Wiki143:WikiProject Stub sorting/Proposals/Archive/2005

{{Wikipedia:WikiProject Stub sorting/Proposals/header}} Template:WikiProject Stub sorting proposal archive

Information
WikiProject Stub sorting File:Puzzle stub.svg
Project page	talk
`-` Stub types (sections)	talk
`-` Stub types (full list)	talk
`-` To do	talk
`-` Naming conventions	talk
`-` Redirects category	talk
Wikipedia:Stub	talk
Discussion
Proposals (A)	talk
`-` Current month
Discussion	talk
Criteria (A) (discontinued)	talk
Deletion (Log) (discontinued)	talk
Category Script error: No such module "Navbar".

This is an archive of the stub type proposals from WP:WSS for 2005 and 2006.

For older discussions on this subject, see the Criteria page archive. For discussions from 2007, see Archive 2007.

Note to archivers

When archiving stubs creations, please check to ensure they are listed on the stub type list. If they are not, please list them there when you archive their discussions.

2005

Archive1 summary

Archived August 20th 2005

mining-stub - not created
fictional-character-stub - created as fict-char-stub
bio-book-stub - created
units-stub - not created
google-stub - not created
accounting-stub - created
compu-lang-stub category change - implemented
UK-constituency-stub - created
Wisconsin stubs - created
Horseracing-stub - created
chemist-stub - created
physicist-stub - created
Ireland-bio-stub - created

Archive2 summary

Archived August 27th 2005

aero-corp-stub and telecom-corp-stub - created, along with a number of other xxx-corp-stubs
country-stub|CountryName - created before proposal
Washington State Highway Stub - created before proposal
California-south-geo-stub - created
split of mythology stubs - Euro-myth-stub, Greek-myth-stub, Asia-myth-stub, Africa-myth-stub, Oceania-myth-stub and Americas-myth-stub created

Archive3 summary

Archived September 3rd 2005

Subdivision of food-stub - Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl created.
anthropology-stub - not created
Country category standardization
Primitive-Technology-stub - not created
Template:Tl - created
Template:Tl - created
US-edu-stub and UK-edu-stub - created as Template:Tl and Template:Tl
Battlestar Galactica - not created
Society - not created
More country bios - not created
More geo-stubs - Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Australian and Canadian School Stubs - created as Template:Tl and Template:Tl
Template:Tl - created
Historical Fiction Book Stub - created as Template:Tl
Make firearms-stub a subcat of weapon-stub - done
Northern Ireland stub - created as Template:Tl

Archive4 summary

Archived September 20th 2005

subdivision of broadcasting-stub - continued discussion
first split of English geo-stubs - nine county-geo-stubs created
- discussion on dynamic stubs and redirects
- Template:Tl - created, later deleted
Template:Tl - not created
Reorganisation of US highway stubs - Template:Tl created
Template:Tl - not created
subdivision of Template:Tl - separate France, Netherlands, India, Canada, Japan rail-stubs created
Template:Tl - not created
split of Template:Tl - Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl - not created
Template:Tl - created
Template:Tl - created
Template:Tl and Template:Tl - created
Template:Tl - created
Template:Tl - created
Template:Tl - created
Template:Tl - not created

Discussions:

Template:Tl and Template:Tl
Template:Tl and multi-geo-stubbing
New hierarchy for education stubs - created
Template:Tl - not created

Archive5 summary

Archived: September 30th 2005

Template:Tl - no stub type created - unable to reach consensus on name or scope
Rail stubs
- Template:Tl not created
- Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl proposed during discussion and created
Religion stubs
- New sect stubs discussed but not created
- Template:Tl created
Food stubs
- Template:Tl discussed, found to exist, and formally adopted
- Template:Tl created
- Changing Template:Cl to be a stubless parent category with Template:Tl pointing to new Template:Cl discussed but not adopted
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl not created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl not created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Earth Scientist stubs
- Template:Tl created
  - Template:Tl created
  - Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created

Archive6 summary

Archived: October 3rd 2005

Template:Tl created
More Geo stubs
- Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl Template:Tl, Template:Tl Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl Template:Tl, Template:Tl created
Template:Tl, Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
History stubs
- Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl not created
Haiti stubs
- Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl not created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl not created
Template:Tl, Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Math stubs
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, ((tl|mathlogic-stub}} created
- Template:Tl not created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Latin American bio stubs
- Template:Tl not created
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl created

Archive7 summary

Archived: October 10th 2005

More Geo stubs
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl created
Template:Tl Template:Tl not created
Template:Tl not created
Template:Tl deleted
Split of Template:Tl
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl all created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl not created
Template:Tl created
Discussions
- US state-specific bio-stubs
- Template:Cl vs Template:Cl
- Reorganisation of People stubs subcategories
- Realignment of border between West and Central Africa

Archive8 summary

Archived: October 21st 2005

Split of Template:Tl
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl (created)
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl (not created)
Template:Tl (not created)
Template:Tl (created)
Template:Tl (created)
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl (all created)
Template:Tl (not created)
Template:Tl (created)
split of footyclub-stub
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl (all created)
Template:Tl (created)
CVG stubs
- Template:Tl,Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl (all created)
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl (not created)
Discussions
- Broadcast & TV-related stubs
- CVG stubs (creations listed above)
- "What is a stub?"
- Split of sportbio-stub

Archive9 summary

Archived: October 23rd 2005

Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Cl created for existing Template:Tl
Template:Tl created
Sub types of Template:Tl
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl not created
Template:Tl created
Sub types of Template:Tl
- Template:Tl not created
- Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Sub types of Template:Tl and Template:Tl
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
More actor stub sub types proposed but not created
Template:Tl created
Sub types of Template:Tl
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Africa Union stub not created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Canadian highway stub proposed, proposer pointed towards existing Template:Tl

