View source for Talk:Sakura Wars

{{GA|19:54, 19 April 2020 (UTC)|topic=Video games|page=1|oldid=951952581}}
{{WikiProject banner shell|class=GA|
{{WikiProject Media franchises |importance=Low}}
{{WikiProject Video games|class=GA|importance=Low|Sega=yes}}
{{WikiProject Anime and manga|b1=y|b2=n|b3=n|b4=y|b5=y|b6=y|importance=low}}
}}
{{Old merge full|otherpage=List of Sakura Wars characters|date=27 October 2015|result=not merge|talk=Talk:Sakura Wars#Proposed merge with List of Sakura Wars characters}}
{{Refideas
|1=[http://www.hardcoregaming101.net/sakurataisen/st1.htm Hardcoregaming101's writeup]
|2=http://gamez.itmedia.co.jp/games/articles/0803/19/news003.html
|3=https://game.watch.impress.co.jp/docs/20071130/sakura.htm
|4=http://sakura-taisen.com/romando/talk_report.html
|5=https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2007-01-26/funimation-announces-mushishi
|6=https://icv2.com/articles/news/view/2353/funimation-gets-sakura-wars-ovas
|7=https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/convention/2005/anime-central/2
|8=https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2005-01-19/sakura-wars-ecole-de-paris-release-date
|9=https://web.archive.org/web/20051208014835/http://www.sakurataisen.tv/
|10=https://archive.org/details/DCUK14/page/n47
|11=https://archive.org/details/game-hihyou-vol.-26-game-magazine-scan-jp/page/n5/mode/1up
|12=https://www.radiosega.net/news/features/2012/08/radiosega-interview-steve-lycett/
|13=https://archive.org/details/Gamejin-PARTNER-Vol-14/Gamejin%20PARTNER%20Vol.%2014/page/38/mode/2up (GBC interview)
|14=https://archive.org/details/Dengeki-Sega-EX-1996-12/Dengeki%20SEGA%20EX%201996%2012/page/98/mode/2up
}}
{{annual readership|days=360}}
{{User:HBC Archive Indexerbot/OptIn 
|target=/Archive index |mask=/Archive <#> |leading_zeros=0 |indexhere=yes 
}}
{{User:MiszaBot/config
|archiveheader = {{aan}}
|maxarchivesize = 100K
|counter = 1
|minthreadsleft = 4
|minthreadstoarchive = 1
|algo = old(30d)
|archive = Talk:Sakura Wars/Archive %(counter)d
}}
{{archivebox|auto=yes|age=30|units=days|bot=lowercase sigmabot III}}

==New logo?==
this is not so important. but I found this logo. is this the most up to date logo? [https://kamigame.jp/アナムネシス/キャラクター/index-サクラ大戦.html] OR is this only used for one specific game? I'm sorry, I wish I knew more about Sakura Wars.[[User:Blue Pumpkin Pie|Blue Pumpkin Pie]] ([[User talk:Blue Pumpkin Pie|talk]]) 17:55, 14 May 2019 (UTC)

I found more evidence that this is indeed the logo for the series. The official website suggests that this is the logo that is used for the series as a whole found here: [https://sakura-taisen.com/archives/whats.html] however it has the "dot com" attached to it. I found another site that has it without the .com [https://www.rpg-o-mania.com/coverage_retrospective_sakurawars.php]. Does anyone think this is a better logo? Would anyone mind if I replaced the old one with the new one?[[User:Blue Pumpkin Pie|<b style="color: #4682B4">Blue</b> <b style="color: #20B2AA">Pumpkin</b> <b style="color: #DAA520">Pie</b>]] <sup>[[User talk:Blue Pumpkin Pie|Chat]]</sup> <sup>[[Special:Contributions/Blue Pumpkin Pie|Contribs]]</sup> 16:01, 18 February 2020 (UTC)

:I have no objections. [[User:Sjones23|Lord Sjones23]] ([[User talk:Sjones23|talk]] - [[User:Sjones23/Wikipedia contributions|contributions]]) 02:32, 19 February 2020 (UTC)

