Talk:Origin of the Albanians

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 3 March 2025 by Tewdar in topic Ancent dna reveals origin of albanians
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Script error: No such module "Banner shell". Template:Contentious topics/talk notice

  1. REDIRECT Template:Archives

Template:Rcat shell User:MiszaBot/config

Winnifrith: "The lack of interest among Slavs for the barren mountains of Northern Albania would explain the survival of Albanian as a language"

So, why are there Slavs in the Carpathians, Alps, Montenegro or Bulgaria? Bebe Mușat (talk) 11:35, 12 December 2024 (UTC)Reply

Restructuring the article: Y/N?

Looking at the way this article is structured, I can't help but notice somewhat of a difference to how the one on the Origin of the Romanians is structured, in particular how that article's section "Theories on the Romanians' ethnogenesis" goes about explaining the theories by first going through the historiography, and then naming theories as "continuity", &c.

Meanwhile, this article lets linguistic considerations take up a lot of space without (from what I've seen) structuring it as "pro-continuity"/"pro-immigrationist" (or something along those lines), which I for once deem not as, uh... "überschaubar" is really the word I'm looking for here (though it might just be me, who knows).

Is there a consensus on whether the above might be taken into consideration, so that the article would then be restructured in a more easily legible way, e.g.

Theories on the Albanians' ethnogenesis

>Historiography: origin of the theories

>Theories of Illyrian/Western Paleo-Balkan continuity

>Immigrationist theories

>Obsolete theories

Anyways, thank you to anyone reading this for taking the time to do so. Lephilologueserbe (talk) 14:30, 15 February 2025 (UTC)Reply

Ancent dna reveals origin of albanians

Why is a pre print which is not peer reviewed on here Jamesjakson10 (talk) 18:09, 3 March 2025 (UTC) Template:Sock voteReply

Sockpuppet makes reasonable complaint? First time for everything I suppose...  Tewdar  23:30, 3 March 2025 (UTC)Reply