Archive10 summary

Archived: October 23rd 2005

Template:Tl created
Template:Tl
Split of Template:Tl
- 37 prefecture level geo stub sub types created, 10 more identified as potential future stub types but not created due to lack of stubs
Template:Tl created as replacement for Template:Tl
New sub types of Template:Tl
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl not created
Grutness' October geo-stubs - all created
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl
- Template:Tl
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl
- Template:Tl
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl
Road stubs - discussion of archiving of old proposals, not a proposal
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Sky television stub not created
Template:Tl
New sub types of Template:Tl
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Uncyclopedia Parallel/Parody Article stub not created

Archive11 summary

Archived: November 10th 2005

Splits of Template:Tl and Template:Tl discussed but not created.
Communication science stub not created.
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl all created.
Spliting of Template:Tl suggested; no proposal, discussion, or action taken.
Template:Tl created.
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created, sub types of Template:Tl discussed but creation postponed.
Split of Template:Tl proposed and not created.
Template:Tl created.
Further discussion of Template:Tl; Template:Tl and Template:Tl created.
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl created.
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl not created.
Template:Tl rejected; Template:Tl not created.
Template:Tl created; Template:Tl not created.
Template:Tl created.
Template:Tl created; Template:Tl and Template:Tl not created.
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl created; Template:Tl not created.
Template:Tl rejected but created anyway by anonymous user.
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created.
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created; medical researcher stub proposed but not created.
Further discussion of {tl|Poland-writer-stub}}; Template:Tl and Template:Tl created.
More European writer splits discussed, but no additional templates created.
Template:Tl rejected.
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created.
Further discussion of {tl|Russia-writer-stub}}; Template:Tl and Template:Tl created.
Discussion of reorganisation of stubs relating to Australian cities (reorganisation carried out)

Archive12 summary

Archived on November 26th 2005

Template:Tl and Template:Tl discussed, but not yet created (see below)
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Split of United States history stubs rejected
Automobile stubs split
- split by manufacturer rejected
- Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl created
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
More football (soccer) stub types
- Template:Tl created
- Split of European footy club stubs rejected
Template:Tl created
Initial split of France-geo-stub by region
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
- Names of other stubs to be created once enough stubs exist discussed
Split of Template:Tl into lawyers, judges, and law professors rejected
Initial split of Germany-geo-stub by state
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl
- Names of other stubs to be created once enough stubs exist discussed
Template:Tl created
Split of struct stubs
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl discussed, but not yet created
More geo stub splits
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl created as new country geo stubs
- Template:Tl created as new US geo stub
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl created as new UK geo stubs
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created as new Canada geo stubs
India geo splits
- Template:Tl discovered
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Split of band stubs
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Split of theatre stubs
- Template:Tl created
- changing Template:Tl from being a redirect of Template:Tl to an independent stub discussed but not approved
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created; other war stubs discussed
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created with Template:Tl as a redirect (with some straightening out required on SfD)
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created

Archive13 summary

Archived on November 27th 2005

Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Split of Poland geo stubs discussed; decision made to split by voivodship when they can be shown to have enough stubs
Template:Tl discussed but not created due to too few stubs
Template:Tl discussed but not created due to too few stubs
Template:Tl discussed but not created due to too few stubs
Rename of Russian-hist-stub refered to SfD
Radio stubs reorganization (done in conjunction with SfD)
Template:Tl proposed after having already been created instead of before as it should have
Template:Tl rejected
More England geo stub splits
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl anounced after creation, others proposed but not created
More Europe geo stub types proposed; deferred until more stubs found
Template:Tl Template:Tl, Template:Tl and the redirect Template:Tl created
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Template:Cl created; Template:Tl adopted as an approved stub
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl discussed, but not created due to too few stubs
Last of England geo stubs created
Template:Tl discussed, but not created due to too few stubs
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Musician stubs
- Template:Tl created along with redirect Template:Tl
- Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl created
- Template:Tl created along with redirect Template:Tl
Hawaii-geo-stub discussed, but not yet created (see below)
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Amusement park stub discussed
Ireland geo split begun with Template:Tl and Template:Tl
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl and redirect Template:Tl created
Template:Tl created
Goa and Konkan stubs
- Template:Tl rejected
- Template:Tl discussed, but not created
- Template:Tl and Template:Tl discussed, but not created due to insufficient stubs
Template:Tl moved to Template:Tl and retained as a redirect.

Archive14 summary

Archived on November 28th 2005

Template:Tl discussed, but not created due to lack of stubs
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl sprouted
Template:Tl created
Template:Tl and Template:Tl created
Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
Discussion about the mess in the cvg stubs
A new code for the stub list *B was added to indicate that there exists a related biography stub
Errant comment about the renaming of Template:Tl

Archive15 summary

Archived on December 14th 2005

2006

Archive16 summary

Archived on January 7th and 8th 2006

Archive17 summary

Archived on January 8th and 9th 2006

Archive18 summary

Archived on January 9th 2006

Archive19 summary

Archived on January 12th 2006

Created:

subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:

Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl

subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
Template:Tl announced
Template:Tl
geo-stubs:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl

Approved, but not created:

Template:Tl
Template:Tl or Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
political relative stub
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl:
- Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl, Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl split approved, no details given
Template:Tl split approved, details uncertain

Not created:

Template:Tl
continental subtypes of Template:Tl
subtypes of Template:Tl
some subtypes of Template:Tl
military analyst stub
subtypes of Template:Tl
Template:Tl
Template:Tl
types related to Ancient Egypt (actually, they were created, but were deleted at SFD soon after that)