== Animation studio for So Long, My Love ==

So, in the staff credits for ''Sakura Wars: So Long, My Love'', Production I.G is credited for animation production assistance while M.S.C was credited as the actual animation production studio, even though I.G's website says that they co-produced it. I tried to correct it, but it was reverted. [[WP:BRD]], I'm taking the discussion to the talk page and see what we can do to work out a possible solution. Thoughts? [[User:Sjones23|Lord Sjones23]] ([[User talk:Sjones23|talk]] - [[User:Sjones23/Wikipedia contributions|contributions]]) 12:00, 17 February 2020 (UTC)
:{{ping|Sjones23}} Apologies if any offence was taken. I've done what I should've at first; done a search and actually brought up a source to confirm M.S.C.'s involvement. I've rewritten the article accordingly. The thing I was taking exception to was that the edits were made without any changes to sources. I was also a little put out by the addition of staff both without sources and in the main article. In the articles for individual games, it makes sense especially if the staff mentioned have articles. Otherwise it just looks like a Wikia page rather than Wikipedia. --[[User:ProtoDrake|ProtoDrake]] ([[User talk:ProtoDrake|talk]]) 12:15, 17 February 2020 (UTC)
::{{ping|ProtoDrake}} No hard feelings. [[User:Sjones23|Lord Sjones23]] ([[User talk:Sjones23|talk]] - [[User:Sjones23/Wikipedia contributions|contributions]]) 12:17, 17 February 2020 (UTC)

{{Talk:Sakura Wars/GA1}}

== RED's involvement in the development?  ==

Was [[Red Entertainment]] ever involved in the development (as in programming, production and playtesting) of the games. while all installments ST96-Dramatic Dungeon had Red credited as licensor (as stated in the opening logos for the pre-ST19-era games) and not as developer (while all the Columns spinoffs and STVE0 credit Red for the character design, STStory is an interesting case as RED had a "licensed & created" credit). [[User:VenezuelanSpongeBobFan2004|VenezuelanSpongeBobFan2004]] ([[User talk:VenezuelanSpongeBobFan2004|talk]]) 07:33, 20 February 2024 (UTC)

== Localized Title for ''Sakura Wars: Atsuki Chishio Ni''  ==

Today a fresh account swept through the Sakura Wars franchise and related pages to revert the localized name of Sakura Wars: Atsuki Chishio Ni from the one used in the English localization for Sakura Wars V, "To My Heating Blood," to a fan-translated title, "In Hot Blood."  I have reverted these changes, as they do not reflect the best information we have at this time on what the game should be called in English.  The English title for Atsuki Chishio Ni can be viewed (in an emulator) in this screenshot:

https://preview.redd.it/05i7quvq4uu91.png?width=960&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=d3035e94f88b985f6f328e8042ff2fbf7501b103

This screen is not easily accessible because of region-locking on PlayStation 2 consoles, thus making it unlikely that the English release of Sakura V and the Japanese release of Heating Blood would have their save files on the same memory card, but the screen does exist.  I recommend that until this localization is superseded by a newer source, we defer to this translation instead of falling back on unofficial fan translations.  [[User:LordHuffNPuff|LordHuffnPuff]] ([[User talk:LordHuffNPuff|talk]]) 21:04, 28 February 2024 (UTC)

:I would beg to differ, here. The screen is very much using a placeholder title. Note the lack of copyright information that should exist for the title, and the fact that the game itself includes numerous such instances of unchecked translation errors. For example, referring to Hanabi as "Fireworks" in a bromide description.
:That the screen is inaccessible without going through an emulator and hacking in save data should be more than proof of that. That this is being treated as an official, sanctioned translation of the title is specious. [[User:Maturra|Maturra]] ([[User talk:Maturra|talk]]) 21:35, 28 February 2024 (UTC)

