Enki succumbs to temptation, and attempts seduction of Uttu. Upset about Enki's reputation, Uttu consults Ninhursag, who, upset at the promiscuous wayward nature of her spouse, advises Uttu to avoid the riverbanks, the places likely to be affected by flooding, the home of Enki. In another version of this myth, Ninhursag takes Enki's semen from Uttu's womb and plants it in the earth where eight plants rapidly germinate. With his two-faced servant and steward Isimud, "Enki, in the swampland, in the swampland lies stretched out, 'What is this (plant), what is this (plant).' His messenger Isimud, answers him; 'My king, this is the tree-plant', he says to him. He cuts it off for him and he (Enki) eats it". And so, despite warnings, Enki consumes the other seven fruit. Consuming his own semen, he falls pregnant (ill with swellings) in his jaw, his teeth, his mouth, his hip, his throat, his limbs, his side and his rib. The gods are at a loss to know what to do; chagrined they "sit in the dust". As Enki lacks a birth canal through which to give birth, he seems to be dying with swellings. The fox then asks Enlil, King of the Gods, "If I bring Ninhursag before thee, what shall be my reward?" Ninhursag's sacred fox then fetches the goddess.

Ninhursag relents and takes Enki's Ab (water, or semen) into her body, and gives birth to gods of healing of each part of the body: Abu for the jaw, Nanshe for the throat, Nintul for the hip, Ninsutu for the tooth, Ninkasi for the mouth, Dazimua for the side, Enshagag for the limbs. The last one, Ninti (Lady Rib), is also a pun on Lady Life, a title of Ninhursag herself. The story thus symbolically reflects the way in which life is brought forth through the addition of water to the land, and once it grows, water is required to bring plants to fruit. It also counsels balance and responsibility, nothing to excess.

Ninti, the title of Ninhursag, also means "the mother of all living", and was a title later given to the Hurrian goddess Kheba. This is also the title given in the Bible to Eve, the Hebrew and Aramaic Ḥawwah (חוה), who was made from the rib of Adam, in a strange reflection of the Sumerian myth, in which Adam – not Enki – walks in the Garden of Paradise.[15]Script error: No such module "Unsubst".

Making of man

After six generations of gods, in the Babylonian Enûma Eliš, in the seventh generation, (Akkadian "shapattu" or sabath), the younger Igigi gods, the sons and daughters of Enlil and Ninlil, go on strike and refuse their duties of keeping creation working. Abzu, god of fresh water, co-creator of the cosmos, threatens to destroy the world with his waters, and the gods gather in terror. Enki promises to help and puts Abzu to sleep, confining him in irrigation canals and places him in the Kur, beneath his city of Eridu. But the universe is still threatened, as Tiamat, angry at the imprisonment of Abzu and at the prompting of her son and vizier Kingu, decides to take back creation herself. The gods gather again in terror and turn to Enki for help, but Enki – who harnessed Abzu, Tiamat's consort, for irrigation – refuses to get involved. The gods then seek help elsewhere, and the patriarchal Enlil, their father, god of Nippur, promises to solve the problem if they make him King of the Gods. In the Babylonian tale, Enlil's role is taken by Marduk, Enki's son, and in the Assyrian version it is Ashur. After dispatching Tiamat with the "arrows of his winds" down her throat and constructing the heavens with the arch of her ribs, Enlil places her tail in the sky as the Milky Way, and her crying eyes become the source of the Tigris and Euphrates. But there is still the problem of "who will keep the cosmos working". Enki, who might have otherwise come to their aid, is lying in a deep sleep and fails to hear their cries. His mother Nammu (creatrix also of Abzu and Tiamat) "brings the tears of the gods" before Enki and says

Template:Poemquote

Enki then advises that they create a servant of the gods, humankind, out of clay and blood.[16] Against Enki's wish, the gods decide to slay Kingu, and Enki finally consents to use Kingu's blood to make the first human, with whom Enki always later has a close relationship, the first of the seven sages, seven wise men or "Abgallu" (ab = water, gal = great, lu = man), also known as Adapa. Enki assembles a team of divinities to help him, creating a host of "good and princely fashioners". He tells his mother:

Template:Poemquote

Adapa, the first man fashioned, later goes and acts as the advisor to the King of Eridu, when in the Sumerian King-List, the me of "kingship descends on Eridu".

Samuel Noah Kramer believes that behind this myth of Enki's confinement of Abzu lies an older one of the struggle between Enki and the Dragon Kur (the underworld).[15]Script error: No such module "Unsubst".

