View source for Blackburn/McCafferty Trophy

{{Short description|American college basketball rivalry}}
{{Infobox sports rivalry
 | wide                     = yes
 | name                     = Blackburn/McCafferty Trophy
 | image                     = 
 | image_size                     = 
 | caption                     = 2008 Shootout logo
 | team1                     = [[Dayton Flyers men's basketball|Dayton Flyers]]
 | team1logo                     = Dayton Flyers logo.svg
 | team2                     = [[Xavier Musketeers men's basketball|Xavier Musketeers]]
 | team2logo                     = Xavier Musketeers logo.svg
 | sport                     = Men's basketball
 | firstmeeting                     = February 20, 1920<br />Dayton 24, Xavier 18
 | mostrecent                     = November 29, 2015<br />Dayton 61, Xavier 90
 | nextmeeting                     =
 | total                     = 
 | series                     = Dayton leads 84–74
 | largestvictory                     = 
 | longeststreak                     = 
 | longestunbeatenstreak                     = 
 | currentstreak                     = 
 | currentunbeatenstreak                     = 
 | trophy                     = 
 | trophy series                     = 
 | stadiums                     = 
}}
{{OSM Location map
| coord = {{coord|39.495|-84.364}}
| zoom = 8
| width = 295 
| height = 250
| caption = Locations of Dayton and Xavier
| mark1 = Red pog.svg
| label1 = Dayton
| mark-coord1 = {{coord|39.7393|-84.1800}}
| label-pos1 = bottom
| label-color1 = black
| mark2 = Blue pog.svg
| label2 = Xavier
| mark-coord2 = {{coord|39.1494|-84.4736}}
| label-pos2 = top
| label-color2 = black
}}

The '''Blackburn/McCafferty Trophy''' is the award given to the winner of regular season [[basketball]] games between the [[University of Dayton]] and [[Xavier University (Cincinnati)|Xavier University]].

==Origin of Competition==
The first meeting between the two [[Catholic Church in the United States|Catholic]] universities was a 24-18 victory by Dayton on February 20, 1920.<ref>{{Cite web |url=http://daytonflyers.collegesports.com/sports/m-baskbl/spec-rel/021805aaa.html |title=Men's Basketball ~ Official Athletic Site of UNIVERSITY OF DAYTON |access-date=2005-11-03 |archive-date=2005-04-26 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20050426014439/http://daytonflyers.collegesports.com/sports/m-baskbl/spec-rel/021805aaa.html |url-status=dead }}</ref> The two schools have maintained an annual meeting since then, frequently meeting twice in one season. The series has been interrupted four times, most recently from 1943-45 due to [[World War II]]. Xavier held a commanding early lead in the series until Dayton won 61 of the next 74 games beginning in 1950. The rivalry between the two schools took on added significance beginning in the 1988-89 season when Dayton joined Xavier in the Midwestern Collegiate Conference (now the [[Horizon League]]) and again in the 1995-96 season when Dayton and Xavier joined the [[Atlantic 10 Conference]]. Dayton has not won against Xavier in Cincinnati since January 10, 1981, a streak that extends to 26 games. Through the 2014-15 season, Dayton leads the all-time series 84–74.  Dayton holds the longest winning streak in the series, with 10 consecutive wins between 1972 and 1977. The longest streak in the Atlantic 10 belongs to both Xavier and Dayton for 150 meetings between the two. Starting in the 2013–14 season, the matchup is once again a non-conference rivalry, after Xavier left the A10 to become a member of the [[Big East Conference]].  After a 9 year hiatus, the teams will meet in a Mental Health Awareness Charity Game at University of Dayton Arena on October 20th, 2024. 

==The Blackburn/McCafferty Trophy==
In the 1980-81 season, the two schools began playing for the Blackburn/McCafferty Trophy during regular season meetings.  Named for former Dayton coach [[Tom Blackburn (basketball)|Tom Blackburn]] and former Xavier coach [[Jim McCafferty]], the award commemorates the two men responsible for raising the national profile of their respective basketball programs.  The winner retains possession of the trophy until the next meeting.  Since the inception of the Blackburn/McCafferty Trophy, Xavier leads 37-20 in the regular season meetings.  Along with the trophy, an [[Most Valuable Player|MVP]] is named for the game and scholarship money is raised for each university [https://web.archive.org/web/20070928020506/http://www.collegesportingnews.com/article_print.asp?articleid=12668].

