Red dwarf: Difference between revisions
imported>Cedelmwood m Reverted edit by 24.142.64.12 (talk) to last version by ClueBot NG |
imported>RafaelTLS mNo edit summary |
||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
|commonscat=Red dwarfs | |commonscat=Red dwarfs | ||
|qid=Q5893 | |qid=Q5893 | ||
|Mass= | |Mass={{solar mass|link=y|0.08{{snd}}0.6}} | ||
| | |temp=2,400{{snd}}{{val|fmt=commas|3,900|ul=K}} | ||
|luminosity= | |luminosity={{solar luminosity|link=y|0.0003{{snd}}0.07}} | ||
|head=}} | |head=}} | ||
A '''red dwarf''' is the smallest kind of [[star]] on the [[main sequence]]. Red dwarfs are by far the most common type of [[Fusor (astronomy)|fusing]] star in the [[Milky Way]], at least in the neighborhood of the [[Sun]]. However, due to their low luminosity, individual red dwarfs are not easily observed. | A '''red dwarf''' is the smallest kind of [[star]] on the [[main sequence]]. Red dwarfs are by far the most common type of [[Fusor (astronomy)|fusing]] star in the [[Milky Way]], at least in the neighborhood of the [[Sun]]. However, due to their low luminosity, individual red dwarfs are not easily observed. Not one star that fits the stricter definitions of a red dwarf is visible to the naked eye.<ref>{{cite web |url=http://kencroswell.com/thebrightestreddwarf.html |title=The Brightest Red Dwarf |first=Ken |last=Croswell |access-date=2019-07-10}}</ref> [[Proxima Centauri]], the star nearest to the Sun, is a red dwarf, as are fifty of the [[List of nearest stars|sixty nearest stars]]. According to some estimates, red dwarfs make up three-quarters of the fusing stars in the Milky Way.<ref name="bbcrd2013-04-11">{{cite web |url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-21350899 |title=Exoplanets near red dwarfs suggest another Earth nearer |date=6 February 2013 |first=Jason |last=Palmer |publisher=BBC |access-date=2019-07-10}}</ref> | ||
The coolest red dwarfs near the Sun have a surface temperature of about {{val|2,000|fmt=commas|ul=K}} and the smallest have radii about 9% [[solar radius|that of the Sun]], with masses about 7.5% [[solar mass|that of the Sun]]. These red dwarfs have [[Stellar classification#Spectral types|spectral type]]s of L0 to L2. There is some overlap with the properties of [[brown dwarf]]s, since the most massive brown dwarfs at lower metallicity can be as hot as {{val|3,600|fmt=commas|u=K}} and have late M spectral types. | The coolest red dwarfs near the Sun have a surface temperature of about {{val|2,000|fmt=commas|ul=K}} and the smallest have radii about 9% [[solar radius|that of the Sun]], with masses about 7.5% [[solar mass|that of the Sun]]. These red dwarfs have [[Stellar classification#Spectral types|spectral type]]s of L0 to L2. There is some overlap with the properties of [[brown dwarf]]s, since the most massive brown dwarfs at lower metallicity can be as hot as {{val|3,600|fmt=commas|u=K}} and have late M spectral types. | ||
Definitions and usage of the term "red dwarf" vary | Definitions and usage of the term "red dwarf" vary by how inclusive they are on the hotter and more massive end. One definition is synonymous with stellar M dwarfs, yielding a maximum temperature of {{val|3,900|u=K|fmt=commas}} and {{Solar mass|0.6|link=y}}. Another includes all stellar M-type main-sequence and all [[K-type main-sequence star]]s (K dwarf), yielding a maximum temperature of {{val|5,200|u=K|fmt=commas}} and {{Solar mass|0.8}}. Some definitions include any stellar M dwarf and part of the K dwarf classification. Other definitions are also in use. Many of the coolest, lowest-mass M dwarfs are expected to be brown dwarfs, not true stars, and so those would be excluded from any definition of red dwarf. | ||
Stellar models indicate that red dwarfs less than {{Solar mass|0.35}} are fully [[Convection zone|convective]].<ref name=aaa496_3_787>{{cite journal | Stellar models indicate that red dwarfs less than {{Solar mass|0.35}} are fully [[Convection zone|convective]].<ref name=aaa496_3_787>{{cite journal | ||
| Line 23: | Line 23: | ||
| journal=Astronomy and Astrophysics | volume=496 | issue=3 | pages=787–790 | | journal=Astronomy and Astrophysics | volume=496 | issue=3 | pages=787–790 | ||
|date=March 2009 | doi=10.1051/0004-6361:200811450 | |date=March 2009 | doi=10.1051/0004-6361:200811450 | ||
| bibcode=2009A&A...496..787R |arxiv = 0901.1659 | s2cid=15159121 }}</ref> Hence, the helium produced by the [[thermonuclear fusion]] of hydrogen is constantly remixed throughout the star, avoiding helium buildup at the core, thereby prolonging the period of fusion. | | bibcode=2009A&A...496..787R |arxiv = 0901.1659 | s2cid=15159121 }}</ref> Hence, the helium produced by the [[thermonuclear fusion]] of hydrogen is constantly remixed throughout the star, avoiding helium buildup at the core, thereby prolonging the period of fusion. A low-mass red dwarf therefore develops very slowly, maintaining a constant [[luminosity]] and spectral type for trillions of years, until its fuel is depleted and it turns into a [[blue dwarf (red dwarf stage)|blue dwarf]]. Because of the comparatively short [[age of the universe]], no red dwarfs yet exist at advanced stages of evolution. | ||
==Definition== | ==Definition== | ||
The term "red dwarf" when used to refer to a star does not have a strict definition. One of the earliest uses of the term was in 1915, used simply to contrast "red" dwarf stars | The term "red dwarf" when used to refer to a star does not have a strict definition. One of the earliest uses of the term was in 1915, used simply to contrast "red" dwarf stars with hotter "blue" dwarf stars.<ref name=lindemann>{{cite journal|bibcode=1915Obs....38..299L|title=The age of the Earth|journal=The Observatory|volume=38|pages=299|last1=Lindemann|first1=F. A.|year=1915}}</ref> It became established use, although the definition remained vague.<ref name=edgeworth>{{cite journal|bibcode=1946Natur.157..481E|title=Red Dwarf Stars|journal=Nature|volume=157|issue=3989|pages=481|last1=Edgeworth|first1=K. E.|year=1946|doi=10.1038/157481d0|s2cid=4106298|doi-access=free}}</ref> In terms of which spectral types qualify as red dwarfs, different researchers picked different limits, for example K8–M5<ref name=dyer>{{cite journal|bibcode=1956AJ.....61..228D|title=An analysis of the space motions of red dwarf stars|journal=Astronomical Journal|volume=61|pages=228|last1=Dyer|first1=Edward R.|year=1956|doi=10.1086/107332}}</ref> or "later than K5".<ref name=mumford>{{cite journal|bibcode=1956AJ.....61..224M|title=The motions and distribution of dwarf M stars|journal=Astronomical Journal|volume=61|pages=224|last1=Mumford|first1=George S.|year=1956|doi=10.1086/107331|doi-access=free}}</ref> ''Dwarf M star'', abbreviated dM, was also used, but sometimes it also included stars of spectral type K.<ref name=Vyssotsky>{{cite journal|bibcode=1956AJ.....61..201V|title=Dwarf M stars found spectrophotometrically|journal=Astronomical Journal|volume=61|pages=201|last1=Vyssotsky|first1=A. N.|year=1956|doi=10.1086/107328}}</ref> | ||
In modern usage, the definition of a ''red dwarf'' still varies. When explicitly defined, it typically includes [[Late-type star|late K-]] and early to mid-M-class stars,<ref name=engle>{{cite journal|bibcode=2011ASPC..451..285E|arxiv=1111.2872|title=Red Dwarf Stars: Ages, Rotation, Magnetic Dynamo Activity and the Habitability of Hosted Planets|journal=9th Pacific Rim Conference on Stellar Astrophysics. Proceedings of a Conference Held at Lijiang|volume=451|pages=285|last1=Engle|first1=S. G.|last2=Guinan|first2=E. F.|year=2011}}</ref> but in many cases it is restricted | In modern usage, the definition of a ''red dwarf'' still varies. When explicitly defined, it typically includes [[Late-type star|late K-]] and early to mid-M-class stars,<ref name=engle>{{cite journal|bibcode=2011ASPC..451..285E|arxiv=1111.2872|title=Red Dwarf Stars: Ages, Rotation, Magnetic Dynamo Activity and the Habitability of Hosted Planets|journal=9th Pacific Rim Conference on Stellar Astrophysics. Proceedings of a Conference Held at Lijiang|volume=451|pages=285|last1=Engle|first1=S. G.|last2=Guinan|first2=E. F.|year=2011}}</ref> but in many cases it is restricted to M-class stars.<ref name=heath>{{cite journal|doi=10.1023/A:1006596718708|pmid=10472629|year=1999|last1=Heath|first1=Martin J.|title=Habitability of planets around red dwarf stars|journal=Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere|volume=29|issue=4|pages=405–24|last2=Doyle|first2=Laurance R.|last3=Joshi|first3=Manoj M.|last4=Haberle|first4=Robert M.|bibcode=1999OLEB...29..405H|s2cid=12329736|doi-access=free}}</ref><ref name=farihi>{{cite journal|bibcode=2006ApJ...646..480F|arxiv=astro-ph/0603747|title=White Dwarf-Red Dwarf Systems Resolved with the Hubble Space Telescope. I. First Results|journal=The Astrophysical Journal|volume=646|issue=1|pages=480–492|last1=Farihi|first1=J.|last2=Hoard|first2=D. W.|last3=Wachter|first3=S.|year=2006|doi=10.1086/504683|s2cid=16750158}}</ref> In some cases all K stars are included as red dwarfs,<ref name=petterson>{{cite journal|bibcode=1989A&A...217..187P|title=A spectroscopic survey of red dwarf flare stars|journal=Astronomy and Astrophysics|volume=217|pages=187|last1=Pettersen|first1=B. R.|last2=Hawley|first2=S. L.|year=1989}}</ref> and occasionally even earlier stars.<ref name=alekseev>{{cite journal|bibcode=2002A&A...396..203A|title=Starspots and active regions on the emission red dwarf star LQ Hydrae|journal=Astronomy and Astrophysics|volume=396|pages=203–211|last1=Alekseev|first1=I. Yu.|last2=Kozlova|first2=O. V.|year=2002|doi=10.1051/0004-6361:20021424|doi-access=free}}</ref> | ||