The Atrahasis-Epos has it that Enlil requested from Nammu the creation of humans. And Nammu told him that with the help of Enki (her son) she can create humans in the image of gods.

Uniter of languages

In the Sumerian epic entitled Enmerkar and the Lord of Aratta, in a speech of Enmerkar, an introductory spell appears, recounting Enki having had mankind communicate in one language (following Jay Crisostomo 2019); in other accounts, it is a hymn imploring Enki to do so. In either case, Enki "facilitated the debates between [the two kings] by allowing the world to speak one language," the presumed superior language of the tablet, i.e. Sumerian.Template:Refn

Jay Crisostomo's 2019 translation, based on the recent work of C. Mittermayer is: Template:Poemquote

S.N. Kramer's 1940 translation is as follows:Template:Refn

Template:Poemquote

The deluge

Script error: No such module "Labelled list hatnote". In the Sumerian version of the flood myth, the causes of the flood and the reasons for the hero's survival are unknown due to the fact that the beginning of the tablet describing the story has been destroyed. Nonetheless, Kramer has stated that it can probably be reasonably inferred that the hero Ziusudra survives due to Enki's aid because that is what happens in the later Akkadian and Babylonian versions of the story.Template:RTemplate:Rp

In the later Legend of Atrahasis, Enlil, the King of the Gods, sets out to eliminate humanity, whose noise is disturbing his rest. He successively sends drought, famine and plague to eliminate humanity, but Enki thwarts his half-brother's plans by teaching Atrahasis how to counter these threats. Each time, Atrahasis asks the population to abandon worship of all gods except the one responsible for the calamity, and this seems to shame them into relenting. Humans, however, proliferate a fourth time. Enraged, Enlil convenes a Council of Deities and gets them to promise not to tell humankind that he plans their total annihilation. Enki does not tell Atrahasis directly, but speaks to him in secret via a reed wall. He instructs Atrahasis to build a boat in order to rescue his family and other living creatures from the coming deluge. After the seven-day deluge, the flood hero frees a swallow, a raven and a dove in an effort to find if the flood waters have receded. Upon landing, a sacrifice is made to the gods. Enlil is angry his will has been thwarted yet again, and Enki is named as the culprit. Enki explains that Enlil is unfair to punish the guiltless, and the gods institute measures to ensure that humanity does not become too populous in the future. This is one of the oldest of the surviving Middle Eastern deluge myths.

Enki and Inanna

The myth Enki and Inanna[17][18] tells the story of how the young goddess of the É-anna temple of Uruk feasts with her father Enki.[19] The two deities participate in a drinking competition; then, Enki, thoroughly inebriated, gives Inanna all of the mes. The next morning, when Enki awakes with a hangover, he asks his servant Isimud for the mes, only to be informed that he has given them to Inanna. Upset, he sends Galla to recover them. Inanna sails away in the boat of heaven and arrives safely back at the quay of Uruk. Eventually, Enki admits his defeat and accepts a peace treaty with Uruk.

Politically, this myth would seem to indicate events of an early period when political authority passed from Enki's city of Eridu to Inanna's city of Uruk.

In the myth of Inanna's Descent,[18] Inanna, in order to console her grieving sister Ereshkigal, who is mourning the death of her husband Gugalana (gu 'bull', gal 'big', ana 'sky/heaven'), slain by Gilgamesh and Enkidu, sets out to visit her sister. Inanna tells her servant Ninshubur ('Lady Evening', a reference to Inanna's role as the evening star) to get help from Anu, Enlil or Enki if she does not return in three days. After Inanna has not come back, Ninshubur approaches Anu, only to be told that he knows the goddess's strength and her ability to take care of herself. While Enlil tells Ninshubur he is busy running the cosmos, Enki immediately expresses concern and dispatches his Galla (Galaturra or Kurgarra, sexless beings created from the dirt from beneath the god's finger-nails) to recover the young goddess. These beings may be the origin of the Greco-Roman Galli, androgynous beings of the third sex who played an important part in early religious ritual.[20]

Script error: No such module "anchor".In the story Inanna and Shukaletuda,[21] Shukaletuda, the gardener, set by Enki to care for the date palm he had created, finds Inanna sleeping under the palm tree and rapes the goddess in her sleep. Awaking, she discovers that she has been violated and seeks to punish the miscreant. Shukaletuda seeks protection from Enki, whom Bottéro believes to be his father.Template:Sfn In classic Enkian fashion, the father advises Shukaletuda to hide in the city where Inanna will not be able to find him. Enki, as the protector of whoever comes to seek his help, and as the empowerer of Inanna, here challenges the young impetuous goddess to control her anger so as to be better able to function as a great judge.

