Chananel ben Chushiel: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Monkbot
m Task 20: replace {lang-??} templates with {langx|??} ‹See Tfd› (Replaced 1);
 
imported>Su987654321
 
Line 6: Line 6:


==Works==
==Works==
R. Chananel wrote the first extant systematic commentary on the [[Talmud]], today included in the [[Vilna edition]] Talmud page on certain [[Masekhet|tractate]]s. The commentary, only parts of which survive, addresses sections of the Talmud relevant to legal practice at the time of writing: the orders [[Moed]], [[Nashim]], and [[Nezikin]]. Some fragments have been recovered from the [[Cairo Geniza]]h and are published in B. M. Levin's ''Otzar ha-Geonim'', though certain fragments may in fact represent geonic material from which R. Chananel copied,<ref>Ta-Shma, Israel Meir (1999). "הספרות הפרשנית לתלמוד". Vol. 1</ref> in particular the work of [[Hai ben Sherira|Hai Gaon]]. R. Chananel's commentary presents a paraphrased summary and explanation of the main arguments in the [[gemara]], omitting most of the non-legal sections ([[Aggada]]) as well as sections that R. Chananel considered too simple to warrant further explanation. A distinctive feature of the commentary is the presentation of the parallel passages from the [[Jerusalem Talmud]]. He is one of the most widely quoted commentaries by all the rishonim including [[Rashi]], [[Tosafot]] and the [[Isaac Alfasi|Rif]]. His opinion is highly regarded in halacha and correct versions of the texts which is used as a basis for Maimonides and many other later halachic authorities. In places where we don't have his commentary, his opinion is usually known from other sources due to mass quotation from all the ''[[Rishonim]]''.{{Citation needed|date=December 2022}} An edition of the commentary published by Vagshal covers tractate Berachot and order Moed, which also includes the ''Sefer ha-Mafteaḥ'' of his colleague [[Nissim Ben Jacob|Nissim Gaon]].
R. Chananel wrote the first extant systematic commentary on the [[Talmud]], today included in the [[Vilna edition]] Talmud page on certain [[Masekhet|tractate]]s. The commentary, only parts of which survive, addresses sections of the Talmud relevant to legal practice at the time of writing: the orders [[Moed]], [[Nashim]], and [[Nezikin]]. Some fragments have been recovered from the [[Cairo Geniza]]h and are published in B. M. Levin's ''Otzar ha-Geonim'', though certain fragments may in fact represent geonic material from which R. Chananel copied,<ref>Ta-Shma, Israel Meir (1999). "הספרות הפרשנית לתלמוד". Vol. 1</ref> in particular the work of [[Hai ben Sherira|Hai Gaon]]. R. Chananel's commentary presents a paraphrased summary and explanation of the main arguments in the [[gemara]], omitting most of the non-legal sections ([[Aggada]]) as well as sections that R. Chananel considered too simple to warrant further explanation. A distinctive feature of the commentary is the presentation of the parallel passages from the [[Jerusalem Talmud]]. He is one of the most widely quoted commentaries by all the rishonim including [[Rashi]], [[Tosafot]] and the [[Isaac Alfasi|Rif]]. His opinion is highly regarded in halacha and correct versions of the texts which is used as a basis for Maimonides and many other later halachic authorities. In places where we don't have his commentary, his opinion is usually known from other sources due to mass quotation from all the ''[[Rishonim]]''.<ref>{{Cite web |title=ALHATORAH.ORG |url=https://alhatorah.org/Commentators:R._Chananel_b._Chushiel/0/en |access-date=2025-06-30 |website=alhatorah.org}}</ref> An edition of the commentary published by Vagshal covers tractate Berachot and order Moed, which also includes the ''Sefer ha-Mafteaḥ'' of his colleague [[Nissim Ben Jacob|Nissim Gaon]].


