View source for Talk:Metal umlaut

{{Article history
|action1=FAC
|action1date=20:20, 14 May 2004
|action1link=Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/Heavy metal umlaut/archive1
|action1result=promoted
|action1oldid=3604718

|action2=AFD
|action2date=02:41, 7 February 2006
|action2link=Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heavy metal umlaut
|action2result=Speedy keep
|action2oldid=38552908

|action3=FAR
|action3date=01:49, 25 September 2006
|action3link=Wikipedia:Featured article review/Heavy metal umlaut/archive1
|action3result=demoted
|action3oldid=77479578

|action4=PR
|action4date=18:33, 4 September 2007
|action4link=Wikipedia:Peer review/Heavy metal umlaut/archive1
|action4result=reviewed
|action4oldid=155461150

|maindate=June 26, 2004
|currentstatus=FFA
}}
{{WikiProject banner shell|class=C|1=
{{WikiProject Writing systems|importance=low}}
{{WikiProject Metal}}
{{WikiProject Spoken Wikipedia}}
}}
{{Press
|author=[[Jon Udell]]
|date=January 22, 2005
|url=http://jonudell.net/udell/2005-01-22-heavy-metal-umlaut-the-movie.html
|author2=Jon Udell
|date2=February 10, 2005
|url2=http://jonudell.net/udell/2005-02-10-heavy-metal-umlaut-the-making-of-the-movie.html
|author3=Tim de Lisle
|title3=Why Moben wanted to be Möben
|org3=The Guardian
|date3=April 20, 2006
|url3=http://www.guardian.co.uk/g2/story/0,,1757088,00.html
|author4=Foster Kamer
|title4=10 Questions for Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales, 10 Years On
|org4=Esquire
|date4=January 13, 2011
|url4=https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/interviews/a9210/jimmy-wales-interview-4847748/
}}
{{archives|banner=yes}}

== Use by nationality? ==

I was wondering if anyone can point me to anyone (metal bands that is) who uses heavy metal umlauts that aren't from the USA -- it appears to me that the phenomenon is, at least primarily if not solely, a US one.  <span style="font-size: smaller;" class="autosigned">— Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[Special:Contributions/80.167.145.44|80.167.145.44]] ([[User talk:80.167.145.44|talk]]) 00:36, 20 February 2014 (UTC)</span><!-- Template:Unsigned IP --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->
*What about [[Motörhead]], a British band? --[[User:Metropolitan90|Metropolitan90]] [[User talk:Metropolitan90|(talk)]] 05:45, 23 February 2016 (UTC)

::''"Motor", the correct German spelling, is pronounced similarly to "motor" in English''

:::No, it isn't. In fact, a '''German''' pronunciation of ''Motör'' would sound almost equivalent to how ''motor'' is usually pronounced in English. [[User:Nuttyskin|Nuttyskin]] ([[User talk:Nuttyskin|talk]]) 00:43, 21 June 2018 (UTC)
:::: No, that is nonsens. Unlike the quick and short English "motor", the German "Motor" is pronounced with longer vowels and emphasis on the second syllable, like "mo tore". "Motör" would sound like the French "[[fr:moteur]]". --[[Special:Contributions/2001:A62:1950:6501:EC9B:83FD:ED77:6967|2001:A62:1950:6501:EC9B:83FD:ED77:6967]] ([[User talk:2001:A62:1950:6501:EC9B:83FD:ED77:6967|talk]]) 21:49, 20 August 2019 (UTC)

==Motörhead==
May we take on board in some way that "Motörhead" actually uses the diacritic accent 'correctly' according to German usage over an o (even if their own word for motor is not pronounced like that, hence they don't use the accent) as noted by the previous comment. Trust Lemmy to come up with some value-added.[[Special:Contributions/212.159.59.41|212.159.59.41]] ([[User talk:212.159.59.41|talk]]) 15:38, 6 February 2019 (UTC)
: Damn!  I read that and started looking for the Like button!  :-)  [[User:SandJ-on-WP|SandJ-on-WP]] ([[User talk:SandJ-on-WP|talk]]) 19:26, 15 June 2019 (UTC)