Eventually, after cooling her anger, she too seeks the help of Enki, as spokesperson of the "assembly of the gods", the Igigi and the Anunnaki. After she presents her case, Enki sees that justice needs to be done and promises help, delivering knowledge of where the miscreant is hiding.

Influence

File:God Ea.jpg
God Ea, a statue from Khorsabad, late 8th century BCE, Iraq, now in the Iraq Museum
File:God Ea, seated, holding a cup. From Nasiriyah, southern Iraq, 2004-1595 BCE. Iraq Museum.jpg
God Ea, seated, holding a cup. From Nasiriyah, southern Iraq, 2004–1595 BCE. Iraq Museum

Enki and later Ea were apparently depicted, sometimes, as a man covered with the skin of a fish, and this representation, as likewise the name of his temple E-apsu, "house of the watery deep", points decidedly to his original character as a god of the waters (see Oannes). Around the excavation of the 18 shrines found on the spot, thousands of carp bones were found, consumed possibly in feasts to the god. Of his cult at Eridu, which goes back to the oldest period of Mesopotamian history, nothing definite is known except that his temple was also associated with Ninhursag's temple which was called Esaggila, "the lofty head house" (E, house, sag, head, ila, high; or Akkadian goddess = Ila), a name shared with Marduk's temple in Babylon, pointing to a staged tower or ziggurat (as with the temple of Enlil at Nippur, which was known as E-kur (kur, hill)), and that incantations, involving ceremonial rites in which water as a sacred element played a prominent part, formed a feature of his worship. This seems also implicated in the epic of the hieros gamos or sacred marriage of Enki and Ninhursag (above), which seems an etiological myth of the fertilisation of the dry ground by the coming of irrigation water (from Sumerian a, ab, water or semen). The early inscriptions of Urukagina in fact go so far as to suggest that the divine pair, Enki and Ninki, were the progenitors of seven pairs of gods, including Enki as god of Eridu, Enlil of Nippur, and Su'en (or Sin) of Ur, and were themselves the children of An (sky, heaven) and Ki (earth).Template:SfnScript error: No such module "Unsubst". The pool of the Abzu at the front of his temple was adopted also at the temple to Nanna (Akkadian Sin) the Moon, at Ur, and spread from there throughout the Middle East. It is believed to remain today as the sacred pool at Mosques, or as the holy water font in Catholic or Eastern Orthodox churches.Template:SfnScript error: No such module "Unsubst".

Whether Eridu at one time also played an important political role in Sumerian affairs is not certain, though not improbable. At all events the prominence of "Ea" led, as in the case of Nippur, to the survival of Eridu as a sacred city, long after it had ceased to have any significance as a political center. Myths in which Ea figures prominently have been found in Assurbanipal's library, and in the Hattusas archive in Hittite Anatolia. As Ea, Enki had a wide influence outside of Sumer, being equated with El (at Ugarit) and possibly Yah (at Ebla) in the Canaanite 'ilhm pantheon. He is also found in Hurrian and Hittite mythology as a god of contracts, and is particularly favourable to humankind. It has been suggested that etymologically the name Ea comes from the term *hyy (life), referring to Enki's waters as life-giving.[22] Enki/Ea is essentially a god of civilization, wisdom, and culture. He was also the creator and protector of man, and of the world in general. Traces of this version of Ea appear in the Marduk epic celebrating the achievements of this god and the close connection between the Ea cult at Eridu and that of Marduk. The correlation between the two rises from two other important connections: (1) that the name of Marduk's sanctuary at Babylon bears the same name, Esaggila, as that of a temple in Eridu, and (2) that Marduk is generally termed the son of Ea, who derives his powers from the voluntary abdication of the father in favour of his son. Accordingly, the incantations originally composed for the Ea cult were re-edited by the priests of Babylon and adapted to the worship of Marduk, and, similarly, the hymns to Marduk betray traces of the transfer to Marduk of attributes which originally belonged to Ea.