The most recent surveys place the coolest true main-sequence stars into spectral types L2 or L3. At the same time, many objects cooler than about M6 or M7 are brown dwarfs, insufficiently massive to sustain [[Isotopes of hydrogen#Hydrogen-1 (Protium)|hydrogen-1]] fusion.<ref name=dietrich/> This gives a significant overlap in spectral types for red and brown dwarfs. Objects in that spectral range can be difficult to categorize. | The most recent surveys place the coolest true main-sequence stars into spectral types L2 or L3. At the same time, many objects cooler than about M6 or M7 are brown dwarfs, insufficiently massive to sustain [[Isotopes of hydrogen#Hydrogen-1 (Protium)|hydrogen-1]] fusion.<ref name=dietrich/> This gives a significant overlap in spectral types for red and brown dwarfs. Objects in that spectral range can be difficult to categorize. | ||
| Line 39: | Line 39: | ||
| title=Late stages of evolution for low-mass stars | | title=Late stages of evolution for low-mass stars | ||
| publisher=Rochester Institute of Technology | | publisher=Rochester Institute of Technology | ||
| access-date=2019-07-10 }}</ref> As a result, they have relatively low pressures, a low fusion rate, and hence, a low temperature. The energy generated is the product of [[nuclear fusion]] of [[hydrogen]] into [[helium]] by way of the [[Proton–proton chain reaction|proton–proton (PP) chain]] | | access-date=2019-07-10 }}</ref> As a result, they have relatively low pressures, a low fusion rate, and hence, a low temperature. The energy generated is the product of [[nuclear fusion]] of [[hydrogen]] into [[helium]] by way of the [[Proton–proton chain reaction|proton–proton (PP) chain]]. Hence, these stars emit relatively little light, sometimes as little as {{frac|10,000}} that of the Sun, although this would still imply a power output on the order of {{val|10|e=22|u=watts}} (10 trillion gigawatts or 10 [[Metric prefix|ZW]]). Even the largest red dwarfs (for example [[HD 179930]], [[HIP 12961]] and [[Lacaille 8760]]) have only about 10% of the [[Solar luminosity|Sun's luminosity]].<ref>{{cite journal | ||
| | | last1=Chabrier | ||
| | | first1=Gilles | ||
| | | last2=Baraffe | ||
| first2=Isabelle | |||
| last3=Plez | |||
| first3=Bertrand | |||
| title=Mass-Luminosity Relationship and Lithium Depletion for Very Low Mass Stars | | title=Mass-Luminosity Relationship and Lithium Depletion for Very Low Mass Stars | ||
| journal=Astrophysical Journal Letters | | journal=Astrophysical Journal Letters | ||
| Line 49: | Line 52: | ||
| bibcode=1996ApJ...459L..91C | | bibcode=1996ApJ...459L..91C | ||
| doi = 10.1086/309951 | | doi = 10.1086/309951 | ||
| doi-access=free | | doi-access=free | ||
}}</ref> In general, red dwarfs less than {{Solar mass|0.35}} transport energy from the core to the surface by [[convection]]. Convection occurs because of [[Opacity (optics)|opacity]] of the interior, which has a high density compared | }}</ref> In general, red dwarfs less than {{Solar mass|0.35}} transport energy from the core to the surface by [[convection]]. Convection occurs because of the [[Opacity (optics)|opacity]] of the interior, which has a high density compared with the temperature. As a result, energy transfer by [[radiation]] is decreased, and instead convection is the main form of energy transport to the surface of the star. Above this mass, a red dwarf will have a region around its core where convection does not occur.<ref>{{cite book | ||
| first=Thanu | last=Padmanabhan | | first=Thanu | last=Padmanabhan | ||
| date=2001 | pages=96–99 | | date=2001 | pages=96–99 | ||
| Line 58: | Line 61: | ||
[[File:Red dwarf lifetime.png|left|thumb|The predicted main-sequence lifetime of a red dwarf plotted against its mass relative to the Sun.<ref name="Adams2004">{{cite conference | [[File:Red dwarf lifetime.png|left|thumb|The predicted main-sequence lifetime of a red dwarf plotted against its mass relative to the Sun.<ref name="Adams2004">{{cite conference | ||
| | | last1=Adams | first1=Fred C. | ||
| | | last2=Laughlin |first2=Gregory | ||
| last3=Graves |first3=Genevieve J. M. | |||
| title=Red Dwarfs and the End of the Main Sequence | | title=Red Dwarfs and the End of the Main Sequence | ||
| book-title=Gravitational Collapse: From Massive Stars to Planets | | book-title=Gravitational Collapse: From Massive Stars to Planets | ||
| Line 68: | Line 72: | ||
| url=http://www.astroscu.unam.mx/rmaa/RMxAC..22/PDF/RMxAC..22_adams.pdf | | url=http://www.astroscu.unam.mx/rmaa/RMxAC..22/PDF/RMxAC..22_adams.pdf | ||
}}</ref>]] | }}</ref>]] | ||
Because low-mass red dwarfs are fully convective, helium does not accumulate at the core, and compared | Because low-mass red dwarfs are fully convective, helium does not accumulate at the core, and compared with larger stars such as the Sun, they can burn a larger proportion of their hydrogen before leaving the [[main sequence]]. As a result, red dwarfs have estimated lifespans far longer than the present age of the universe, and stars less than {{Solar mass|0.8}} have not had time to leave the main sequence. The lower the mass of a red dwarf, the longer the lifespan. It is believed that the lifespans of these stars exceed the expected 10-billion-year lifespan of the Sun by the third or fourth power of the ratio of the solar mass to their masses; thus, a {{Solar mass|0.1}} red dwarf may continue burning for 10 trillion years.<ref name="richmond"/><ref>{{cite journal | ||
|last1=Adams |first1=Fred C. | |||
|last2=Laughlin |first2=Gregory | |||
|title=A Dying Universe: The Long Term Fate and Evolution of Astrophysical Objects | |title=A Dying Universe: The Long Term Fate and Evolution of Astrophysical Objects | ||
|name-list-style=amp|year=1997|doi=10.1103/RevModPhys.69.337 | |name-list-style=amp|year=1997|doi=10.1103/RevModPhys.69.337 | ||
|journal=Reviews of Modern Physics|volume=69|issue=2|pages=337–372 | |journal=Reviews of Modern Physics|volume=69|issue=2|pages=337–372 | ||
|arxiv=astro-ph/9701131 | |arxiv=astro-ph/9701131 | ||
|bibcode = 1997RvMP...69..337A |s2cid=12173790}}</ref> As the proportion of hydrogen in a red dwarf is consumed, the rate of fusion declines and the core starts to contract. The gravitational energy released by this size reduction is converted into heat, which is carried throughout the star by convection.<ref>{{cite book | first=Theo | last=Koupelis | date=2007 | title=In Quest of the Universe | publisher=Jones & Bartlett Publishers | isbn=978-0-7637-4387-1 | url-access=registration | url=https://archive.org/details/inquestofunivers00koup }}</ref> | |bibcode = 1997RvMP...69..337A |s2cid=12173790 | ||
}}</ref> As the proportion of hydrogen in a red dwarf is consumed, the rate of fusion declines and the core starts to contract. The gravitational energy released by this size reduction is converted into heat, which is carried throughout the star by convection.<ref>{{cite book | first=Theo | last=Koupelis | date=2007 | title=In Quest of the Universe | publisher=Jones & Bartlett Publishers | isbn=978-0-7637-4387-1 | url-access=registration | url=https://archive.org/details/inquestofunivers00koup }}</ref> | |||
{| class="wikitable floatright" style="text-align:center; font-size:smaller;" | {| class="wikitable floatright" style="text-align:center; font-size:smaller;" | ||
| Line 94: | Line 100: | ||
| M3V || 0.37 || 0.361 || 0.016 || style="background-color:#{{Color temperature|3430 |hexval}}"|3,430 || 1.53 | | M3V || 0.37 || 0.361 || 0.016 || style="background-color:#{{Color temperature|3430 |hexval}}"|3,430 || 1.53 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| M4V || 0.23 || 0.274 || 7. | | M4V || 0.23 || 0.274 || {{val|7.2|e=−3}} || style="background-color:#{{Color temperature|3210 |hexval}}"|3,210 || 1.65 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| M5V || 0.162 || 0.196 || 3. | | M5V || 0.162 || 0.196 || {{val|3.0|e=−3}} || style="background-color:#{{Color temperature|3060 |hexval}}"|3,060 || 1.83 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| M6V || 0.102 || 0.137 || 1. | | M6V || 0.102 || 0.137 || {{val|1.0|e=−3}} || style="background-color:#{{Color temperature|2810 |hexval}}"|2,810 || 2.01 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| M7V || 0.090 || 0.120 || 6. | | M7V || 0.090 || 0.120 || {{val|6.5|e=−4}} || style="background-color:#{{Color temperature|2680 |hexval}}"|2,680 || 2.12 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| M8V || 0.085 || 0.114 || 5. | | M8V || 0.085 || 0.114 || {{val|5.2|e=−4}} || style="background-color:#{{Color temperature|2570 |hexval}}"|2,570 || 2.15 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| M9V || 0.079 || 0.102 || 3. | | M9V || 0.079 || 0.102 || {{val|3.0|e=−4}} || style="background-color:#{{Color temperature|2380 |hexval}}"|2,380 || 2.17 | ||