==History==
The article used to have a section on the history:
:The first gratuitous use of the umlaut in the name of a hard rock or metal band appears to have been by [[Blue Öyster Cult]], in 1970. Blue Öyster Cult's website states it was added by guitarist and keyboardist [[Allen Lanier]],<ref name="Blue_Öyster_1">{{cite web |url=http://www.blueoystercult.com/History/history3.html |title=BÖC Retrospectively: Stalk Forrest Group 1969–1970 |accessdate=September 12, 2006 |publisher=blueoystercult.com}}</ref> but rock critic [[Richard Meltzer]] claims to have suggested it to their producer and manager [[Sandy Pearlman]] just after Pearlman came up with the name: "I said, 'How about an umlaut over the O?' Metal had a [[Richard Wagner|Wagnerian]] aspect anyway."<ref name="Sandy_Pearlman">{{cite web | url=http://www.spiraling.com/words/umlaut.html |title=Hell Holes: Spin̈al Tap's main man explains the importance of the umlaut |accessdate=September 12, 2006|author=Lisa Gidley |publisher=CMJ |year=2000}}</ref>
Seems a shame to have completely lost this. - [[User:Snori|Snori]] ([[User talk:Snori|talk]]) 22:18, 5 November 2018 (UTC)
:Put back in. - [[User:Snori|Snori]] ([[User talk:Snori|talk]]) 08:58, 21 May 2019 (UTC)
::Might need updating: I just came across a band from 1967 called “Frut of the Loom” spelled thus but with an umlaut over the u in ‘Frut’. [[User:RUReady2Testify|RUReady2Testify]] ([[User talk:RUReady2Testify|talk]]) 19:47, 16 April 2023 (UTC)
{{reflist-talk}}

== Spinal Tap ==

in the mockumentary film This Is Spın̈al Tap, fictional rocker David St. Hubbins (Michael McKean) says, "It's like a pair of eyes. You're looking at the umlaut, and it's looking at you."

I have seen this movie over 100 times. This line does not appear in the movie, and this quote should be deleted.[[User:Robbmonster|Robbmonster]] ([[User talk:Robbmonster|talk]]) 14:07, 12 January 2019 (UTC)

:{{reply|Robbmonster}} according to the cited source, that quotation isn't from the movie, but from an interview (mock interview?) with the David St Hubbins character. ~[[User:Anachronist|Anachronist]] <small>([[User talk:Anachronist|talk]])</small> 21:06, 12 January 2019 (UTC)
::Thank you for the swift reply. If what you say is correct - and I have no doubt it is - a couple of points need to be raised. 1) At the very least, the sentence using the St Hubbins quote needs to be changed, as it currently says "in the mockumentary film This Is Spın̈al Tap, fictional rocker David St. Hubbins (Michael McKean) says, "It's like a pair of eyes". The 'in the mocumentary film' part implies just that: IN the film. The other point is can an interview with a fictional character be used as a reference? David St Hubbins does not actually exist! I tried to use an interview with a real person as a reference (a musician talking about their inspiration for a song) and was not allowed to do so as it was a 'primary source' or some such.[[User:Robbmonster|Robbmonster]] ([[User talk:Robbmonster|talk]]) 08:57, 13 January 2019 (UTC)
:::{{reply|Robbmonster}} I see the problem. I corrected the sentence to make it clear that this was an interview separate from the film.
:::Primary sources are OK to use to verify what is stated in the primary source. Other uses are examined on a case-by-case basis; for example, citing primary sources does nothing to confer notability on a subject. Generally primary sources (such as interviews) aren't to be used as a basis for stating things as facts in Wikipedia's voice, but if the thing you need to say is encyclopedically relevant, it can be used with proper attribution, as in "Joe Blow said in an interview that XYZ inspired him to write the song" (attributing the statement), instead of "Joe Blow was inspired by XYZ to write the song" (stating it as a fact in Wikipedia's voice).
:::Regarding when a fictional character can be used as a source, I agree this particular example is pretty shaky, while remaining an interesting thing to include.
:::By the way, Spinal Tap has done other interviews in character. Here's one on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZtSQCbAQxU I found it amusing how they dissed the movie as a "hatchet job", saying the director was terrible. ~[[User:Anachronist|Anachronist]] <small>([[User talk:Anachronist|talk]])</small> 23:08, 15 January 2019 (UTC)