It is, however, as the third figure in the triad (the two other members of which were Anu and Enlil) that Ea acquires his permanent place in the pantheon. To him was assigned the control of the watery element, and in this capacity he becomes the shar apsi; i.e. king of the Apsu or "the abyss". The Apsu was figured as the abyss of water beneath the earth, and since the gathering place of the dead, known as Aralu, was situated near the confines of the Apsu, he was also designated as En -Ki; i.e. "lord of that which is below", in contrast to Anu, who was the lord of the "above" or the heavens. The cult of Ea extended throughout Babylonia and Assyria. We find temples and shrines erected in his honour, e.g. at Nippur, Girsu, Ur, Babylon, Sippar, and Nineveh, and the numerous epithets given to him, as well as the various forms under which the god appears, alike bear witness to the popularity which he enjoyed from the earliest to the latest period of Babylonian-Assyrian history. The consort of Ea, known as Ninhursag, Ki, Uriash Damkina, "lady of that which is below", or Damgalnunna, "big lady of the waters", originally was fully equal with Ea, but in more patriarchal Assyrian and Neo-Babylonian times plays a part merely in association with her lord. Generally, however, Enki seems to be a reflection of pre-patriarchal times, in which relations between the sexes were characterised by a situation of greater gender equality. In his character, he prefers persuasion to conflict, which he seeks to avoid if possible.

Ea and West Semitic deities

In 1964, a team of Italian archaeologists under the direction of Paolo Matthiae of the University of Rome La Sapienza performed a series of excavations of material from the third-millennium BCE city of Ebla. Much of the written material found in these digs was later translated by Giovanni Pettinato. Among other conclusions, he found a tendency among the inhabitants of Ebla, after the reign of Sargon of Akkad, to replace the name of El, king of the gods of the Canaanite pantheon (found in names such as Mikael and Ishmael), with Ia (Mikaia, Ishmaia).[23]

Jean Bottéro (1952)[24] and others[25] suggested that Ia in this case is a West Semitic (Canaanite) way of pronouncing the Akkadian name Ea. Scholars largely reject the theory identifying this Ia with the Israelite theonym YHWH,[26] while explaining how it might have been misinterpreted.[27] Ia has also been compared by William Hallo with the Ugaritic god Yamm ("Sea"), (also called Judge Nahar, or Judge River) whose earlier name in at least one ancient source was Yaw or Ya'aScript error: No such module "Unsubst"..Template:Clarify[28]

Ea was also known as Dagon and Uanna (Grecised Oannes), the first of the Seven Sages.[1]

See also

References

Notes

Template:Reflist

Citations

Template:Reflist

Bibliography

Template:Refbegin

  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Template:Cite thesis
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Template:Cite thesis
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  • Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".

Template:Refend

External links

Template:Sister project Template:Sister project

Template:Sumerian mythology Template:Authority control

  1. a b Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1". p. 324, note 27.
  2. Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
  3. Origins of the ancient constellations: I. The Mesopotamian traditions by J.H. Rogers
  4. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  5. Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
  6. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  7. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named seal
  8. Jacobsen, Thorkild (1970) "Mesopotamian Gods and Pantheons", p. 22
  9. Steinkeller P. (1999) "Priests and Officials", p. 129
  10. van Buren, E.D. (1951) OsNs 21, p. 293Template:Full citation needed
  11. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  12. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  13. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  14. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  15. a b Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  16. Script error: No such module "Footnotes".; Script error: No such module "Footnotes".; Christopher B. Siren (1999) based on John C. Gibson's Canaanite Mythology and S. H. Hooke's Middle Eastern Mythology
  17. "Inanna: Lady of Love and War, Queen of Heaven and Earth, Morning and Evening Star", consulted 25 August 2007 [1]
  18. a b Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  19. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  20. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  21. Lishtar "The Avenging Maiden and the Predator Gardener: a study of Inanna and Shukaletuda" [2]
  22. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  23. Freeman, Tzvi. "Is there evidence of Abraham's revolution? – The Big Picture". Chabad.org. Retrieved 2011-06-06.
  24. Bottero, Jean. "Religion in Ancient Mesopotamia" (University of Chicago Press, 2004) Template:ISBN
  25. Boboula, Ida. "The Great Stag: A Sumerian Deity and Its Affiliations", Fifty-Third General Meeting of the Archaeological Institute of America (1951) in American Journal of Archaeology, Vol. 56, No. 3 (Jul. 1952) 171–178, Template:Jstor
  26. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  27. "Yahweh" in K. van der Toorn, Bob Becking, Pieter Willem van der Horst, Dictionary of Deities and Demons in the Bible (1999), Template:ISBN, p. 911: "his cult at Ebla is a chimera."
  28. Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".