R. Chananel also authored a [[Rabbinic literature#Meforshim|commentary]] on the [[Torah]], cited by many later Biblical commentators, chiefly [[Bahya ben Asher]]. This commentary is to some extent directed against the [[Karaite Judaism|Karaite]]s.{{Citation needed|date=December 2022}} While no full copy of this work survives, we possess many fragments of it; it has recently been published by the  ''Mosad Ha-Rav Kook'' as a separate work, as well as in the ''Torat Hayyim'' [[Mikraot Gedolot|Torah edition with commentaries]].
R. Chananel also authored a [[Rabbinic literature#Meforshim|commentary]] on the [[Torah]], cited by many later Biblical commentators, chiefly [[Bahya ben Asher]]. This commentary is to some extent directed against the [[Karaite Judaism|Karaite]]s.<ref>{{Cite web |title=HANANEEL BEN ḤUSHIEL - JewishEncyclopedia.com |url=https://jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/7178-hananeel-ben-hushiel |access-date=2025-06-30 |website=jewishencyclopedia.com}}</ref> While no full copy of this work survives, we possess many fragments of it; it has recently been published by the  ''Mosad Ha-Rav Kook'' as a separate work, as well as in the ''Torat Hayyim'' [[Mikraot Gedolot|Torah edition with commentaries]].


Other works by Rabbeinu Chananel include [[responsa]]; a number of  [[Rishonim]] attribute to him the anonymous "Sefer ha-Miktzo'ot," [[posek|decisions]] on [[halakha|ritual law]].{{chart/start}}
Other works by Rabbeinu Chananel include [[responsa]]; a number of  [[Rishonim]] attribute to him the anonymous "Sefer ha-Miktzo'ot," [[posek|decisions]] on [[halakha|ritual law]].{{tree chart/start}}
{{chart|boxstyle=background:lightgreen;|Chushiel|Chushiel=[[Chushiel|רבנו חושיאל]]}}
{{tree chart|boxstyle=background:lightgreen;|Chushiel|Chushiel=[[Chushiel|רבנו חושיאל]]}}
{{chart| |!|}}
{{tree chart| |!|}}
{{chart|Chananel | |Chananel ='''חננאל בן חושיאל'''}}
{{tree chart|Chananel | |Chananel ='''חננאל בן חושיאל'''}}
{{chart| |!|}}
{{tree chart| |!|}}
{{chart|boxstyle=background:lightblue;|Alfasi|Alfasi=[[Isaac Alfasi|רי"ף]]}}
{{tree chart|boxstyle=background:lightblue;|Alfasi|Alfasi=[[Isaac Alfasi|רי"ף]]}}
{{chart/end}}
{{tree chart/end}}
<br>
<br>
{{legend|lightgreen|Teachers}}
{{legend|lightgreen|Teachers}}
Line 33: Line 33:
* [https://www.ucalgary.ca/~elsegal/TalmudMap/OtherComs.html#Hananel Rabbenu Hananel], Prof. Eliezer Segal
* [https://www.ucalgary.ca/~elsegal/TalmudMap/OtherComs.html#Hananel Rabbenu Hananel], Prof. Eliezer Segal
* [https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/the-rishonim/episodes/R-Hananel-I-The-Man-and-His-Methods-e25n082#Rishonim Podcast: R. Hananel], Podcast about Rabbi Hananel
* [https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/the-rishonim/episodes/R-Hananel-I-The-Man-and-His-Methods-e25n082#Rishonim Podcast: R. Hananel], Podcast about Rabbi Hananel


{{s-start}}
{{s-start}}
Line 39: Line 38:
{{succession box
{{succession box
| before=[[Chushiel|Chushiel ben Elchanan]]
| before=[[Chushiel|Chushiel ben Elchanan]]
| title=Rosh Yeshiva of [[History_of_the_Jews_in_Kairouan#Kairouan_yeshiva|Kairouan]]
| title=Rosh Yeshiva of [[History of the Jews in Kairouan#Kairouan yeshiva|Kairouan]]
| with=[[Nissim ben Jacob]]
| with=[[Nissim ben Jacob]]
| after=None
| after=None

Latest revision as of 03:20, 30 June 2025

Template:Short description Chananel ben Chushiel or Ḥananel ben Ḥushiel (Template:Langx), an 11th-century Kairouanan rabbi and Talmudist, was in close contact with the last Geonim. He is best known for his commentary on the Talmud. Chananel is often referred to as Rabbeinu ChananelHebrew for "our teacher, Chananel" (in Hebrew, רבנו חננאל, or abbreviated, ר"ח).