==Results==
Rankings are from the [[AP Poll]] (1936–present)
{{Sports rivalry series table
| cols = 2
| format = compact
| series_summary = yes
| team1 = Dayton
| team1style = {{NCAA secondary color cell|Dayton Flyers}}
| team2 = Xavier
| team2style = {{NCAA color cell|Xavier Musketeers}}

| February 20, 1920 | [[Dayton, Ohio|Dayton, OH]] | Dayton | 24 | Xavier | 18
| 1920-21 | [[Cincinnati|Cincinnati, OH]] | Dayton | 18 | Xavier | 21
| 1921-22 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 13 | Xavier | 27
| 1921-22 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 14 | Xavier | 10
| 1928-29 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 12 | Xavier | 18
| February 23, 1929 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 25 | Xavier | 26
| 1929-30 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 20 | Xavier | 19
| 1929-30 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 18 | Xavier | 29
| 1930-31 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 10 | Xavier | 33
| 1930-31 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 19 | Xavier | 40
| 1931-32 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 10 | Xavier | 20
| 1931-32 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 12 | Xavier | 46
| January 16, 1940 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 44 | Xavier | 29
| February 14, 1940 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 27 | Xavier | 34
| 1940-41 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 30 | Xavier | 54
| 1940-41 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 35 | Xavier | 37
| 1941-42 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 42 | Xavier | 58
| 1941-42 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 46 | Xavier | 32
| 1942-43 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 39 | Xavier | 61
| 1942-43 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 51 | Xavier | 28
| 1945-46 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 41 | Xavier | 48
| 1945-46 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 47 | Xavier | 33
| January 4, 1947 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 35 | Xavier | 34
| February 13, 1947 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 55 | Xavier | 75
| February 10, 1948 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 52 | Xavier | 72
| February 24, 1948 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 32 | Xavier | 57
| February 15, 1949 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 48 | Xavier | 66
| February 27, 1949 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 44 | Xavier | 49
| January 22, 1950 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 65 | Xavier | 55
| February 13, 1950 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 59 | Xavier | 42
| March 2, 1950 | [[Cleveland|Cleveland, OH]] | Dayton | 59 | Xavier | 51
| February 11, 1951 | Cincinnati, OH | No. 18 Dayton | 63 | Xavier | 57
| March 3, 1951 | Dayton, OH | No. 14 Dayton | 77 | Xavier | 53
| January 27, 1952 | Dayton, OH | No. 16 Dayton | 67 | Xavier | 60
| February 24, 1952 | Cincinnati, OH | No. 11 Dayton | 82 | Xavier | 80
| January 18, 1953 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 68 | Xavier | 70
| February 22, 1953 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 81 | Xavier | 63
| January 24, 1954 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 66 | Xavier | 58
| February 21, 1954 | Cincinnati, OH | No. 17 Dayton | 81 | Xavier | 63
| January 30, 1955 | Cincinnati, OH | No. 15 Dayton | 91 | Xavier | 80
| February 20, 1955 | Dayton, OH | No. 13 Dayton | 71 | Xavier | 60
| January 21, 1956 | Dayton, OH | No. 2 Dayton | 81 | Xavier | 73
| February 19, 1956 | Cincinnati, OH | No. 2 Dayton | 85 | Xavier | 75
| [[1956 National Invitation Tournament|March 20, 1956]]<sup>A</sup> | [[New York City|New York, NY]] | No. 3 Dayton | 72 | Xavier | 68
| January 13, 1957 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 61 | Xavier | 59
| February 20, 1957 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 65 | Xavier | 68
| January 29, 1958| Dayton, OH | No. 16 Dayton | 74 | Xavier | 59
| February 16, 1958 | Cincinnati, OH | No. 14 Dayton | 64 | Xavier | 58
| [[1956 National Invitation Tournament|March 22, 1958]]<sup>B</sup> | New York, NY | No. 11 Dayton | 74<sup>OT</sup> | Xavier | 78
| January 14, 1959| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 60 | Xavier | 56
| March 8, 1959| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 69 | Xavier | 71
| January 6, 1960| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 54 | Xavier | 51
| February 24, 1960| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 91 | Xavier | 82
| January 28, 1961| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 87 | Xavier | 64
| February 22, 1961| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 94 | Xavier | 71
| January 3, 1962| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 64 | Xavier | 48
| February 7, 1962| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 71 | Xavier | 72
| January 3, 1963| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 69 | Xavier | 64
| February 6, 1963| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 79 | Xavier | 63
| January 4, 1964| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 94 | Xavier | 103
| February 1, 1964| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 81 | Xavier | 82
| January 4, 1965| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 83 | Xavier | 79
| February 3, 1965| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 112 | Xavier | 81
| January 3, 1966| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 105 | Xavier | 79
| February 9, 1966| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 76 | Xavier | 73
| January 4, 1967| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 75 | Xavier | 72
| February 8, 1967| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 70 | Xavier | 66
| January 3, 1968| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 83 | Xavier | 80
| February 7, 1968| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 64 | Xavier | 56
| January 4, 1969| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 55 | Xavier | 59
| January 27, 1969| Dayton, OH | No. 20 Dayton | 72 | Xavier | 64
| January 3, 1970| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 94 | Xavier | 76
| February 4, 1970| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 90 | Xavier | 78
| February 15, 1971| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 70 | Xavier | 50
| February 27, 1971| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 82 | Xavier | 76
| December 12, 1971| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 69 | Xavier | 66
| February 5, 1972| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 66 | Xavier | 77
| January 6, 1973| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 98 | Xavier | 82
| March 3, 1973| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 87 | Xavier | 81
| January 9, 1974| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 62 | Xavier | 52
| February 23, 1974| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 86 | Xavier | 55
| December 7, 1974| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 75 | Xavier | 66
| February 19, 1975| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 78 | Xavier | 67
| January 3, 1976| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 80 | Xavier | 71