::I do not believe you need to hack with an emulator - PS2 memory cards are region-free.  Furthermore, I'm not sure that even if this were to be the case that it would matter in this context.  Generally all text strings are translated during a localization process irrespective of whether they will be exposed to the player, and indeed, the translation team (especially in older games) is often presented with lines jumbled up, in alphabetical order, in a spreadsheet, or in any other number of contextless or confusing scenarios, which is why you see errors like the Hanabi example you cite.  Thus, we can't say that this is a placeholder title, or a wrong translation - somebody would need to produce some sort of interview or hard evidence to that effect; otherwise we have to presume that the string was translated as intended, given the context for where it appears in the game.  Additionally, it would be odd to include copyright information tagged to in-game text in such a fashion - this is not standard practice for save import system text strings.  I agree that in a subjective sense, "In Hot Blood" is certainly a ''better'' translation than ''To My Heating Blood,'' but this is the translation that we have, courtesy of NIS America working under license from SEGA, and unless we can produce a superseding document with an alternate title that either postdates the game's North American release, is sourced from SEGA directly, and/or indicates that this title is not meant to be the official title, it's the best we got.  Which kind of sucks, but only one of the two titles under discussion actually appears in the code for a Sakura Wars game and thus meets the standards for Wikipedia's sourcing and citation.[[User:LordHuffNPuff|LordHuffnPuff]] ([[User talk:LordHuffNPuff|talk]]) 22:58, 28 February 2024 (UTC)
:::Apologies for the delay. 
:::I've gone through my archives and numerous sources. The official English-language [https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.sp777town.gp.ps0050&hl=en_US&pli=1 Google Play store page] for Sega parent company Sammy's app "777 Town" mobile port of the Sakura Wars: Atsuki Chishio ni slot machine refers to the title as "Sakura Wars: In Hot Blood."
:::The most recent update was in September 2023. [[User:Maturra|Maturra]] ([[User talk:Maturra|talk]]) 02:16, 29 February 2024 (UTC)
::::Failing that, Sega's [https://www.segasammy.co.jp/cms/wp-content/uploads/pdf/en/ir/e_sega_kessan_tuuki_2003.pdf 2003 financial report] refers to the title as "To Hot Blood."
::::Both of these titles come directly from Sega and Sammy, at multiple points in time, offering a consensus and general consistency in their own internal naming for the title. [[User:Maturra|Maturra]] ([[User talk:Maturra|talk]]) 02:18, 29 February 2024 (UTC)
:::::IMO "To Hot Blood" should be used due to the company using the name and the rather poor sourcing for "To My Heating Blood". Source #10 just gives "Hot Blood" as the translation. Source #95 on [[Sakura Wars (video game)]] also has the headline "Sakura Wars -In Hot Blood- Complete Music Collection". [[User:Jon698|Jon698]] ([[User talk:Jon698|talk]]) 02:43, 29 February 2024 (UTC)
:::::{{re|User:Maturra}} {{re|User:LordHuffnPuff}} Sources #136 and #137 on Sakura Wars also don't give the name "To My Heating Blood", but instead use "Atsuki Chishio Ni". [[User:Jon698|Jon698]] ([[User talk:Jon698|talk]]) 02:46, 29 February 2024 (UTC)
::::::The Google Play link provided above actually uses "In the Hot Blood," not "In Hot Blood" which offers a third translation rather than corroborating the fan translation or the NISA translation.  The financial report offers a fourth option.  Regarding {{re|User:Jon698}}'s reference, Source 95 on  [[Sakura Wars (video game)]] is using the same fan translation, and is an import review, so should not be considered in this discussion of which translation is Official - it's just the reviewer's best guess, I would imagine.  This gives us the following options, with sources:
::::::#In Hot Blood - popular fan name, but no official sources recommend this usage (though personally it's the "best" when it comes to natural English usage)
::::::#To My Heating Blood - Used by NIS America in their translation of Sakura Wars V.  This is the only usage that has actually appeared in a Sakura Wars video game, to my knowledge.
::::::#In the Hot Blood - From the store page of [777TOWN] Pachislot Sakura Wars-In the Hot Blood- via Google Play Store.
::::::#Hot Blood - From the 777Town Pachislot site... but only if you use the site preview for the store page.
::::::#To Hot Blood - From Sega Corporation's Consolidated Financial Results for the Year ended March 31, 2003
::::::#Atsuki Chishio Ni - Just keep the Romaji and avoid this mess.
::::::I would discard #1 out of hand due to lack of sourcing (bummer).  2, 3, and 5 are all stronger contenders, with 3 perhaps being the strongest due to it being the most recent.  4 seems like a goof.  It's also maybe the worst grammatically, because of course it is.  Romaji is always an option too, and maybe the best consensus approach, with a footnote about how it has been translated various ways over the years. [[User:LordHuffNPuff|LordHuffnPuff]] ([[User talk:LordHuffNPuff|talk]]) 03:22, 29 February 2024 (UTC)