|} | |} | ||
According to computer simulations, the minimum mass a red dwarf must have to eventually evolve into a [[red giant]] is {{Solar mass|0.25}}; less massive objects, as they age, would increase their surface temperatures and luminosities becoming [[Blue dwarf (red-dwarf stage)|blue dwarfs]] and finally [[white dwarf]]s.<ref name="Adams2004" /> | According to computer simulations, the minimum mass a red dwarf must have to eventually evolve into a [[red giant]] is {{Solar mass|0.25}}; less massive objects, as they age, would increase their surface temperatures and luminosities, becoming [[Blue dwarf (red-dwarf stage)|blue dwarfs]] and finally [[white dwarf]]s.<ref name="Adams2004" /> | ||
The less massive the star, the longer this evolutionary process takes. A {{Solar mass|0.16}} red dwarf (approximately the mass of the nearby [[Barnard's Star]]) would stay on the main sequence for 2.5 trillion years, followed by five billion years as a blue dwarf, during which the star would have one third of the [[Solar luminosity|Sun's luminosity]] ({{Solar luminosity|link=y}}) and a surface temperature of 6,500–8,500 [[kelvin]]s.<ref name="Adams2004" /> | The less massive the star, the longer this evolutionary process takes. A {{Solar mass|0.16}} red dwarf (approximately the mass of the nearby [[Barnard's Star]]) would stay on the main sequence for 2.5 trillion years, followed by five billion years as a blue dwarf, during which the star would have one third of the [[Solar luminosity|Sun's luminosity]] ({{Solar luminosity|link=y}}) and a surface temperature of 6,500–8,500 [[kelvin]]s.<ref name="Adams2004" /> | ||
The fact that red dwarfs and other low-mass stars | The fact that red dwarfs and other low-mass stars remain on the main sequence when more massive stars have moved off the main sequence allows the age of [[star cluster]]s to be estimated by finding the mass at which the stars move off the main sequence. This provides a lower limit to the age of the [[Universe]] and also allows formation timescales to be placed upon the structures within the [[Milky Way]], such as the [[Galactic spheroid|Galactic halo]] and [[Galactic plane|Galactic disk]]. | ||
All observed red dwarfs contain [[Metallicity|"metals"]], | All observed red dwarfs contain [[Metallicity|"metals"]], defined in astronomy as elements heavier than hydrogen and helium. The [[Big Bang]] model predicts that the first generation of stars should have only hydrogen, helium, and trace amounts of lithium, and hence would be of low metallicity. With their extreme lifespans, any red dwarfs that were a part of that first generation ([[population III stars]]) should still exist today. Low-metallicity red dwarfs, however, are rare. The accepted model for the chemical evolution of the universe anticipates such a scarcity of metal-poor dwarf stars because only giant stars are thought to have formed in the metal-poor environment of the early universe.{{why|date=December 2023}} As giant stars end their short lives in [[supernova]] explosions, they spew out the heavier elements needed to form smaller stars. Therefore, dwarfs became more common as the universe aged and became enriched in metals. While the basic scarcity of ancient metal-poor red dwarfs is expected, observations have detected even fewer than predicted. The sheer difficulty of detecting objects as dim as red dwarfs was thought to account for this discrepancy, but improved detection methods have only confirmed the discrepancy.<ref>{{cite news |url=https://astrobites.org/2012/02/15/and-now-theres-a-problem-with-m-dwarfs-too/ |title=And now there's a problem with M dwarfs, too |first=Elisabeth |last=Newton |newspaper=[[Astrobites]] |date=Feb 15, 2012 |access-date=2019-07-10}}</ref> | ||
The boundary between the least massive red dwarfs and the most massive brown dwarfs depends strongly on the metallicity. At solar metallicity the boundary occurs at about {{solar mass|0.07}}, while at zero metallicity the boundary is around {{solar mass|0.09}}. At solar metallicity, the least massive red dwarfs theoretically have temperatures around {{val|1,700|fmt=commas|ul=K}}, while measurements of red dwarfs in the solar neighbourhood suggest the coolest stars have temperatures of about {{val|2,075|fmt=commas|u=K}} and spectral classes of about L2. Theory predicts that the coolest red dwarfs at zero metallicity would have temperatures of about {{val|3,600|fmt=commas|u=K}}. The least massive red dwarfs have radii of about {{solar radius|0.09}}, while both more massive red dwarfs and less massive brown dwarfs are larger.<ref name=dietrich> | The boundary between the least massive red dwarfs and the most massive brown dwarfs depends strongly on the metallicity. At solar metallicity the boundary occurs at about {{solar mass|0.07}}, while at zero metallicity the boundary is around {{solar mass|0.09}}. At solar metallicity, the least massive red dwarfs theoretically have temperatures around {{val|1,700|fmt=commas|ul=K}}, while measurements of red dwarfs in the solar neighbourhood suggest the coolest stars have temperatures of about {{val|2,075|fmt=commas|u=K}} and spectral classes of about L2. Theory predicts that the coolest red dwarfs at zero metallicity would have temperatures of about {{val|3,600|fmt=commas|u=K}}. The least massive red dwarfs have radii of about {{solar radius|0.09}}, while both more massive red dwarfs and less massive brown dwarfs are larger.<ref name=dietrich> | ||
| Line 139: | Line 145: | ||
In the mid-1970s, red dwarf standard stars were published by Keenan & McNeil (1976)<ref>{{cite book |last1=Keenan |first1=Philip Childs |last2=McNeil |first2=Raymond C. |year=1976 |title=An atlas of spectra of the cooler stars: Types G, K, M, S, and C. Part 1: Introduction and tables |place=Columbus, OH |publisher=Ohio State University Press |bibcode=1976aasc.book.....K}}</ref> and Boeshaar (1976),<ref>{{cite thesis |last1=Boeshaar |first1=P.C. |year=1976 |title=The spectral classification of M dwarf stars |degree=Ph.D. |publisher=Ohio State University |place=Columbus, OH |bibcode=1976PhDT........14B}}</ref> but there was little agreement among the standards. As later cooler stars were identified through the 1980s, it was clear that an overhaul of the red dwarf standards was needed. Building primarily upon the Boeshaar standards, a group at Steward Observatory (Kirkpatrick, Henry, & McCarthy, 1991)<ref name="ReferenceA"/> filled in the spectral sequence from K5V to M9V. It is these M type dwarf standard stars which have largely survived as the main standards to the modern day. There have been negligible changes in the red dwarf spectral sequence since 1991. Additional red dwarf standards were compiled by Henry et al. (2002),<ref>{{cite journal |bibcode=2002AJ....123.2002H |title=The Solar neighborhood. VI. New southern nearby stars identified by optical spectroscopy |journal=The Astronomical Journal |volume=123 |issue=4 |page=2002 |last1=Henry |first1=Todd J .|author-link2=Lucianne Walkowicz |last2=Walkowicz |first2=Lucianne M. |last3=Barto |first3=Todd C. |last4=Golimowski |first4=David A. |year=2002 |doi=10.1086/339315 |arxiv = astro-ph/0112496|s2cid=17735847 }}</ref> and D. Kirkpatrick has recently | In the mid-1970s, red dwarf standard stars were published by Keenan & McNeil (1976)<ref>{{cite book |last1=Keenan |first1=Philip Childs |last2=McNeil |first2=Raymond C. |year=1976 |title=An atlas of spectra of the cooler stars: Types G, K, M, S, and C. Part 1: Introduction and tables |place=Columbus, OH |publisher=Ohio State University Press |bibcode=1976aasc.book.....K}}</ref> and Boeshaar (1976),<ref>{{cite thesis |last1=Boeshaar |first1=P.C. |year=1976 |title=The spectral classification of M dwarf stars |degree=Ph.D. |publisher=Ohio State University |place=Columbus, OH |bibcode=1976PhDT........14B}}</ref> but there was little agreement among the standards. As later cooler stars were identified through the 1980s, it was clear that an overhaul of the red dwarf standards was needed. Building primarily upon the Boeshaar standards, a group at Steward Observatory (Kirkpatrick, Henry, & McCarthy, 1991)<ref name="ReferenceA"/> filled in the spectral sequence from K5V to M9V. It is these M type dwarf standard stars which have largely survived as the main standards to the modern day. There have been negligible changes in the red dwarf spectral sequence since 1991. Additional red dwarf standards were compiled by Henry et al. (2002),<ref>{{cite journal |bibcode=2002AJ....123.2002H |title=The Solar neighborhood. VI. New southern nearby stars identified by optical spectroscopy |journal=The Astronomical Journal |volume=123 |issue=4 |page=2002 |last1=Henry |first1=Todd J .|author-link2=Lucianne Walkowicz |last2=Walkowicz |first2=Lucianne M. |last3=Barto |first3=Todd C. |last4=Golimowski |first4=David A. |year=2002 |doi=10.1086/339315 |arxiv = astro-ph/0112496|s2cid=17735847 }}</ref> and D. Kirkpatrick has recently | ||
