Wiki143:Suspected sock puppets/Father's Wish/report

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Chronological overview

July 19, 2006

  • At 11:39, Script error: No such module "user". made modifications to the Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 1 article[1], an article that describes a future episode of the animated television series, Avatar: The Last Airbender. The changes consisted of changing the title of the episode from "Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 1" to "Journey to Ba Sing Se (Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 1)". The name of the link to the next episode in the series was changed from "Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2" to "Journey to Ba Sing Se (Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2)". This change would have resulted in a redlink, since the actual name of the article was Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2.
  • At 11:45, anonymous user Template:User-multi modified the List of Avatar: The Last Airbender episodes article to modify the name of the episode mentioned above from Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 1 to Journey to Ba Sing Se "Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 1". The same edit modified the name of another future episode of the series from Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2 to The Drill "Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2".[2] and at 11:57, added an entry for a third future article, "Tales of Ba Sing Se". [3]
  • At 14:12, Father's wish added content to the Earth Kingdom article, an article describing a recently broadcast episode of the same series.[6]. The content related to The Serpent's Pass and Waterfall Pond, two locations in the episode.
  • At 14:22, anonymous user Template:User-multi initially reverted the all of the changes to the Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 1 article[7], but then immediately replaced the content [8]. The user then reverted the just change made by Father's Wish to the "next episode" link to the next episode in the infobox, changing the episode title from Journey to Ba Sing Se (Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2) to Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2, possibly to resolve the problem with the redlink.[9]. This user then changed the episode title of the Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2 article in the infobox from "Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2" to "The Drill (Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 2)". [10]. This user then changed the link to the next episode on the City of Walls and Secrets article from (TBA) to Tales of Ba Sing Se, linked to the article.
  • At 15:25, Father's Wish added more location details to the Earth Kingdom article[12], including Ba Sing Se monorail, Ba Sing Se University, Royal Palace, and The Fighting Cliffs.
  • At 15:28, Father's Wish contributed significant plot details [13] to the City of Walls and Secrets article, another future episode of the same series.
  • At 21:40, Script error: No such module "user". reverted all of the edits by the three users [14], [15], and [16] (with the exception of the City of Walls and Secrets article) with the edit summary "references?".
  • At 22:39, Script error: No such module "user". reverted the changes made by Father's Wish and 69.34.208.226 to the City of Walls and Secrets article with the edit summary "revert".[17]

July 20, 2006

  • At 06:36, anonymous user Template:User-multi replaced content that had been reverted by Prototime on the List of Avatar: The Last Airbender episodes article. [18]. The user also added further plot details to the three episodes on that page. [19]. Comparing the version added by this anonymous user to the version prior to the initial revert by Prototime [20] indicates that the content replacement was not a version revert, but entering new information. In particular, the content added by 74.69.151.228 on 7/19/06 at 11:45 about Tales of Ba Sing Se was not replaced.
  • At 07:13, Script error: No such module "user". reverted the 07:09 addition by 70.230.75.48 [23], with the edit summary "apparently you don't listen".
  • At 07:20, user HeirToPendragon removed content on 12 locations in the Earth Kingdom article [24], with the edit summary, "All these locations are unnessary as land marks and most sound made up. I think we should stick to key towns and important locations. Many of these need serious editing.".
  • At 12:32, user Father's Wish reverted HeirToPendragon's deletion of content from the Earth Kingdom article with no edit summary comment.[25]
  • At 19:23, Father's Wish added content to the Trivia section of the Avatar: The Last Airbender article relating to the identity of one of the silhouetted characters in the opening sequence of the show.[37]
  • At 19:25, Script error: No such module "user". added a nonsense comment to the same paragraph in the Avatar: The Last Airbender article that Father's Wish had been modifying.[38]
  • At 19:25, Script error: No such module "user". reverted the changes to the Avatar: The Last Airbender article that had been made by Father's Wish and Belleberly [39] with the edit summary "Revert nonsense.".
  • At 19:32, user HeirToPendragon re-reverted the Earth Kingdom article [41] with the edit summary "Father's Wish, most these locations are pointless information that don't need reiteration on this pagebut on their episodes they surround. You also have no Ba Sing Se proof".
  • At 19:46, user HeirToPendragon removed the nonsense comment added to Avatar: The Last Airbender by Belleberly [42] with the edit summary "just stop, it's not aang".
  • At 20:09, user Father's Wish re-reverted the Earth Kingdom article[43] without comment.
  • At 20:10, user HeirToPendragon re-reverted the Earth Kingdom article [44] without comment.
  • At 20:18, user Father's Wish added content to the Fire Nation article, an article that describes another episode of this same series.[45] The content related to a device called a Tank Train.
  • At 20:24, user HeirToPendragon reverted Father's Wish's addition to the Fire Nation article [46] with the edit summary "Father's Wish stop adding unknown information, it's called Vandalism and we will report you for it".
  • At 21:48, Script error: No such module "user". posted a question on Father's Wish's talk page requesting sources of the information he contributed to Wikipedia.[47]
  • At 22:25, user Redsparta reverted the Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 1 article to the same version reverted to by user Prototime at 21:40 on 7/19/06 [49] with the edit summary "removing unreferenced information".

