View source for Talk:Munich massacre

{{ArticleHistory
|action1=GAN
|action1date=14 November 2006
|action1result=not listed
|action1oldid=87857799

|action2=GAN
|action2date=19 July 2011
|action2result=not listed
|action2link=Talk:Munich massacre/GA1
|action2oldid=439037908

|currentstatus=FGAN
|otd1date=2005-09-05|otd1oldid=22613796|otd2date=2006-09-05|otd2oldid=73884900|otd3date=2007-09-05|otd3oldid=155777671|otd4date=2008-09-05|otd4oldid=236352728|otd5date=2009-09-05|otd5oldid=311954987|otd6date=2010-09-05|otd6oldid=383063932|otd7date=2011-09-05|otd7oldid=448558773
}}
{{Arab-Israeli Arbitration Enforcement}}
{{Top 25 Report|April 21, 2013}}
{{WikiProject banner shell|class=B|collapsed=yes|vital=yes|1=
{{WikiProject Bavaria|importance=High}}
{{WikiProject Crime and Criminal Biography|importance=Mid|terrorism=yes|terrorism-imp=high|serialkiller=yes|serialkiller-imp=Mid}}
{{WikiProject Death|importance=High}}
{{WikiProject Disaster management |importance=High }}
{{WikiProject European history|importance=High}}
{{WikiProject Germany|importance=High|Munich=yes|MunichImp=Top}}
{{WikiProject History|importance=High}}
{{WikiProject International relations|importance=High}}
{{WikiProject Israel|importance=High}}
{{WikiProject Judaism|importance=Mid}}
{{WikiProject Law Enforcement|importance=Mid}}
{{WikiProject Military history|b1=no|b2=yes|b3=yes|b4=yes|b5=yes|German=y|Cold-War=yes}}
{{WikiProject Olympics |importance=High}}
{{WikiProject Palestine|importance=Mid}}
}}
{{Merged-from|Anton Fliegerbauer|3 November 2022}}
{{User:MiszaBot/config
|archiveheader = {{aan}}
|maxarchivesize = 100K
|counter = 4
|minthreadsleft = 5
|algo = old(90d)
|archive = Talk:Munich massacre/Archive %(counter)d
}}
{{Archives |search=yes |bot=MiszaBot I |age=3 |units=months |index=/Archive index }}
{{User:HBC Archive Indexerbot/OptIn 
|target=/Archive index |mask=/Archive <#> |leading_zeros=0 |indexhere=yes 
}}

__TOC__

== Hostage-taker or terrorist? ==

can this be updated to refer to the ‘hostage-takers’ as terrorists? [[Special:Contributions/97.113.59.47|97.113.59.47]] ([[User talk:97.113.59.47|talk]]) 04:14, 28 February 2025 (UTC)
:There does not appear to be a good reason to do that. Firstly, there is [[WP:TERRORIST]], and secondly, the string 'hostage-taker' occurs 35 times compared to the string 'terrorist', which appears 60 times. [[User:Sean.hoyland|Sean.hoyland]] ([[User talk:Sean.hoyland|talk]]) 04:22, 28 February 2025 (UTC)
::Why not use one or the other? Hostage taker doesn’t convoy the depth of the actions.  They didn’t just take hostages.  They terrorized both the victims, the other athletes and the world.  It’s like calling the 9/11 perpetrators “bad pilots”. [[Special:Contributions/97.113.59.47|97.113.59.47]] ([[User talk:97.113.59.47|talk]]) 18:52, 1 March 2025 (UTC)
:::Hostage taker is a neutral or descriptive term focusing solely on the act of taking hostages. It does not inherently convey a political, ideological, or moral stance but instead emphasizes the method used in the attack. 
:::Even militant suggests an armed individual engaged in conflict, often with a political or ideological motivation. While it acknowledges that the perpetrators were part of an organized group, it does not inherently imply illegitimacy or wrongdoing. Some may view it as a more neutral or less emotionally charged term.
:::Terrorist explicitly conveys the idea that the perpetrators used violence to instill fear and achieve political ends. This term  labels the attackers as individuals who deliberately targeted civilians for political purposes. [[Special:Contributions/97.113.59.47|97.113.59.47]] ([[User talk:97.113.59.47|talk]]) 18:56, 1 March 2025 (UTC)

== Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 8 March 2025 ==

{{edit extended-protected|Munich massacre|answered=yes}}
Article states that "During the memorial service, Eliash collapsed and died of a heart attack." This is incorrect. Carmel Eliash had a heart attack during the service but he did not die. He did, however, die the following year during a different event in Israel. [[Special:Contributions/2003:DD:2F10:1D87:208C:2D32:FD55:F3A7|2003:DD:2F10:1D87:208C:2D32:FD55:F3A7]] ([[User talk:2003:DD:2F10:1D87:208C:2D32:FD55:F3A7|talk]]) 22:28, 8 March 2025 (UTC)
:{{fixed}}. 22:54, 8 March 2025 (UTC)

== "West German neo-Nazis provided logistical assistance to the group" ==
{{edit extended-protected|Munich massacre|answered=yes}}
The claim very early in the article is that ''"West German neo-Nazis provided logistical assistance to the group."''

That is a deliberate attempt to mislead readers. 

There were no neo-Nazis involved in the planning and execution of the attack. The linked ''Spiegel'' article tries hard to convince its readers that  neo-Nazis were somehow involved and says ''"...is it now necessary to consider the story ... in a new light? Yes at least in part."'' But whenever it becomes more concrete, they write things like ''"...it is still unclear today whether..."'' or ''"The question remains unanswered to this day."''.

All they do is create a smoke-screen with the aim of taking the leftists (Red Army Faction, RAF) out of the equation, who strongly sympathized with the attackers and publicly welcomed the attack. 

But in any case, the truth is that: ''"Black September didn't need any German logistic assistance."''  Which they do in fact write. But only to make sure no-one will ask for potential connections to the Red Army Faction.

A key conclusion of the article is very revealing...: ''"Until now, many experts assumed that it was left-wing extremists who had had ties to Black September, helping the terrorists find places to stay in Munich, for example. ... But according to the released documents, such statements must now be treated as myths."'' 

- Evidently, all the journalists at ''Spiegel'' cared about is to take potential blame away from their RAF friends. [[Special:Contributions/138.246.3.57|138.246.3.57]] ([[User talk:138.246.3.57|talk]]) 22:01, 10 March 2025 (UTC)

:{{fixed}}. Refined the text contributed by a former editor by making a qualification edit to ensure accuracy after reviewing the provided source. [[User:Nightsturm|Nightsturm]] ([[User talk:Nightsturm|talk]]) 15:18, 15 March 2025 (UTC)

== Afif and “Jewish Mother” ==
In the “attack and hostage taking” section of the article it says “According to the author Simon Reeve, Afif (the son of a Jewish mother and Christian father)” however on the page for Afif it says “Biographies of Afif claimed that his mother was Jewish, while his father was a wealthy Christian Arab businessman. However, both his family and Israel's interior ministry records dispute the claim about his mother. According to the records, his mother, Arifa, was born in 1920 to Hassan and Amina.” Is it possible to update this page (or Afif’s page) so that the two pages are consistent? [[User:Tiakat333|Tiakat333]] ([[User talk:Tiakat333|talk]]) 21:27, 21 March 2025 (UTC)

==Palestinian information three weeks before claim==
The statement "West German authorities had received a tip-off from a Palestinian informant in Beirut three weeks before the massacre" is not supported by the citation [https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/13537121.2022.2088134 "The Munich massacre and the proliferation of counterterrorism special operation forces"]. The relevant part of the cited article, on page 629, reads:
:In 2012 it was revealed that concrete intelligence from multiple sources regarding a potential attack by Palestinian functions at the Olympic games was known to the security forces, but no contingency plan was established. The West German newspaper Der Spiegel even revealed that a psychologist working for the Munich police wrote about 26 possible scenarios at the Olympic games, one of which was an invasion of Palestinian elements to the Olympic village.
No mention of a Palestinian source, no mention of Beirut, no mention of three weeks. - [[User:Tim1965|Tim1965]] ([[User talk:Tim1965|talk]]) 02:44, 12 April 2025 (UTC)

:The statement is in the second source within the paragraph. I have removed the misplaced source and properly repositioned the correct one. [[User:Nightsturm|Nightsturm]] ([[User talk:Nightsturm|talk]]) 16:50, 16 April 2025 (UTC)