reviewed the classification of red dwarfs and standard stars in Gray & Corbally's 2009 monograph.<ref>{{cite book |last1=Gray |first1=Richard O. |last2=Corbally |first2=Christopher |year=2009 |title=Stellar Spectral Classification |publisher=Princeton University Press |bibcode=2009ssc..book.....G}}</ref> The M dwarf primary spectral standards are: [[GJ 270]] (M0V), [[GJ 229A]] (M1V), [[Lalande 21185]] (M2V), [[Gliese 581]] (M3V), [[Gliese 402]] (M4V), [[GJ 51]] (M5V), [[Wolf 359]] (M6V), [[van Biesbroeck 8]] (M7V), [[VB 10]] (M8V), [[LHS 2924]] (M9V). | reviewed the classification of red dwarfs and standard stars in Gray & Corbally's 2009 monograph.<ref>{{cite book |last1=Gray |first1=Richard O. |last2=Corbally |first2=Christopher |year=2009 |title=Stellar Spectral Classification |publisher=Princeton University Press |bibcode=2009ssc..book.....G}}</ref> The M dwarf primary spectral standards are: [[GJ 270]] (M0V), [[GJ 229A]] (M1V), [[Lalande 21185]] (M2V), [[Gliese 581]] (M3V), [[Gliese 402]] (M4V), [[GJ 51]] (M5V), [[Wolf 359]] (M6V), [[van Biesbroeck 8]] (M7V), [[VB 10]] (M8V), [[LHS 2924]] (M9V). | ||
== Planet formation == | |||
[[File:HH30 Webb investigates a dusty and dynamic disc (potm2501a).jpg|thumb|Image of the edge-on disk around the low-mass star [[HH 30]] with the [[James Webb Space Telescope]].]] | |||
Gas-rich disks ([[Protoplanetary disk|protoplanetary disks]]) have been detected around low-mass stars and brown dwarfs with ages as high as around 45 Myrs. This is unusual as more massive stars usually don't show primordial disks beyond 10 Myrs. These old disks have been dubbed [[Peter Pan disk|Peter Pan disks]], with [[WISE J080822.18-644357.3|J0808]] being the prototype.<ref name="Silverberg2020">{{cite journal |last1=Silverberg |first1=Steven M. |last2=Wisniewski |first2=John P. |last3=Kuchner |first3=Marc J. |last4=Lawson |first4=Kellen D. |last5=Bans |first5=Alissa S. |last6=Debes |first6=John H. |last7=Biggs |first7=Joseph R. |last8=Bosch |first8=Milton K. D. |last9=Doll |first9=Katharina |last10=Luca |first10=Hugo A. Durantini |last11=Enachioaie |first11=Alexandru |last12=Hamilton |first12=Joshua |last13=Holden |first13=Jonathan |last14=Hyogo |first14=Michiharu |last15=the Disk Detective Collaboration |date=2020-01-14 |title=Peter Pan Disks: Long-lived Accretion Disks Around Young M Stars |journal=The Astrophysical Journal |volume=890 |issue=2 |page=106 |arxiv=2001.05030 |bibcode=2020ApJ...890..106S |doi=10.3847/1538-4357/ab68e6 |s2cid=210718358 |doi-access=free}}</ref> The long presence of gas in the disk could enable the formation of [[Resonant chain|resonant chains]], such as seen in [[TRAPPIST-1]].<ref name="Gaidos2022">{{Cite journal |last1=Gaidos |first1=Eric |last2=Mann |first2=Andrew W. |last3=Rojas-Ayala |first3=Bárbara |last4=Feiden |first4=Gregory A. |last5=Wood |first5=Mackenna L. |last6=Narayanan |first6=Suchitra |last7=Ansdell |first7=Megan |last8=Jacobs |first8=Tom |last9=LaCourse |first9=Daryll |date=2022-07-01 |title=Planetesimals around stars with TESS (PAST) - II. An M dwarf 'dipper' star with a long-lived disc in the TESS continuous viewing zone |journal=Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society |volume=514 |issue=1 |pages=1386–1402 |arxiv=2204.14163 |bibcode=2022MNRAS.514.1386G |doi=10.1093/mnras/stac1433 |issn=0035-8711 |doi-access=free}}</ref> It is thought that only some will reach this high age and most will dissipate after 5 Myrs. The environment can play a role in the disk lifetime, such as [[stellar flyby|stellar flybys]] and external [[photoevaporation]], which can result in ionized [[proplyds]].<ref name="Pfalzner2024">{{Cite journal |last1=Pfalzner |first1=Susanne |last2=Dincer |first2=Furkan |date=2024-03-01 |title=Low-mass Stars: Their Protoplanetary Disk Lifetime Distribution |journal=The Astrophysical Journal |volume=963 |issue=2 |pages=122 |arxiv=2401.03775 |bibcode=2024ApJ...963..122P |doi=10.3847/1538-4357/ad1bef |issn=0004-637X |doi-access=free}}</ref> Some edge-on protoplanetary disks around early M-stars are resolved, such as [[2MASS J04202144+2813491|Tau 042021]] and [[HH 30]]. These show [[Astrophysical jet|jets]] and more recently [[Disk wind|disk winds]] in [[NIRCam]] and [[NIRSpec]] observations. The disk wind is an important part in removal of mass from the disk and [[Accretion (astrophysics)|accretion]] of material onto the surface of stars.<ref name="Pascucci2024">{{Cite journal |last1=Pascucci |first1=Ilaria |last2=Beck |first2=Tracy L. |last3=Cabrit |first3=Sylvie |last4=Bajaj |first4=Naman S. |last5=Edwards |first5=Suzan |last6=Louvet |first6=Fabien |last7=Najita |first7=Joan R. |last8=Skinner |first8=Bennett N. |last9=Gorti |first9=Uma |last10=Salyk |first10=Colette |last11=Brittain |first11=Sean D. |last12=Krijt |first12=Sebastiaan |last13=Muzerolle Page |first13=James |last14=Ruaud |first14=Maxime |last15=Schwarz |first15=Kamber |date=2024-10-01 |title=The nested morphology of disk winds from young stars revealed by JWST/NIRSpec observations |journal=Nature Astronomy |volume=9 |pages=81–89 |arxiv=2410.18033 |bibcode=2025NatAs...9...81P |doi=10.1038/s41550-024-02385-7 |issn=2397-3366}}</ref><ref name="Duchêne2024">{{Cite journal |last1=Duchêne |first1=Gaspard |last2=Ménard |first2=François |last3=Stapelfeldt |first3=Karl R. |last4=Villenave |first4=Marion |last5=Wolff |first5=Schuyler G. |last6=Perrin |first6=Marshall D. |last7=Pinte |first7=Christophe |last8=Tazaki |first8=Ryo |last9=Padgett |first9=Deborah L. |date=2024-02-01 |title=JWST Imaging of Edge-on Protoplanetary Disks. I. Fully Vertically Mixed 10 μm Grains in the Outer Regions of a 1000 au Disk |journal=The Astronomical Journal |volume=167 |issue=2 |pages=77 |arxiv=2309.07040 |bibcode=2024AJ....167...77D |doi=10.3847/1538-3881/acf9a7 |issn=0004-6256 |doi-access=free}}</ref> | |||
Observations with the [[Mid-Infrared Instrument]] has advanced the study of the composition of the inner part of primordial disks around late M-dwarfs. Studies found either [[hydrocarbon]]-rich composition (e.g. [[2MASS J1605–1933]],<ref name="Tabone2023">{{Cite journal |last1=Tabone |first1=B. |last2=Bettoni |first2=G. |last3=van Dishoeck |first3=E. F. |last4=Arabhavi |first4=A. M. |last5=Grant |first5=S. |last6=Gasman |first6=D. |last7=Henning |first7=Th |last8=Kamp |first8=I. |last9=Güdel |first9=M. |last10=Lagage |first10=P. O. |last11=Ray |first11=T. |last12=Vandenbussche |first12=B. |last13=Abergel |first13=A. |last14=Absil |first14=O. |last15=Argyriou |first15=I. |date=July 2023 |title=A rich hydrocarbon chemistry and high C to O ratio in the inner disk around a very low-mass star |journal=Nature Astronomy |language=en |volume=7 |issue=7 |pages=805–814 |arxiv=2304.05954 |bibcode=2023NatAs...7..805T |doi=10.1038/s41550-023-01965-3 |issn=2397-3366}}</ref> [[ISO-ChaI 147]],<ref name="Arabhavi2023">{{Cite journal |last1=Arabhavi |first1=A. M. |last2=Kamp |first2=I. |last3=Henning |first3=Th. |last4=van Dishoeck |first4=E. F. |last5=Christiaens |first5=V. |last6=Gasman |first6=D. |last7=Perrin |first7=A. |last8=Güdel |first8=M. |last9=Tabone |first9=B. |last10=Kanwar |first10=J. |last11=Waters |first11=L. B. F. M. |last12=Pascucci |first12=I. |last13=Samland |first13=M. |last14=Perotti |first14=G. |last15=Bettoni |first15=G. |date=2024-06-07 |title=Abundant hydrocarbons in the disk around a very-low-mass star |journal=Science |volume=384 |issue=6700 |pages=1086–1090 |arxiv=2406.14293 |bibcode=2024Sci...384.1086A |doi=10.1126/science.adi8147|pmid=38843318 }}</ref> [[WISEA J044634.16-262756.1|J0446B]]<ref name="Long2024">{{Cite journal |last1=Long 龙 |first1=Feng 凤. |last2=Pascucci |first2=Ilaria |last3=Houge |first3=Adrien |last4=Banzatti |first4=Andrea |last5=Pontoppidan |first5=Klaus M. |last6=Najita |first6=Joan |last7=Krijt |first7=Sebastiaan |last8=Xie |first8=Chengyan |last9=Williams |first9=Joe |last10=Herczeg 沈 |first10=Gregory J. 