Survivor: Palau

Survivor: Palau is the tenth season of the American CBS competitive reality television series Survivor. The season filmed from November 1, 2004, through December 9, 2004, and premiered on February 17, 2005. Filming took place in Koror, Palau. Hosted by Jeff Probst, it consisted of the usual 39 days of gameplay with 20 competitors, the most the series had ever begun with up to that point.

For the second time since the series' premiere, the contestants selected the tribes instead of the producers. The self-selection into two tribes of nine left two contestants not chosen and immediately eliminated from the game. In the game, Koror dominated from the very beginning, winning every immunity challenge and all but three reward challenges. Mid-game, having survived alone at Ulong after the entirety of her tribe had been voted out or eliminated at tribal councils, its last remaining player, Stephenie LaGrossa, received a map to Koror. While the players at the finale spoke of this as a merger, the producers have described Palau as the only season without a merge. In the end, fire lieutenant Tom Westman defeated advertising executive Katie Gallagher in a 6–1 jury vote to become the Sole Survivor.

In addition to host Probst naming this as one of his favorite seasons, he stated that the final immunity challenge was his favorite immunity challenge from any season. He also said Palau was his favorite filming location. Survivor earned a Primetime Emmy Award nomination in 2005.

Contestants

File:Jolanda Jones.jpg

Jolanda Jones

File:Stephenie LaGrossa.jpg

Stephenie LaGrossa

The two tribes were named Ulong (named after Ulong Island, one of Palau's tourist spots) and Koror (named after the capital city of Palau at the time). This was the first (and only) season in Survivor history not to have a merged tribe.

Notable contestants include Miss USA 2002 competitor and Miss Ohio USA 2002 Kim Mullen, Actress Jennifer Lyon, and eventual Texas House of Representatives member, Jolanda Jones.

List of Survivor: Palau contestants

Contestant	Age	From	Tribe		Finish
			Original	Absorbed	Placement	Day
	23	Dallas, Texas	rowspan="2" Template:StribeTemplate:Efn		EliminatedTemplate:Efn	Day 2
	55	Ulysses, Pennsylvania
	38	Houston, Texas	rowspan="4" Template:Stribe		1st voted out	Day 3
	22	Easley, South Carolina	2nd voted out		Day 6
	21	Ventura, California	3rd voted out		Day 8
	25	Huber Heights, Ohio	4th voted out		Day 11
	56	Bellevue, Washington	Template:Stribe		5th voted out	Day 12
	24	New Orleans, Louisiana	rowspan="4" Template:Stribe		6th voted out
	33	Mobile, Alabama	7th voted out		Day 15
	27	Birmingham, Alabama	8th voted out		Day 18
	27	Troy, Alabama	EliminatedTemplate:Efn		Day 21
	32	Athens, Texas	rowspan="2" Template:Stribe	rowspan=9 Template:Stribe	9th voted out 1st jury member	Day 24
	39	Las Vegas, Nevada	Quit 2nd jury member	Day 27
	24	Toms River, New Jersey	Template:Stribe	10th voted out 3rd jury member	Day 30
	27	Chicago, Illinois	rowspan="6" Template:Stribe	11th voted out 4th jury member	Day 33
	46	Solon, Ohio	12th voted out 5th jury member	Day 36
	32	Encino, California	Eliminated 6th jury member	Day 37
	23	Ambridge, Pennsylvania	14th voted out 7th jury member	Day 38
	29	Merced, California	Runner-up	Day 39
	40	Sayville, New York	Sole Survivor

Future appearances

Bobby Jon Drinkard and Stephenie LaGrossa competed again in Survivor: Guatemala. LaGrossa and Tom Westman competed in Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains on the Heroes tribe. LaGrossa is set to compete on Survivor 50: In the Hands of the Fans.

Outside of Survivor, LaGrossa competed on the USA Network reality competition series Snake in the Grass. LaGrossa also competed on the first season of the Peacock reality TV series The Traitors.

Season summary

File:Rock-Islands-Palau-1-2016-aerial-view-Luka-Peternel.jpg

The season was filmed on the island of Koror in Palau.

The twenty players began the game by rowing a boat to shore, with the first player of each gender to reach shore to win immunity. The next day, Jeff Probst announced that they would now pick tribes via a schoolyard pick, with those who had won immunity getting first pick. In addition, the last male and female remaining would immediately leave the game. The two tribes, Koror and Ulong, then participated in the first reward/immunity challenge, with the winner, Koror, deciding to leave their present beach to another one they had not seen.