:::::::I wish to draw attention to policy [[Wikipedia:Article titles]]; which points out bluntly:
:::::::{{quote|1=Wikipedia does not necessarily use the subject's "official" name as an article title; it generally prefers the name that is most commonly used (as determined by its prevalence in a significant majority of [[Wikipedia:Independent sources|independent]], [[Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable]], English-language sources) as such names will usually best fit the [[Wikipedia:CRITERIA|five criteria]] listed above.|2=[[Wikipedia:Article titles]]}} Further Essay: [[Wikipedia:Official names]] reinforces this position.
:::::::There is no widespread usage of the ''To My Heating Blood'' name. It's ''not'' a common name. The Google Play and Sega Crop financial doc information casts further doubts that this was ever intended as a title, as neither of them uses the word "heating".
:::::::<br>
:::::::Further evidence against official status is the lack of any '[[trademark symbol]]'. Trademarks, both registered and unregistered are to be marked with a trademark symbol in most situations. (You can see examples of this on the covers of both official English and Japanese ''Sakura Wars'' covers.) If this was planned as and being treated as a title, it would have a trademark symbol. Legal would have been on them to put one there, because failure to properly identify a trademark can harm the ability to defend the trademark in court, especially an unregistered one. It would appear here, as this screen would likely be the only time the title would have appeared in ''Sakura Wars V''.
:::::::<br>
:::::::My position is that we should continue with the revert to the ''Sakura Wars: In Hot Blood'', as that name checks off all 5 items on [[Wikipedia:Article_titles#Deciding_on_an_article_title|article name checklist]]: recognizability, naturalness, precision, concision, and consistency.-- [[User:The Navigators|The Navigators]] ([[User Talk:The Navigators|talk]]) 03:58, 29 February 2024 (UTC)
::::::::Seconding this.
::::::::At the moment, we're picking from a bunch of non-ideal options, as Sega has never actually announced nor trademarked a formal title for the release.
::::::::"In Hot Blood," in particular, was born out of being a literal translation of the subtitle "Atsuki Chishio ni," which itself is an excerpt of an excerpt from a tanka in Akiko Yosano's [[Midaregami]].
::::::::Beyond that, the only really ideal option would be to go with romaji, as "Atsuki Chishio ni" and "In Hot Blood" are both immediately recognizable and consistent, particularly among folks within the greater Sakura Wars community. It does fail the concision and recognizability clauses, though, as:
::::::::1. The title doesn't grok super well with folks not in the greater fan community, due to "In Hot Blood" being used almost ubiquitously everywhere from [https://www.giantbomb.com/sakura-taisen-atsuki-chishio-ni/3030-15100/ Giant Bomb] to news sites like [https://www.rpgfan.com/music-review/sakura-taisen-in-hot-blood-teigeki-complete-music-collection/ RPGFan].
::::::::2. "In Hot Blood" is known well enough that retailers outside of the fan community [https://a-pachinko.store/products/s-sammy132 are labeling products] with it. [[User:Maturra|Maturra]] ([[User talk:Maturra|talk]]) 05:38, 29 February 2024 (UTC)
:::::::::I won't stand in the way of consensus if a few more voices want to push hard on Option 1, but I think that this is a misapplication of that policy because we're not naming an article, which is explicitly what that article is about: Article Titles.  This game has no dedicated article, only in-article references.  I thing that preferring Atsuki Chishio Ni with a footnote that covers the naming situation is more ideal, and there is precedent - for example, the [[Tengai Makyō]] series (from the same developer studio, coincidentally!) uses the Romaji in an article title despite ''Far East of Eden'' being a widely-used and recognized English name for that series.  [[User:LordHuffNPuff|LordHuffnPuff]] ([[User talk:LordHuffNPuff|talk]]) 10:55, 29 February 2024 (UTC)
::::::::::I'd also be fine with Atsuki Chishio Ni, as it's an official title. [[User:Maturra|Maturra]] ([[User talk:Maturra|talk]]) 02:22, 1 March 2024 (UTC)
:::::::::::Given that this conversation has not been updated since 3/1, can we assume consensus? [[User:Maturra|Maturra]] ([[User talk:Maturra|talk]]) 03:38, 6 March 2024 (UTC)
::::::::::::{{re|User:Maturra}} I would say yes. Go ahead and make the necessary changes. [[User:Jon698|Jon698]] ([[User talk:Jon698|talk]]) 18:31, 6 March 2024 (UTC)
:::::::::::::I was waiting for somebody else to weigh in, seems fine to me. [[User:LordHuffnPuff|LordHuffnPuff]] ([[User talk:LordHuffnPuff|talk]]) 21:02, 6 March 2024 (UTC)
{{od}} Although this thread is at least a month old, I agree that we usually go with [[WP:COMMONNAME|the most commonly recognizable name]]. I've contacted the video games WikiProject [[Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Video games#Sakura Wars|here]] for their thoughts on the matter. [[User:Sjones23|Lord Sjones23]] ([[User talk:Sjones23|talk]] - [[User:Sjones23/Wikipedia contributions|contributions]]) 04:36, 4 April 2024 (UTC)