| February 28, 1976| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 77 | Xavier | 75
| January 8, 1977| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 75 | Xavier | 59
| March 3, 1977| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 86 | Xavier | 48
| January 7, 1978| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 56 | Xavier | 58
| February 28, 1978| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 90 | Xavier | 62
| December 30, 1978| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 67 | Xavier | 66
| February 10, 1979| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 75 | Xavier | 54
| January 19, 1980| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 59 | Xavier | 73
| February 26, 1980| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 73 | Xavier | 60
| January 10, 1981| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 74 | Xavier | 72
| February 22, 1981| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 73 | Xavier | 64
| December 12, 1981| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 62 | Xavier | 61
| December 11, 1982| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 63 | Xavier | 53
| February 29, 1984| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 61 | Xavier | 72
| March 3, 1985| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 66 | Xavier | 56
| February 25, 1986| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 78 | Xavier | 93
| December 27, 1986| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 69 | Xavier | 65
| February 27, 1988| Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 73 | Xavier | 86
| February 4, 1989| Dayton, OH | Dayton | 78 | Xavier | 82
| March 4, 1989 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 78 | Xavier | 83
| February 3, 1990 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 81 | No. 23 Xavier | 88
| March 3, 1990 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 111 | No. 19 Xavier | 108
| [[Horizon League men's basketball tournament|March 10, 1990]]<sup>C</sup> | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 98 | No. 24 Xavier | 89
| February 17, 1991 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 83 | Xavier | 79
| March 2, 1991 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 79 | Xavier | 102
| [[Horizon League men's basketball tournament|March 8, 1991]]<sup>D</sup> | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 71 | Xavier | 90
| January 21, 1992 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 69 | Xavier | 77
| February 29, 1992 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 56 | Xavier | 72
| January 16, 1993 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 58 | Xavier | 85
| February 13, 1993 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 46 | Xavier | 53
| January 12, 1994 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 46 | No. 25 Xavier | 57
| January 24, 1994 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 62 | Xavier | 88
| December 19, 1994 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 73 | Xavier | 99
| January 27, 1996 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 61 | Xavier | 55
| February 20, 1996 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 95 | Xavier | 102
| January 7, 1997 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 98 | No. 12 Xavier | 91
| February 12, 1997 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 53 | No. 19 Xavier | 79
| January 24, 1998 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 93 | No. 19 Xavier | 82
| March 1, 1998 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 84 | Xavier | 89
| January 30, 1999 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 91 | Xavier | 86
| February 24, 1999 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 62 | Xavier | 90
| January 11, 2000 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 76 | Xavier | 72
| February 2, 2000 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 64<sup>OT</sup> | Xavier | 65
| January 30, 2001 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 72 | Xavier | 82
| March 4, 2001 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 65 | No. 25 Xavier | 62
| January 5, 2002 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 59 | Xavier | 66
| January 26, 2002 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 59 | Xavier | 75
| [[2002 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|March 8, 2002]]<sup>E</sup> | [[Philadelphia|Philadelphia, PA]] | Dayton | 59 | No. 24 Xavier | 66
| February 8, 2003 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 77 | No. 20 Xavier | 85
| February 22, 2003 | Dayton, OH | No. 25 Dayton | 72 | No. 14 Xavier | 73
| January 31, 2004 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 74 | Xavier | 67
| February 21, 2004 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 60 | Xavier | 67
| [[2004 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|March 13, 2004]]<sup>F</sup> | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 49 | Xavier | 58
| February 19, 2005 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 59 | Xavier | 55
| March 5, 2005 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 65 | Xavier | 74
| January 28, 2006 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 55 | Xavier | 60
| February 21, 2006 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 66 | Xavier | 62
| January 27, 2007 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 67 | Xavier | 83
| February 24, 2007 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 67 | Xavier | 75
| [[2007 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|March 8, 2007]]<sup>G</sup> | [[Atlantic City, New Jersey|Atlantic City, NJ]] | Dayton | 51 | Xavier | 72
| January 24, 2008 | Cincinnati, OH | No. 16 Dayton | 43 | No. 23 Xavier | 69
| February 24, 2008 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 51 | No. 10 Xavier | 57
| [[2008 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|March 8, 2008]]<sup>H</sup> | Atlantic City, NJ | Dayton | 65 | No. 10 Xavier | 74
| February 11, 2009 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 71 | No. 14 Xavier | 58
| March 5, 2009 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 59 | No. 17 Xavier | 76
| January 16, 2010 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 74 | Xavier | 78
| February 6, 2010 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 90 | Xavier | 65
| [[2010 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|March 12, 2010]]<sup>I</sup> | Atlantic City, NJ | Dayton | 73 | No. 24 Xavier | 78
| January 15, 2011 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 76 | Xavier | 81
| February 27, 2011 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 62 | No. 25 Xavier | 66
| [[2011 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|March 11, 2011]]<sup>J</sup> | Atlantic City, NJ | Dayton | 68 | No. 18 Xavier | 67
| January 21, 2012 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 87 | Xavier | 72
| February 18, 2012 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 83<sup>OT</sup> | Xavier | 86
| [[2012 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|March 9, 2012]]<sup>K</sup> | Atlantic City, NJ | Dayton | 69 | Xavier | 70
| January 30, 2013 | Cincinnati, OH | Dayton | 61 | Xavier | 66
| February 16, 2013 | Dayton, OH | Dayton | 70 | Xavier | 59
| [[Orlando Invitational#2015 bracket|November 29, 2015]]<sup>L</sup> | [[Bay Lake, Florida|Bay Lake, FL]]| Dayton | 61 | No. 23 Xavier | 90
}}