As the challenges continued, it quickly became apparent that Ulong was the weaker tribe, while strong leadership by Tom and Ian at Koror kept the tribe intact. Ulong would win no immunity challenges and few reward challenges, and Koror's only visit to tribal council was the result of a double-elimination twist. Stephenie and Bobby Jon, the last two members of Ulong, lost the final tribal immunity challenge. Since they were unable to vote, the two faced off in a fire-making challenge with Stephenie emerging victorious. After spending the night alone, she was instructed to travel to Koror, and was absorbed into their tribe.

Koror developed a core group of five – Tom, Ian, Gregg, Jenn, and Katie – and those on the outside saw them as a threat but were unable to break them. Despite making an immediate strong impression on her new tribe, Stephenie was quickly identified as a target due to her strength and for being the outsider. In a twist that would eventually lead to its use in later seasons, one individual immunity challenge required the first player to drop out to spend a night alone on an isolated island. Janu was exiled and found the experience liberating, choosing to quit the game at the next tribal council, effectively sparing Stephenie from being voted out. However, her safety would not last and Stephenie was subsequently voted out.

With six players remaining, Tom and Ian decided to spare Caryn, the last remaining outsider, instead plotting with her to eliminate Gregg for potentially strengthening a bond with Katie after going on a reward together. Despite voting Gregg out, Katie felt betrayed by Ian, and her feelings worsened when Ian took Tom with him on a reward instead of her as he had promised. Ian attempted to make amends but Katie still held harsh feelings towards him. After disposing of Caryn, the final four players opted to allow the next vote to end in a tie between Jenn and Ian, and Ian won the subsequent fire-making challenge.

The final immunity challenge required players to stand on buoys for as long as possible; Katie dropped out early, but both Tom and Ian remained for nearly 12 hours. Ian opted to quit the challenge, conceding immunity to Tom, after Tom played on his remorse for hurting Katie's feelings and breaking his promises to her. Forgoing the usual tribal council, Tom voted Ian out of the game on the spot. At the final tribal council, Tom's leadership and physical ability against Katie's less dominant gameplay led the jury to award Tom the title of Sole Survivor by a vote of 6–1.

Challenge winners and eliminations by episode

Episode			Challenge winner(s)		Eliminated
No.	Title	Original air date	Reward	Immunity	Tribe	Player
1	"This Has Never Happened Before!"	February 17, 2005	rowspan="2" Template:Stribe	IanTemplate:Efn	rowspan="2" Template:Stribe	Jonathan
			JolandaTemplate:Efn	Wanda
			colspan="2" Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Jolanda
2	"Love is in the Air, Rats Are Everywhere"	February 24, 2005	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Ashlee
3	"Dangerous Creatures and Horrible Setbacks"	March 3, 2005	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Jeff
4	"Sumo at Sea"	March 10, 2005	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Kim
5	"The Best and Worst Reward Ever"	March 16, 2005	rowspan="2" Template:Stribe		Template:Stribe	Willard
			IbrehemTemplate:Efn	Template:Stribe	Angie
6	"Jellyfish 'N Chips"	March 23, 2005	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	James
7	"The Great White Shark Hunter"	March 31, 2005	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Ibrehem
8	"Neanderthal Man"	April 7, 2005	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Bobby Jon
9	"I Will Not Give Up"	April 14, 2005	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Tom	rowspan="7" Template:Stribe	Coby
10	"Exile Island"	April 21, 2005	Caryn, Gregg, Janu, Tom	Tom	Janu
11	"I'll Show You How Threatening I Am"	April 28, 2005	Template:Stribe	Ian	Stephenie
12	"We'll Make You Pay"	May 5, 2005	Gregg [Jenn, Katie]	Ian	Gregg
13	"It Could All Backfire"	May 12, 2005	Ian [Tom]	Tom	Caryn
14	"The Ultimate Shock"	May 15, 2005	rowspan=2 Template:Stribe	Tom	Jenn
			Tom	Ian
15	"The Reunion"

In the case of multiple tribes or castaways who win reward or immunity, they are listed in order of finish, or alphabetically where it was a team effort; where one castaway won and invited others, the invitees are in brackets.