雷歌 |last11=Andrews |first11=Sean M. |last12=Bergin |first12=Edwin |last13=Blake |first13=Geoffrey A. |last14=Colmenares |first14=María José |last15=Harsono |first15=Daniel |date=2025 |title=The First JWST View of a 30-Myr-old Protoplanetary Disk Reveals a Late-stage Carbon-rich Phase |journal=The Astrophysical Journal Letters |volume=978 |issue=2 |pages=L30 |arxiv=2412.05535 |bibcode=2025ApJ...978L..30L |doi=10.3847/2041-8213/ad99d2 |doi-access=free |last16=Romero-Mirza |first16=Carlos E. |last17=Li 李 |first17=Rixin 日新 |last18=Lu |first18=Cicero X. |last19=Pinilla |first19=Paola |last20=Wilner |first20=David J. |last21=Vioque |first21=Miguel |last22=Zhang |first22=Ke |collaboration=JDISCS Collaboration}}</ref>) or [[water]]-rich composition (e.g. [[Sz 114]]<ref name="Xie2023">{{Cite journal |last1=Xie |first1=Chengyan |last2=Pascucci |first2=Ilaria |last3=Long |first3=Feng |last4=Pontoppidan |first4=Klaus M. |last5=Banzatti |first5=Andrea |last6=Kalyaan |first6=Anusha |last7=Salyk |first7=Colette |last8=Liu |first8=Yao |last9=Najita |first9=Joan R. |last10=Pinilla |first10=Paola |last11=Arulanantham |first11=Nicole |last12=Herczeg |first12=Gregory J. |last13=Carr |first13=John |last14=Bergin |first14=Edwin A. |last15=Ballering |first15=Nicholas P. |date=2023-12-01 |title=Water-rich Disks around Late M Stars Unveiled: Exploring the Remarkable Case of Sz 114 |journal=The Astrophysical Journal Letters |language=en |volume=959 |issue=2 |pages=L25 |arxiv=2310.13205 |bibcode=2023ApJ...959L..25X |doi=10.3847/2041-8213/ad0ed9 |doi-access=free |issn=2041-8205 }}</ref>). The disks show a trend from [[oxygen]]-rich in younger disks to [[carbon]]-rich in older disks. [[Silicate mineral|Silicates]] are also detected for some disks.<ref name="Arabhavi2025">{{cite journal |arxiv=2506.02748 |last1=Arabhavi |first1=A. M. |last2=Kamp |first2=I. |last3=Henning |first3=Th. |last4=van Dishoeck |first4=E. F. |last5=Jang |first5=H. |last6=Waters |first6=L. B. F. M. |last7=Christiaens |first7=V. |last8=Gasman |first8=D. |last9=Pascucci |first9=I. |last10=Perotti |first10=G. |last11=Grant |first11=S. L. |last12=Güdel |first12=M. |last13=Lagage |first13=P. -O. |last14=Barrado |first14=D. |last15=Caratti o Garatti |first15=A. |last16=Lahuis |first16=F. |last17=Kaeufer |first17=T. |last18=Kanwar |first18=J. |last19=Morales-Calderón |first19=M. |last20=Schwarz |first20=K. |last21=Sellek |first21=A. D. |last22=Tabone |first22=B. |last23=Temmink |first23=M. |last24=Vlasblom |first24=M. |last25=Patapis |first25=P. |title=MINDS: The very low-mass star and brown dwarf sample. Detections and trends in the inner disk gas |journal=Astronomy & Astrophysics |date=2025 |volume=699 |pages=A194 |doi=10.1051/0004-6361/202554109 |bibcode=2025A&A...699A.194A }}</ref> This is explained with a model of inwards drifting material. At first water-ice-rich pebbles drift inwards, increasing the amount of oxygen in the inner disk. Then carbon-rich vapour drifts inwards and increases the amount of carbon in the inner disk. This process is more efficient in very low-mass stars because the icy outer part is closer to the inner disk.<ref name="Mah2023">{{Cite journal |last1=Mah |first1=Jingyi |last2=Bitsch |first2=Bertram |last3=Pascucci |first3=Ilaria |last4=Henning |first4=Thomas |date=2023-09-01 |title=Close-in ice lines and the super-stellar C/O ratio in discs around very low-mass stars |journal=Astronomy & Astrophysics |language=en |volume=677 |pages=L7 |arxiv=2308.15128 |bibcode=2023A&A...677L...7M |doi=10.1051/0004-6361/202347169 |issn=0004-6361}}</ref> This trend of carbon-rich disks is also present in [[Brown dwarf|brown dwarfs]] and [[Planetary-mass object|planetary-mass objects]]. The brown dwarf [[2M1207]] has a disk rich in hydrocarbons,<ref name="Arabhavi2025" /> and the planetary-mass object [[Cha 1107−7626]] also shows hydrocarbons in the disk.<ref name="Flagg2025">{{Cite journal |arxiv=2505.13714 |first1=Laura |last1=Flagg |first2=Aleks |last2=Scholz |title=Detection of Hydrocarbons in the Disk around an Actively-Accreting Planetary-Mass Object |date=2025 |last3=Almendros-Abad |first3=V. |last4=Jayawardhana |first4=Ray |last5=Damian |first5=Belinda |last6=Muzic |first6=Koraljka |last7=Natta |first7=Antonella |last8=Pinilla |first8=Paola |last9=Testi |first9=Leonardo |journal=The Astrophysical Journal |volume=986 |issue=2 |page=200 |doi=10.3847/1538-4357/add71d |doi-access=free |bibcode=2025ApJ...986..200F }}</ref> This composition could influence the composition of the planets formed within these disks, especially their [[Atmosphere|atmospheres]]. If close-in planets accrete their atmospheres early, they could have a low C/O ratio (low amounts of carbon, high amounts of oxygen). If they accrete their atmospheres late, their atmospheres could have a high C/O ratio (similar to [[Titan (moon)|Titan]]).<ref name="Mah2023" /> The removal of carbon from the solids could also result in carbon-poor composition of the soldis (core/mantle/crust) in [[Terrestrial planet|rocky planets]].<ref name="Arabhavi2023" /><ref name="Long2024" /> | |||
After the primordial gas is removed, the system is left with a [[debris disk]]. Examples of debris disks around red dwarfs are [[AU Microscopii]], [[CE Antliae]] and [[Fomalhaut C]]. | |||
==Planets== | ==Planets== | ||
| Line 152: | Line 166: | ||
}}</ref> | }}</ref> | ||
At least four and possibly up to six exoplanets were discovered orbiting within the [[Gliese 581 planetary system|Gliese 581 planetary system]] between 2005 and 2010. One planet has about the mass of [[Neptune]], or 16 [[Earth mass]]es ({{Earth mass| | At least four and possibly up to six exoplanets were discovered orbiting within the [[Gliese 581 planetary system|Gliese 581 planetary system]] between 2005 and 2010. One planet has about the mass of [[Neptune]], or 16 [[Earth mass]]es ({{Earth mass|sym=y}}). It orbits just {{Convert|6|e6km|AU|lk=on}} from its star, and is estimated to have a surface temperature of {{cvt|150|C|K F|lk=on}}, despite the dimness of its star. In 2006, an even smaller exoplanet (only {{Earth mass|sym=y|5.5}}) was found orbiting the red dwarf [[OGLE-2005-BLG-390L]]; it lies {{convert|390|e6km|AU}} from the star and its surface temperature is {{cvt|−220|C|K F}}. | ||
In 2007, a new, potentially [[planetary habitability|habitable]] exoplanet, {{nowrap|[[Gliese 581c]]}}, was found, orbiting [[Gliese 581]]. The minimum mass estimated by its discoverers (a team led by [[Stephane Udry]]) is {{Earth mass|5.36}}. The discoverers estimate its radius to be 1.5 times that of Earth ({{Earth radius|link=y}}). Since then [[Gliese 581d]], which is also potentially habitable, was discovered. | In 2007, a new, potentially [[planetary habitability|habitable]] exoplanet, {{nowrap|[[Gliese 581c]]}}, was found, orbiting [[Gliese 581]]. The minimum mass estimated by its discoverers (a team led by [[Stephane Udry]]) is {{Earth mass|5.36|sym=y}}. The discoverers estimate its radius to be 1.5 times that of Earth ({{Earth radius|link=y}}). Since then [[Gliese 581d]], which is also potentially habitable, was discovered. | ||
Gliese 581c and d are within the [[habitable zone]] of the host star, and are two of the most likely candidates for habitability of any exoplanets discovered so far.<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.space.com/scienceastronomy/070424_hab_exoplanet.html |title=Major discovery: New planet could harbor water and life | | Gliese 581c and d are within the [[habitable zone]] of the host star, and are two of the most likely candidates for habitability of any exoplanets discovered so far.<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.space.com/scienceastronomy/070424_hab_exoplanet.html |title=Major discovery: New planet could harbor water and life |last=Than |first=Ker |date=24 April 2007 |publisher=SPACE.com |access-date=2019-07-10}}</ref> [[Gliese 581g]], detected September 2010,<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.physorg.com/news204999128.html |title=Scientists find potentially habitable planet near Earth |publisher=Physorg.com |access-date=2013-03-26}}</ref> has a near-circular orbit in the middle of the star's habitable zone. However, the planet's existence is contested.<ref>{{cite journal |last1=Tuomi |first1=M. |date=2011 |title=Bayesian re-analysis of the radial velocities of Gliese 581. Evidence in favour of only four planetary companions |journal=Astronomy & Astrophysics |volume=528 |pages=L5 |arxiv=1102.3314 |doi=10.1051/0004-6361/201015995 |bibcode=2011A&A...528L...5T|s2cid=11439465 }}</ref> | ||
On 23 February 2017 NASA announced the discovery of seven Earth-sized planets orbiting the red dwarf star [[TRAPPIST-1]] approximately 39 light-years away in the constellation Aquarius. The planets were discovered through the transit method, meaning we have mass and radius information for all of them. [[TRAPPIST-1e]], [[TRAPPIST-1f|f]], and [[TRAPPIST-1g|g]] appear to be within the habitable zone and may have liquid water on the surface.<ref>{{cite web |url=https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-telescope-reveals-largest-batch-of-earth-size-habitable-zone-planets-around |website=www.nasa.gov |title=NASA telescope reveals record-breaking exoplanet discovery |date=2017-02-22 |df=dmy-all}}</ref> | On 23 February 2017 NASA announced the discovery of seven Earth-sized planets orbiting the red dwarf star [[TRAPPIST-1]] approximately 39 light-years away in the constellation Aquarius. The planets were discovered through the transit method, meaning we have mass and radius information for all of them. [[TRAPPIST-1e]], [[TRAPPIST-1f|f]], and [[TRAPPIST-1g|g]] appear to be within the habitable zone and may have liquid water on the surface.<ref>{{cite web |url=https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-telescope-reveals-largest-batch-of-earth-size-habitable-zone-planets-around |website=www.nasa.gov |title=NASA telescope reveals record-breaking exoplanet discovery |date=2017-02-22 |df=dmy-all}}</ref> | ||