Source<ref>{{cite web |title=2018-19 Men's Basketball Guide |url=https://s3.amazonaws.com/sidearm.sites/goxavier.com/documents/2018/12/28/115_172_Records_2018.pdf |website=[[Amazon Web Services]] |publisher=Xavier Athletics |accessdate=14 May 2020}}</ref>

=== Notes ===
<sup>A</sup>[[1956 National Invitation Tournament|1956 NIT Quarterfinals]]<br />
<sup>B</sup>[[1958 National Invitation Tournament|1958 NIT Finals]]<br />
<sup>C</sup>[[Horizon League men's basketball tournament|1990 Midwestern Collegiate Conference tournament]]<br />
<sup>D</sup>[[Horizon League men's basketball tournament|1992 Midwestern Collegiate Conference tournament]]<br />
<sup>E</sup>[[2002 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|2002 Atlantic 10 tournament]]<br />
<sup>F</sup>[[2004 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|2004 Atlantic 10 tournament]]<br />
<sup>G</sup>[[2007 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|2007 Atlantic 10 tournament]]<br />
<sup>H</sup>[[2008 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|2008 Atlantic 10 tournament]]<br />
<sup>I</sup>[[2010 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|2010 Atlantic 10 tournament]]<br />
<sup>J</sup>[[2011 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|2011 Atlantic 10 tournament]]<br />
<sup>K</sup>[[2012 Atlantic 10 men's basketball tournament|2012 Atlantic 10 tournament]]<br />
<sup>L</sup>[[Orlando Invitational#2015 bracket|2015 Advocare Invitational]]