Biography

Rabbeinu Chananel (c. 980–1055) was probably born in Southern Italy,[1] likely Bari,[2] an important rabbinic center in the late geonic period. Around the year 1005, his father Chushiel travelled to North Africa with the intention of making his way to Egypt.[3] While waiting for his son to join him, Chushiel settled instead in Kairouan (modern Tunisia), at the time under the rule of Zirid Emirs on behalf of the Fatimids. R. Chananel studied under his father, who became head of the Kairouan yeshiva, and through correspondence with Hai Gaon. He is closely associated with Nissim Ben Jacob in the capacity of rabbi and Rosh yeshiva of Kairouan. His most famous student is Isaac Alfasi. According to R. Abraham Ibn Daud, R. Chananel was also successful in business and was said to be very wealthy and had nine daughters.[4]

Works

R. Chananel wrote the first extant systematic commentary on the Talmud, today included in the Vilna edition Talmud page on certain tractates. The commentary, only parts of which survive, addresses sections of the Talmud relevant to legal practice at the time of writing: the orders Moed, Nashim, and Nezikin. Some fragments have been recovered from the Cairo Genizah and are published in B. M. Levin's Otzar ha-Geonim, though certain fragments may in fact represent geonic material from which R. Chananel copied,[5] in particular the work of Hai Gaon. R. Chananel's commentary presents a paraphrased summary and explanation of the main arguments in the gemara, omitting most of the non-legal sections (Aggada) as well as sections that R. Chananel considered too simple to warrant further explanation. A distinctive feature of the commentary is the presentation of the parallel passages from the Jerusalem Talmud. He is one of the most widely quoted commentaries by all the rishonim including Rashi, Tosafot and the Rif. His opinion is highly regarded in halacha and correct versions of the texts which is used as a basis for Maimonides and many other later halachic authorities. In places where we don't have his commentary, his opinion is usually known from other sources due to mass quotation from all the Rishonim.[6] An edition of the commentary published by Vagshal covers tractate Berachot and order Moed, which also includes the Sefer ha-Mafteaḥ of his colleague Nissim Gaon.

R. Chananel also authored a commentary on the Torah, cited by many later Biblical commentators, chiefly Bahya ben Asher. This commentary is to some extent directed against the Karaites.[7] While no full copy of this work survives, we possess many fragments of it; it has recently been published by the Mosad Ha-Rav Kook as a separate work, as well as in the Torat Hayyim Torah edition with commentaries.

Other works by Rabbeinu Chananel include responsa; a number of Rishonim attribute to him the anonymous "Sefer ha-Miktzo'ot," decisions on ritual law.Template:Tree chart/start Script error: No such module "Tree chart". Script error: No such module "Tree chart". Script error: No such module "Tree chart". Script error: No such module "Tree chart". Script error: No such module "Tree chart". Template:Tree chart/end

<templatestyles src="Legend/styles.css" />

  Teachers

<templatestyles src="Legend/styles.css" />

  Students

See also

References

Template:Reflist

External links

Template:S-relTemplate:S-endTemplate:RishonimTemplate:Authority control
Preceded byTemplate:S-bef/checkTemplate:Succession box/check Rosh Yeshiva of Kairouan
With: Nissim ben Jacob Template:S-ttl/check
Template:S-aft/check Succeeded by
  1. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  2. According to Abraham Ibn Daud's Sefer ha-Kabbalah (12th century), Rabbeinu Chananel was born in Kairouan; he gives Bari as the point of origin for his father, R. Chushiel ben Elchanan. See Gerson Cohen, ed., Sefer ha-Qabbalah (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1967), English, p. 64, Hebrew, p. 47.
  3. Ta-Shma, Israel Meir (1999). "הספרות הפרשנית לתלמוד". Vol. 1, p. 123
  4. Cohen, ed., Sefer ha-Qabbalah, Eng. pp. 77-78, Heb. pp. 57-58.
  5. Ta-Shma, Israel Meir (1999). "הספרות הפרשנית לתלמוד". Vol. 1
  6. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".
  7. Script error: No such module "citation/CS1".