:The question as always is what the sources call it. [https://www.rpgfan.com/music-review/sakura-taisen-in-hot-blood-teigeki-complete-music-collection/ The sources] [http://www.hardcoregaming101.net/sakura-wars/ do appear to call it] "In Hot Blood", so that is what it ought to be called. What is in the Wii game is largely irrelevant since we as video game article editors know that [[Engrish]] is rather common in localizations.  [[User:Zxcvbnm|ᴢxᴄᴠʙɴᴍ]] ([[User talk:Zxcvbnm|ᴛ]]) 05:33, 4 April 2024 (UTC)
::I agree that we should go with the common name, but I wonder if any of the translated names are "common", or if the untranslated title is still the most recognizable? I'm not at all familiar with the sources so I'll defer to anyone who is. [[User:Axem Titanium|Axem Titanium]] ([[User talk:Axem Titanium|talk]]) 19:45, 4 April 2024 (UTC)
:::"In Hot Blood" has a bit more presence, to the point that some retailers use it for merch. Notably, it's been what Pacino dealers have used to sell machines for ages. Beyond that, it's the common name on news sites like RPGFan and VGMO.
:::Atsuki Chishio Ni gets a lot of play, but IHB tends to be generally known and referenced. [[User:Maturra|Maturra]] ([[User talk:Maturra|talk]]) 20:05, 4 April 2024 (UTC)
* Outsider opinion: if it's this controversial and unclear what the English translation is, then use "Atsuki Chishio Ni" in prose, with a footnote listing the relevant translations.  [[User:SnowFire|SnowFire]] ([[User talk:SnowFire|talk]]) 18:28, 8 April 2024 (UTC)
*:That's what I suggested.  We had consensus and a month of silence, no real reason to reopen this now. [[User:LordHuffnPuff|LordHuffnPuff]] ([[User talk:LordHuffnPuff|talk]]) 22:25, 12 April 2024 (UTC)