| Line 164: | Line 178: | ||
[[File:NASA-RedDwarfPlanet-ArtistConception-20130728.jpg|thumb|left|upright=1.2|An artist's impression of a planet with two [[exomoon]]s orbiting in the [[habitable zone]] [[Planets orbiting red dwarfs|of a red dwarf]].]] | [[File:NASA-RedDwarfPlanet-ArtistConception-20130728.jpg|thumb|left|upright=1.2|An artist's impression of a planet with two [[exomoon]]s orbiting in the [[habitable zone]] [[Planets orbiting red dwarfs|of a red dwarf]].]] | ||
Modern evidence suggests that planets in red dwarf systems are extremely unlikely to be habitable. In spite of their great numbers and long lifespans, there are several factors which may make life difficult on planets around a red dwarf. First, planets in the habitable zone of a red dwarf would be so close to the parent star that they would likely be [[Tidal locking|tidally locked]]. For a nearly circular orbit, this would mean that one side would be in perpetual daylight and the other in eternal night. This could create enormous temperature variations from one side of the planet to the other. Such conditions would appear to make it difficult for forms of life similar to those on Earth to evolve. And it appears there is a great problem with the atmosphere of such tidally locked planets: the perpetual night zone would be cold enough to freeze the main gases of their atmospheres, leaving the daylight zone bare and dry. On the other hand, a theory proposes that either a thick atmosphere or planetary ocean could potentially circulate heat around such a planet.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.astrobio.net/news-exclusive/planets-orbiting-red-dwarfs-may-stay-wet-enough-life/|title=Planets Orbiting Red Dwarfs May Stay Wet Enough for Life|publisher=Astrobiology|language=en| | Modern evidence suggests that planets in red dwarf systems are extremely unlikely to be habitable. In spite of their great numbers and long lifespans, there are several factors which may make life difficult on planets around a red dwarf. First, planets in the habitable zone of a red dwarf would be so close to the parent star that they would likely be [[Tidal locking|tidally locked]]. For a nearly circular orbit, this would mean that one side would be in perpetual daylight and the other in eternal night. This could create enormous temperature variations from one side of the planet to the other. Such conditions would appear to make it difficult for forms of life similar to those on Earth to evolve. And it appears there is a great problem with the atmosphere of such tidally locked planets: the perpetual night zone would be cold enough to freeze the main gases of their atmospheres, leaving the daylight zone bare and dry. On the other hand, a theory proposes that either a thick atmosphere or planetary ocean could potentially circulate heat around such a planet.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.astrobio.net/news-exclusive/planets-orbiting-red-dwarfs-may-stay-wet-enough-life/|title=Planets Orbiting Red Dwarfs May Stay Wet Enough for Life|publisher=Astrobiology|language=en|first=Charles Q.|last=Choi|date=9 February 2015|access-date=15 January 2017 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20150921050613/http://www.astrobio.net/news-exclusive/planets-orbiting-red-dwarfs-may-stay-wet-enough-life/ |archive-date=2015-09-21 |url-status=usurped}}</ref> Furthermore, even if a red dwarf's characteristics render most of its planet's surface uninhabitable, there is a chance for life to exist around a limited region, such as the planet's [[Terminator (solar)|terminator]].<ref>{{Cite web |last=Raymond |first=Sean |date=2015-02-20 |title=Forget "Earth-Like" Worlds |url=https://nautil.us/forget-earth_likewell-first-find-aliens-on-eyeball-planets-235308/ |access-date=2025-01-26 |website=Nautilus |language=en-US}}</ref> | ||
Variability in stellar energy output may also have negative impacts on the development of life. Red dwarfs are often [[flare star]]s, which can emit gigantic flares, doubling their brightness in minutes. This variability makes it difficult for life to develop and persist near a red dwarf.<ref>{{cite journal |last1=Vida |first1=K. |last2=Kővári |first2=Zs. |last3=Pál |first3=A. |last4=Oláh |first4=K. |last5=Kriskovics |first5=L. |display-authors=etal|title=Frequent Flaring in the TRAPPIST-1 System - Unsuited for Life? |journal=The Astrophysical Journal |date=2017 |volume=841 |issue=2 |page=2 |doi=10.3847/1538-4357/aa6f05 |bibcode=2017ApJ...841..124V|arxiv=1703.10130 |s2cid=118827117 |doi-access=free }}</ref> While it may be possible for a planet orbiting close to a red dwarf to keep its atmosphere even if the star flares, more-recent research suggests that these stars may be the source of constant high-energy flares and very large magnetic fields, diminishing the possibility of life as we know it.<ref>{{cite magazine|magazine = Scientific American |url = https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/red-star-rising/ |title = Red Star Rising|first = Mark|last = Alpert|date = 1 November 2005}}</ref><ref>{{cite web |website=Gizmodo |url=https://gizmodo.com/this-stormy-star-means-alien-life-may-be-rarer-than-we-1743540362 |title=This Stormy Star Means Alien Life May Be Rarer Than We Thought |first=George |last=Dvorsky |date=2015-11-19 |access-date=2019-07-10}}</ref> | |||
== Notes == | |||
{{notelist}} | |||
==See also== | ==See also== | ||
| Line 183: | Line 200: | ||
{{Refbegin}} | {{Refbegin}} | ||
* {{cite journal | * {{cite journal | ||
| | |last1=Burrows |first1=A. | ||
|last2=Hubbard |first2=W. B. | |||
|last3=Saumon |first3=D. | |||
|last4=Lunine |first4=J. I. | |||
|title=An expanded set of brown dwarf and very low mass star models | |title=An expanded set of brown dwarf and very low mass star models | ||
|journal=Astrophysical Journal | |journal=Astrophysical Journal | ||
|date=1993 |volume=406 |issue=1 |pages=158–71 |bibcode=1993ApJ...406..158B |doi=10.1086/172427 |doi-access=free }} | |date=1993 |volume=406 |issue=1 |pages=158–71 | ||
|bibcode=1993ApJ...406..158B |doi=10.1086/172427 |doi-access=free }} | |||
* {{cite news|title=VLT Interferometer Measures the Size of Proxima Centauri and Other Nearby Stars |publisher=European Southern Observatory |date=November 19, 2002 |url=http://www.eso.org/outreach/press-rel/pr-2002/pr-22-02.html |access-date=2007-01-12 |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20070103234953/http://www.eso.org/outreach/press-rel/pr-2002/pr-22-02.html |archive-date=January 3, 2007 }} | * {{cite news|title=VLT Interferometer Measures the Size of Proxima Centauri and Other Nearby Stars |publisher=European Southern Observatory |date=November 19, 2002 |url=http://www.eso.org/outreach/press-rel/pr-2002/pr-22-02.html |access-date=2007-01-12 |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20070103234953/http://www.eso.org/outreach/press-rel/pr-2002/pr-22-02.html |archive-date=January 3, 2007 }} | ||
* [http://space.com/scienceastronomy/051130_small_planet.html Neptune-Size Planet Orbiting Common Star Hints at Many More] | * [http://space.com/scienceastronomy/051130_small_planet.html Neptune-Size Planet Orbiting Common Star Hints at Many More] | ||
Latest revision as of 22:31, 10 October 2025
Template:Short description Script error: No such module "about". Script error: No such module "redirect hatnote". Template:Infobox astronomical formation A red dwarf is the smallest kind of star on the main sequence. Red dwarfs are by far the most common type of fusing star in the Milky Way, at least in the neighborhood of the Sun. However, due to their low luminosity, individual red dwarfs are not easily observed. Not one star that fits the stricter definitions of a red dwarf is visible to the naked eye.[1] Proxima Centauri, the star nearest to the Sun, is a red dwarf, as are fifty of the sixty nearest stars. According to some estimates, red dwarfs make up three-quarters of the fusing stars in the Milky Way.[2]
The coolest red dwarfs near the Sun have a surface temperature of about Template:Val and the smallest have radii about 9% that of the Sun, with masses about 7.5% that of the Sun. These red dwarfs have spectral types of L0 to L2. There is some overlap with the properties of brown dwarfs, since the most massive brown dwarfs at lower metallicity can be as hot as Template:Val and have late M spectral types.