== Metal Umlaut ''or'' Heavy Metal Umlaut ==

I am in Britain and have listened to heavy metal for 40 years.  I have always known this to be referred to as a 'heavy metal umlaut', not a 'metal umlaut', including when it was referred to on BBC radio by the likes of Johnnie Walker.  Is calling it a 'metal umlaut' a USA thing?  [[User:SandJ-on-WP|SandJ-on-WP]] ([[User talk:SandJ-on-WP|talk]]) 19:36, 15 June 2019 (UTC)

== Umlauts are anything but tough in German ==

In German, Umlauts are mostly used in [[diminutive]] forms. While Hans is a name for a grown up man, like John, "little Johnny" is called [[Hänschen klein]], as in the children's song. Very though indeed. --[[Special:Contributions/2001:A62:1950:6501:EC9B:83FD:ED77:6967|2001:A62:1950:6501:EC9B:83FD:ED77:6967]] ([[User talk:2001:A62:1950:6501:EC9B:83FD:ED77:6967|talk]]) 22:02, 20 August 2019 (UTC)

:That used to be explained in the Mötley Crüe reactions section, but isn't there now... [[User:AnonMoos|AnonMoos]] ([[User talk:AnonMoos|talk]]) 16:47, 23 August 2019 (UTC)
:German here, can confirm. "Brütal" sounds cute, a bit gay maybe, but not at all brutal.  [[Special:Contributions/2001:9E8:4601:400:2D28:C336:925D:96BE|2001:9E8:4601:400:2D28:C336:925D:96BE]] ([[User talk:2001:9E8:4601:400:2D28:C336:925D:96BE|talk]]) 23:40, 3 August 2024 (UTC)

== lol, you don't understand what an umlaut is at all ==

As you write it, it sounds like an umlaut is just the two dots. That's total bullshit. There are only 3 different umlauts: ä, ö, ü or Ä, Ö, Ü. Please fix this article (and in case that the article is correct, please fix the english language, too).  <!-- Template:Unsigned IP --><small class="autosigned">—&nbsp;Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[Special:Contributions/87.145.178.6|87.145.178.6]] ([[User talk:87.145.178.6#top|talk]]) 18:14, 26 January 2020 (UTC)</small> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->

:Just thought the same. Also bands using regular german words like die Ärzte shouldnt be in the list. As you wrote, it is common in the German language. [[User:KhlavKhalash|KhlavKhalash]] ([[User talk:KhlavKhalash|talk]]) 16:04, 3 April 2022 (UTC)

::In band names, the two dots are applied to other letters besides A, O, and U. So, yes, it's just the two dots. The article is called what it is because of the [[WP:COMMONNAME]] guideline.
::I do agree that band names that ''correctly'' include an umlaut because that's how the word is spelled, rather than use it for decorative purposes, should probably be removed. However, the band "Die Ärzte" is included because they use ''three'' dots over the "A", not just two, as it says quite clearly in the article. ~[[User:Anachronist|Anachronist]] <small>([[User talk:Anachronist|talk]])</small> 04:11, 4 April 2022 (UTC)

== Deathtöngue ==

:{{xt|* Deathtöngue – the original name of a metal band in the comic [[Bloom County]] (changed, after media publicity, to "Billy and the Boingers")}}

Real media publicity, or fictional (i.e. within the strip) media publicity? —[[User:Tamfang|Tamfang]] ([[User talk:Tamfang|talk]]) 04:45, 13 April 2023 (UTC)

== Djerba logo ? ==

That one doesn't sound very legitimate to me.   The square dots on the logo seem more like they are representing the Arabic spelling of Djerba (جربة). 

https://www.francophonie.org/rencontres-institutionnelles-et-evenements-paralleles-au-programme-2445

[[Special:Contributions/184.161.226.126|184.161.226.126]] ([[User talk:184.161.226.126|talk]]) 12:08, 13 January 2025 (UTC)