===Game Most Valuable Players===
{| class="wikitable"
!Date
!Most Valuable Player
!colspan=2|Team
|-
| Jan 10, 1981 || Mike Kanieski||Dayton
|-
| Feb 22, 1981 || Mike Kanieski||Dayton 
|- 
| Dec 12, 1981 || Kevin Conrad||Dayton 
|- 
| Dec 11, 1982 || [[Roosevelt Chapman]]||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 29, 1984 || Victor Fleming||Xavier 
|- 
| Mar 3, 1985 || [[Anthony Grant (basketball)|Anthony Grant]]||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 25, 1986 || Walt McBride||Xavier 
|- 
| Dec 27, 1986 || Anthony Corbitt||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 27, 1988 || [[Stan Kimbrough]]||Xavier 
|- 
| Feb 4, 1989 || Stan Kimbrough||Xavier 
|- 
| Mar 4, 1989 || Noland Robinson||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 3, 1990 || Jamal Walker||Xavier 
|- 
| Mar 3, 1990 || [[Negele Knight]]||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 17, 1991 || Chip Jones||Dayton 
|- 
| Mar 2, 1991 || Jamal Walker||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 21, 1992 || [[Aaron Williams (basketball)|Aaron Williams]]||Xavier 
|- 
| Feb 29, 1992 || Jamie Gladden||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 16, 1993 || [[Brian Grant]]||Xavier 
|- 
| Feb 13, 1993 || Mark Poynter||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 12, 1994 || Steve Gentry||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 29, 1994 || Jeff Massey||Xavier 
|- 
| Dec 19, 1994 || [[Larry Sykes]]||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 27, 1996 || Rodney Horton||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 20, 1996 || Gary Lumpkin||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 7, 1997 || Darnell Hoskins||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 12, 1997 || [[Torraye Braggs]]||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 24, 1998 || [[Ryan Perryman]]||Dayton 
|- 
| Mar 1, 1998 || Torraye Braggs||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 30, 1999 || Coby Turner||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 24, 1999 || Lenny Brown||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 11, 2000 || David Morris||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 2, 2000 || Alvin Brown||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 30, 2001 || [[David West (basketball)|David West]]||Xavier 
|- 
| Mar 4, 2001 || Yuanta Holland||Dayton 
|- 
| Jan 5, 2002 || [[Romain Sato]]||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 26, 2002 || [[Lionel Chalmers]]||Xavier 
|- 
| Feb 8, 2003 || David West||Xavier 
|- 
| Feb 22, 2003 || David West||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 31, 2004 || Ramod Marshall||Dayton 
|- 
| Feb 21, 2004 || Lionel Chalmers||Xavier 
|- 
| Feb 19, 2005 || Marques Bennett||Dayton 
|- 
| Mar 5, 2005 || Will Caudle||Xavier 
|- 
| Jan 28, 2006 || Brian Thornton||Xavier 
|- 
| Feb 21, 2006 || Norman Plummer||Dayton 
|- 
| Jan 27, 2007 || [[Justin Doellman]]||Xavier 
|- 
| Feb 24, 2007 || Drew Lavender||Xavier
|- 
| Jan 24, 2008 || [[Stanley Burrell (basketball)|Stanley Burrell]]||Xavier
|- 
| Feb 24, 2008 || [[Josh Duncan]]||Xavier
|- 
| Feb 11, 2009 || [[Chris Wright (basketball, born 1988)|Chris Wright]]||Dayton
|- 
| Mar 5, 2009 || Dante' Jackson||Xavier
|- 
| Jan 15, 2010 || [[Jordan Crawford]]||Xavier
|- 
| Feb 6, 2010 || Chris Wright||Dayton
|- 
| Jan 15, 2011 || [[Tu Holloway]]||Xavier
|- 
| Feb 27, 2011 || Tu Holloway||Xavier
|- 
| Jan 21, 2012 || [[Kevin Dillard]]||Dayton
|- 
| Feb 18, 2012 || Tu Holloway||Xavier
|- 
| Jan 31, 2013 || Dee Davis||Xavier
|- 
| Feb 15, 2013 || Kevin Dillard||Dayton
|}

==References==
{{Reflist}}

{{Dayton Flyers men's basketball navbox}}
{{Xavier Musketeers men's basketball navbox}}
{{Atlantic 10 Conference rivalry navbox}}
{{Big East Conference men's basketball rivalries navbox}}

{{DEFAULTSORT:Blackburn McCafferty Trophy}}
[[Category:College basketball rivalry trophies in the United States]]
[[Category:Dayton Flyers men's basketball]]
[[Category:Xavier Musketeers men's basketball]]