Definitions and usage of the term "red dwarf" vary by how inclusive they are on the hotter and more massive end. One definition is synonymous with stellar M dwarfs, yielding a maximum temperature of Template:Val and Template:Solar mass. Another includes all stellar M-type main-sequence and all K-type main-sequence stars (K dwarf), yielding a maximum temperature of Template:Val and Template:Solar mass. Some definitions include any stellar M dwarf and part of the K dwarf classification. Other definitions are also in use. Many of the coolest, lowest-mass M dwarfs are expected to be brown dwarfs, not true stars, and so those would be excluded from any definition of red dwarf.
Stellar models indicate that red dwarfs less than Template:Solar mass are fully convective.[3] Hence, the helium produced by the thermonuclear fusion of hydrogen is constantly remixed throughout the star, avoiding helium buildup at the core, thereby prolonging the period of fusion. A low-mass red dwarf therefore develops very slowly, maintaining a constant luminosity and spectral type for trillions of years, until its fuel is depleted and it turns into a blue dwarf. Because of the comparatively short age of the universe, no red dwarfs yet exist at advanced stages of evolution.
Definition
The term "red dwarf" when used to refer to a star does not have a strict definition. One of the earliest uses of the term was in 1915, used simply to contrast "red" dwarf stars with hotter "blue" dwarf stars.[4] It became established use, although the definition remained vague.[5] In terms of which spectral types qualify as red dwarfs, different researchers picked different limits, for example K8–M5[6] or "later than K5".[7] Dwarf M star, abbreviated dM, was also used, but sometimes it also included stars of spectral type K.[8]
In modern usage, the definition of a red dwarf still varies. When explicitly defined, it typically includes late K- and early to mid-M-class stars,[9] but in many cases it is restricted to M-class stars.[10][11] In some cases all K stars are included as red dwarfs,[12] and occasionally even earlier stars.[13]
The most recent surveys place the coolest true main-sequence stars into spectral types L2 or L3. At the same time, many objects cooler than about M6 or M7 are brown dwarfs, insufficiently massive to sustain hydrogen-1 fusion.[14] This gives a significant overlap in spectral types for red and brown dwarfs. Objects in that spectral range can be difficult to categorize.
Description and characteristics
Template:Star nav Red dwarfs are very-low-mass stars.[15] As a result, they have relatively low pressures, a low fusion rate, and hence, a low temperature. The energy generated is the product of nuclear fusion of hydrogen into helium by way of the proton–proton (PP) chain. Hence, these stars emit relatively little light, sometimes as little as <templatestyles src="Fraction/styles.css" />1⁄10,000 that of the Sun, although this would still imply a power output on the order of Template:Val (10 trillion gigawatts or 10 ZW). Even the largest red dwarfs (for example HD 179930, HIP 12961 and Lacaille 8760) have only about 10% of the Sun's luminosity.[16] In general, red dwarfs less than Template:Solar mass transport energy from the core to the surface by convection. Convection occurs because of the opacity of the interior, which has a high density compared with the temperature. As a result, energy transfer by radiation is decreased, and instead convection is the main form of energy transport to the surface of the star. Above this mass, a red dwarf will have a region around its core where convection does not occur.[17]
Because low-mass red dwarfs are fully convective, helium does not accumulate at the core, and compared with larger stars such as the Sun, they can burn a larger proportion of their hydrogen before leaving the main sequence. As a result, red dwarfs have estimated lifespans far longer than the present age of the universe, and stars less than Template:Solar mass have not had time to leave the main sequence. The lower the mass of a red dwarf, the longer the lifespan. It is believed that the lifespans of these stars exceed the expected 10-billion-year lifespan of the Sun by the third or fourth power of the ratio of the solar mass to their masses; thus, a Template:Solar mass red dwarf may continue burning for 10 trillion years.[15][19] As the proportion of hydrogen in a red dwarf is consumed, the rate of fusion declines and the core starts to contract. The gravitational energy released by this size reduction is converted into heat, which is carried throughout the star by convection.[20]
| Spectral type[24] |
Mass (Template:Solar mass) | Radius (Template:Solar radius) | Luminosity (Template:Solar luminosity) | Effective temperature (K) |
Color index (B − V) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| M0V | 0.57 | 0.588 | 0.069 | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|3,850 | 1.42 |
| M1V | 0.50 | 0.501 | 0.041 | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|3,660 | 1.49 |
| M2V | 0.44 | 0.446 | 0.029 | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|3,560 | 1.51 |
| M3V | 0.37 | 0.361 | 0.016 | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|3,430 | 1.53 |
| M4V | 0.23 | 0.274 | Template:Val | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|3,210 | 1.65 |
| M5V | 0.162 | 0.196 | Template:Val | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|3,060 | 1.83 |
| M6V | 0.102 | 0.137 | Template:Val | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|2,810 | 2.01 |
| M7V | 0.090 | 0.120 | Template:Val | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|2,680 | 2.12 |
| M8V | 0.085 | 0.114 | Template:Val | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|2,570 | 2.15 |
| M9V | 0.079 | 0.102 | Template:Val | style="background-color:#Template:Color temperature"|2,380 | 2.17 |
According to computer simulations, the minimum mass a red dwarf must have to eventually evolve into a red giant is Template:Solar mass; less massive objects, as they age, would increase their surface temperatures and luminosities, becoming blue dwarfs and finally white dwarfs.[18]
The less massive the star, the longer this evolutionary process takes. A Template:Solar mass red dwarf (approximately the mass of the nearby Barnard's Star) would stay on the main sequence for 2.5 trillion years, followed by five billion years as a blue dwarf, during which the star would have one third of the Sun's luminosity (Template:Solar luminosity) and a surface temperature of 6,500–8,500 kelvins.[18]
The fact that red dwarfs and other low-mass stars remain on the main sequence when more massive stars have moved off the main sequence allows the age of star clusters to be estimated by finding the mass at which the stars move off the main sequence. This provides a lower limit to the age of the Universe and also allows formation timescales to be placed upon the structures within the Milky Way, such as the Galactic halo and Galactic disk.
All observed red dwarfs contain "metals", defined in astronomy as elements heavier than hydrogen and helium. The Big Bang model predicts that the first generation of stars should have only hydrogen, helium, and trace amounts of lithium, and hence would be of low metallicity. With their extreme lifespans, any red dwarfs that were a part of that first generation (population III stars) should still exist today. Low-metallicity red dwarfs, however, are rare. The accepted model for the chemical evolution of the universe anticipates such a scarcity of metal-poor dwarf stars because only giant stars are thought to have formed in the metal-poor environment of the early universe.Template:Why As giant stars end their short lives in supernova explosions, they spew out the heavier elements needed to form smaller stars. Therefore, dwarfs became more common as the universe aged and became enriched in metals. While the basic scarcity of ancient metal-poor red dwarfs is expected, observations have detected even fewer than predicted. The sheer difficulty of detecting objects as dim as red dwarfs was thought to account for this discrepancy, but improved detection methods have only confirmed the discrepancy.[25]
The boundary between the least massive red dwarfs and the most massive brown dwarfs depends strongly on the metallicity. At solar metallicity the boundary occurs at about Template:Solar mass, while at zero metallicity the boundary is around Template:Solar mass. At solar metallicity, the least massive red dwarfs theoretically have temperatures around Template:Val, while measurements of red dwarfs in the solar neighbourhood suggest the coolest stars have temperatures of about Template:Val and spectral classes of about L2. Theory predicts that the coolest red dwarfs at zero metallicity would have temperatures of about Template:Val. The least massive red dwarfs have radii of about Template:Solar radius, while both more massive red dwarfs and less massive brown dwarfs are larger.[14][26]
Spectral standard stars
The spectral standards for M type stars have changed slightly over the years, but settled down somewhat since the early 1990s. Part of this is due to the fact that even the nearest red dwarfs are fairly faint, and their colors do not register well on photographic emulsions used in the early to mid 20th century. The study of mid- to late-M dwarfs has significantly advanced only in the past few decades, primarily due to development of new astrographic and spectroscopic techniques, dispensing with photographic plates and progressing to charged-couple devices (CCDs) and infrared-sensitive arrays.