Voting history

	No tribes		Original tribes											Absorbed tribe
Episode	1			2	3	4	5			6		7	8	9	10	11	12	13	14
Day	2		3	6	8	11	12			15		18	21	24	27	30	33	36	37			38
Tribe	colspan="2" Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	colspan="2" Template:Stribe	colspan="2" Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe	colspan="3" Template:Stribe	Template:Stribe
Eliminated	Jonathan	Wanda	Jolanda	Ashlee	Jeff	Kim	Willard	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Angie	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	James	Ibrehem	Bobby Jon	Coby	Janu	Stephenie	Gregg	Caryn	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Jenn	Ian
Votes	EliminatedTemplate:Efn		6–3	6–1–1	4–2–1	5–1	8–1	2–2–1	3–0	2–2	2–0	2–1	ChallengeTemplate:Efn	7–1–1	QuitTemplate:Efn	6–1	4–2	4–1	2–2	1–1	ChallengeTemplate:Efn	1–0
Voter	Vote
Tom							Willard							Coby		Stephenie	Gregg	Caryn	Ian	Ian		Ian
Katie							Willard							Coby		Stephenie	Gregg	Caryn	Jenn	Jenn		Template:StribeTemplate:Efn
Ian							Willard							Coby		Stephenie	Gregg	Caryn	Jenn	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn
Jenn							Willard							Coby		Stephenie	Caryn	Caryn	Ian	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn
Caryn							Willard							Coby		Stephenie	Gregg	Ian
Gregg							Willard							Coby		Stephenie	Caryn
Stephenie			Jolanda	Ashlee	Jeff	Kim		Bobby Jon	Angie	Ibrehem	James	Ibrehem	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Coby		Caryn
Janu							Willard							Stephenie
Coby							Willard							Janu
Bobby Jon			Angie	Ashlee	Kim	Kim		Angie	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	James	James	Ibrehem	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn
Ibrehem			Angie	Kim	Jeff	Kim		James	Angie	James	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn	Stephenie
James			Jolanda	Ashlee	Kim	Kim		Angie	Angie	Ibrehem	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn
Angie			Jolanda	Ashlee	Jeff	Kim		Bobby Jon	Template:StribeTemplate:Efn
Willard							Katie
Kim			Jolanda	Ashlee	Jeff	James
Jeff			Jolanda	Ashlee	James
Ashlee			Jolanda	Jeff
Jolanda			Angie
Wanda
Jonathan

Jury vote
Episode	15
Day	39
Finalist	Tom	Katie
Vote	6–1
Juror	Vote
Ian	Template:Ya
Jenn	Template:Ya
Caryn	Template:Ya
Gregg	Template:Ya
Stephenie	Template:Ya
Janu	Template:Ya
Coby		Template:Ya

Reception

Survivor: Palau has generally received praise from fans and critics alike, particularly for the gameplay of winner Tom Westman, and such memorable moments as the "bah-bah-buoy" challenge that lasted almost 12 hours (the longest challenge in American Survivor history), as well as the first-ever "tribe of one" in Survivor history. Host Jeff Probst ranked it as his 4th-favorite in 2010, citing the memorability of the buoy challenge and also calling Westman "one of our greatest winners." Andrea Deiher of Zap2it similarly ranked Palau as #4, saying that LaGrossa "became maybe the toughest woman ever to play the game," and called the buoy challenge "the most epic immunity challenge ever." Tom Santilli of Examiner.com ranked it 7th, saying that it "was one of the strongest [seasons], and featured a very memorable overall cast," adding that the "tribe of one" incident "may be one of the saddest moments in history, and cemented Stephanie in the hearts of many fans." Entertainment Weekly's Dalton Ross ranked it as the ninth-best season of the series, saying that he "loved watching one tribe decimate the other...the challenges may have been Survivors best ever," and although he claimed that everyone "knew Tom would win from episode 1, it was still gripping nonetheless." In 2014, Joe Reid of The Wire ranked it 10th, stating that Westman "went pretty much wire-to-wire in barnstorming this season," and played "Perhaps a perfect game," while also noting that "Stephanie and Bobby Jon won our hearts by surviving the longest on the decimated Ulong tribe, the losingest tribe of all time." In 2015, a poll by Rob Has a Podcast ranked Palau 13th out of 30 with Rob Cesternino ranking this season 9th. This was updated in 2021 during Cesternino's podcast, Survivor All-Time Top 40 Rankings, ranking 18th out of 40. Palau was also ranked 13th on "The Purple Rock Podcast," with the summary stating: "Palau has a lot of things going for it: great challenges, a good cast, an interesting way to start the game, and several great story arcs. All of those factors work into an interesting final episode that make the season memorable and result in an excellent winner." In 2020, Inside Survivor ranked this season 17th out of 40 citing "its wholly unique story—a story unlike any other season that came before or after" with the decimation of the Ulong tribe. In 2024, Nick Caruso of TVLine ranked this season 13th out of 47.

External links

• Official CBS Survivor Palau Website