July 21, 2006

  • At 13:09, Father's Wish responded to Frye2387's talk page question about the source of his contributions with the statement, "I got it from the Nickolodean site (a bit early). For proof, here's a bunch of pictures: [5 pictures listed]. I was gonna put them alongside the descriptions, but then I realized I didn't have a clue how to do that here. Go check Episode 12, you'll see what I mean."[56]. The comments were placed in a section entitled "Verification...or whatever".
  • At 13:34, anonymous user Template:User-multi modified the Father's Wish's talk page and removed the statements about obtaining the information from the Nickolean site and not knowing how to add the photos to the articles.[58]
  • Also at 13:34, Father's wish modified the section title on his talk page to "Verification?".[59] He did not replace the content that had been removed by 68.239.106.106.
  • At 14:19, User Crisu reverted Father's Wish's addition to Avatar: The Last Airbender [60] with the edit summary "Revert trivia until that information has a cited reference".
  • At 16:24, user Frye2387 removed content relating to six locations from the Earth Kingdom article [61] with the edit comment "A forum post does not meet Wikipedia's requirements for a refillable source".
  • At 22:18, user Prototime removed content relating to ten more locations from the Earth Kingdom article [65] with the edit comment "removed a ton of plagiarized info from Nick.com".
  • At 22:27, user Prototime removed content relating to four more locations from the Earth Kingdom article [66] with the edit comment "removed even more plaigarism".

July 22, 2006

  • At 01:03, user Redsparta removed the vandalism added by 71.136.33.225 to the Avatar: The Last Airbender article [67] with the edit summary "revert vandalism".
  • At 03:34, user HeirToPendragon reverted the vandalism added by 202.0.51.222 to Avatar: The Last Airbender[69] with the edit summary "The Airbender is not Aang, if you change it again I will report you".
  • At 10:41, anonymous user 74.69.151.228 added an episode summary to the Secret of the Fire Nation, Part 1 article.[70]. The text was not a recreation of the reverted content that had been previously added by Father's Wish.

Relationship Analysis

Script error: No such module "user". and Script error: No such module "user".

  • Obviously unrelated. The anonymous user was engaged in reverting content added by Father's Wish on July 19.

Script error: No such module "user". and Script error: No such module "user".

  • Likely unrelated. Both users made changes to the Avatar: The Last Airbender article around the same time, and the changes of both users were reverted at the same time by User:Crisu at 19:25 on 7/20/06. Although Belleberly continued to vandalize two more times, he did not re-add any of the content added by Father's Wish. When Father's Wish re-added the content that had been reverted by Crisu, he did not add the vandalism being added to the page by any other users.

Script error: No such module "user". and Script error: No such module "user".

  • Likely unrelated, for the reasons outlined in the Father's Wish vs Belleberly section.

Script error: No such module "user". and anonymous Chicago vandal

  • Likely unrelated.
    • The edits by the Chicago vandal were initially to the List of Avatar: The Last Airbender episodes article, an article that Father's Wish only made one typographical edit at 18:33 on July 20.
    • An anonymous user modified Father's Wish's user page, but the IP address traces to a Verizon user in Washington DC, not Chicago.
Retrieved from "http://debianws.lexgopc.com/wiki143/index.php?title=Wiki143:Suspected_sock_puppets/Father%27s_Wish/report&oldid=3237492"