The revised Yerkes Atlas system (Johnson & Morgan, 1953)[27] listed only two M type spectral standard stars: HD 147379 (M0V) and HD 95735/Lalande 21185 (M2V). While HD 147379 was not considered a standard by expert classifiers in later compendia of standards, Lalande 21185 is still a primary standard for M2V. Robert Garrison[28] does not list any "anchor" standards among the red dwarfs, but Lalande 21185 has survived as a M2V standard through many compendia.[27][29][30] The review on MK classification by Morgan & Keenan (1973) did not contain red dwarf standards.
In the mid-1970s, red dwarf standard stars were published by Keenan & McNeil (1976)[31] and Boeshaar (1976),[32] but there was little agreement among the standards. As later cooler stars were identified through the 1980s, it was clear that an overhaul of the red dwarf standards was needed. Building primarily upon the Boeshaar standards, a group at Steward Observatory (Kirkpatrick, Henry, & McCarthy, 1991)[30] filled in the spectral sequence from K5V to M9V. It is these M type dwarf standard stars which have largely survived as the main standards to the modern day. There have been negligible changes in the red dwarf spectral sequence since 1991. Additional red dwarf standards were compiled by Henry et al. (2002),[33] and D. Kirkpatrick has recently reviewed the classification of red dwarfs and standard stars in Gray & Corbally's 2009 monograph.[34] The M dwarf primary spectral standards are: GJ 270 (M0V), GJ 229A (M1V), Lalande 21185 (M2V), Gliese 581 (M3V), Gliese 402 (M4V), GJ 51 (M5V), Wolf 359 (M6V), van Biesbroeck 8 (M7V), VB 10 (M8V), LHS 2924 (M9V).
Planet formation
Gas-rich disks (protoplanetary disks) have been detected around low-mass stars and brown dwarfs with ages as high as around 45 Myrs. This is unusual as more massive stars usually don't show primordial disks beyond 10 Myrs. These old disks have been dubbed Peter Pan disks, with J0808 being the prototype.[35] The long presence of gas in the disk could enable the formation of resonant chains, such as seen in TRAPPIST-1.[36] It is thought that only some will reach this high age and most will dissipate after 5 Myrs. The environment can play a role in the disk lifetime, such as stellar flybys and external photoevaporation, which can result in ionized proplyds.[37] Some edge-on protoplanetary disks around early M-stars are resolved, such as Tau 042021 and HH 30. These show jets and more recently disk winds in NIRCam and NIRSpec observations. The disk wind is an important part in removal of mass from the disk and accretion of material onto the surface of stars.[38][39]
Observations with the Mid-Infrared Instrument has advanced the study of the composition of the inner part of primordial disks around late M-dwarfs. Studies found either hydrocarbon-rich composition (e.g. 2MASS J1605–1933,[40] ISO-ChaI 147,[41] J0446B[42]) or water-rich composition (e.g. Sz 114[43]). The disks show a trend from oxygen-rich in younger disks to carbon-rich in older disks. Silicates are also detected for some disks.[44] This is explained with a model of inwards drifting material. At first water-ice-rich pebbles drift inwards, increasing the amount of oxygen in the inner disk. Then carbon-rich vapour drifts inwards and increases the amount of carbon in the inner disk. This process is more efficient in very low-mass stars because the icy outer part is closer to the inner disk.[45] This trend of carbon-rich disks is also present in brown dwarfs and planetary-mass objects. The brown dwarf 2M1207 has a disk rich in hydrocarbons,[44] and the planetary-mass object Cha 1107−7626 also shows hydrocarbons in the disk.[46] This composition could influence the composition of the planets formed within these disks, especially their atmospheres. If close-in planets accrete their atmospheres early, they could have a low C/O ratio (low amounts of carbon, high amounts of oxygen). If they accrete their atmospheres late, their atmospheres could have a high C/O ratio (similar to Titan).[45] The removal of carbon from the solids could also result in carbon-poor composition of the soldis (core/mantle/crust) in rocky planets.[41][42]
After the primordial gas is removed, the system is left with a debris disk. Examples of debris disks around red dwarfs are AU Microscopii, CE Antliae and Fomalhaut C.
Planets
Many red dwarfs are orbited by exoplanets, but large Jupiter-sized planets are comparatively rare. Doppler surveys of a wide variety of stars indicate about 1 in 6 stars with twice the mass of the Sun are orbited by one or more of Jupiter-sized planets, versus 1 in 16 for Sun-like stars and the frequency of close-in giant planets (Jupiter size or larger) orbiting red dwarfs is only 1 in 40.[47] On the other hand, microlensing surveys indicate that long-orbital-period Neptune-mass planets are found around one in three red dwarfs.[48] Observations with HARPS further indicate 40% of red dwarfs have a "super-Earth" class planet orbiting in the habitable zone where liquid water can exist on the surface.[49] Computer simulations of the formation of planets around low-mass stars predict that Earth-sized planets are most abundant, but more than 90% of the simulated planets are at least 10% water by mass, suggesting that many Earth-sized planets orbiting red dwarf stars are covered in deep oceans.[50]
At least four and possibly up to six exoplanets were discovered orbiting within the Gliese 581 planetary system between 2005 and 2010. One planet has about the mass of Neptune, or 16 Earth masses (Template:Earth mass). It orbits just Template:Convert from its star, and is estimated to have a surface temperature of Template:Cvt, despite the dimness of its star. In 2006, an even smaller exoplanet (only Template:Earth mass) was found orbiting the red dwarf OGLE-2005-BLG-390L; it lies Template:Convert from the star and its surface temperature is Template:Cvt.
In 2007, a new, potentially habitable exoplanet, Gliese 581c, was found, orbiting Gliese 581. The minimum mass estimated by its discoverers (a team led by Stephane Udry) is Template:Earth mass. The discoverers estimate its radius to be 1.5 times that of Earth (Template:Earth radius). Since then Gliese 581d, which is also potentially habitable, was discovered.
Gliese 581c and d are within the habitable zone of the host star, and are two of the most likely candidates for habitability of any exoplanets discovered so far.[51] Gliese 581g, detected September 2010,[52] has a near-circular orbit in the middle of the star's habitable zone. However, the planet's existence is contested.[53]
On 23 February 2017 NASA announced the discovery of seven Earth-sized planets orbiting the red dwarf star TRAPPIST-1 approximately 39 light-years away in the constellation Aquarius. The planets were discovered through the transit method, meaning we have mass and radius information for all of them. TRAPPIST-1e, f, and g appear to be within the habitable zone and may have liquid water on the surface.[54]
Habitability
Modern evidence suggests that planets in red dwarf systems are extremely unlikely to be habitable. In spite of their great numbers and long lifespans, there are several factors which may make life difficult on planets around a red dwarf. First, planets in the habitable zone of a red dwarf would be so close to the parent star that they would likely be tidally locked. For a nearly circular orbit, this would mean that one side would be in perpetual daylight and the other in eternal night. This could create enormous temperature variations from one side of the planet to the other. Such conditions would appear to make it difficult for forms of life similar to those on Earth to evolve. And it appears there is a great problem with the atmosphere of such tidally locked planets: the perpetual night zone would be cold enough to freeze the main gases of their atmospheres, leaving the daylight zone bare and dry. On the other hand, a theory proposes that either a thick atmosphere or planetary ocean could potentially circulate heat around such a planet.[55] Furthermore, even if a red dwarf's characteristics render most of its planet's surface uninhabitable, there is a chance for life to exist around a limited region, such as the planet's terminator.[56]
Variability in stellar energy output may also have negative impacts on the development of life. Red dwarfs are often flare stars, which can emit gigantic flares, doubling their brightness in minutes. This variability makes it difficult for life to develop and persist near a red dwarf.[57] While it may be possible for a planet orbiting close to a red dwarf to keep its atmosphere even if the star flares, more-recent research suggests that these stars may be the source of constant high-energy flares and very large magnetic fields, diminishing the possibility of life as we know it.[58][59]
Notes
See also
- Template:Annotated link
- Template:Annotated link
- Template:Annotated link
- Template:Annotated link
- Template:Annotated link
- Template:Annotated link
- Template:Annotated link
References
Sources
- Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- Neptune-Size Planet Orbiting Common Star Hints at Many More
External links
Template:Sister project Template:Sister project
- Variable stars AAVSO
- Stellar Flares Publications about Flares by the Stellar Activity Group (UCM)
- Red Dwarfs Jumk.de
- Red Star Rising : Small, cool stars may be hot spots for life – Scientific American (November 2005)
Template:Star Template:Portal bar Template:Authority control
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b c Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Younger brown dwarfs may also exhibit spectra similar to late M-type stars.
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Template:Cite thesis
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ a b Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Template:Cite magazine
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".Template:Dead link
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
- ↑ Script error: No such module "Citation/CS1".
- ↑ Template:Cite magazine
- ↑ Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".